4 ms·
Lawyers in Musk pay case seek fee of $6B in Tesla stock
- two_handfuls 3y agoSuch a weird world. These numbers are so absurd, I can’t even imagine it.
- penjelly 3y agoit feels perverse that their pay could be inversely proportional to how much they prevent other people from getting.
- sp332 3y agoThey argued, successfully, that Musk mislead the board when they approved his payout. They are being paid by Tesla for prptecting Tesla's money. For every dollar they are asking for, they saved shareholders almost 9 dolars.
- DoesntMatter22 3y agoExcept in reality they are going to vote on this again and musk is likely going to get a similar amount of money. I've yet to see any actual shareholders say they had an issue with him being paid. If this judge actually gives them 5 billion its going to nuke the future of Delaware as a business state. What's happening is unprecedented.
- hnburnsy 3y agoExactly, what CEO is going to want to incorporate in a state where judges can nuke your pay package and then force your company to pay for the nuking?
- DoesntMatter22 3y agoI think the threat isn't even pay packages but the fact that truly spurious litigation could set companies back billions. It's not worth the risk. Some will stay but many will migrate out
- jeffreportmill1 3y agoI’m an actual shareholder, and I was furious over the 50B compensation package. Musk was already an investor with billions of dollars of incentive to do a good job. It was nothing short of fraud to pack the board with friends and relatives and push through a CEO pay package orders of magnitude greater than the already exorbitant US CEO pay. He is greedy, selfish and criminally insane. I’m not even sure he works at Tesla anymore. Seems more preoccupied with Twitter and rockets and robots and drilling holes and how he didn’t get his share of the AI revolution. He’s a gambling addict - if you sent 1000 gamblers into a casino with 1000 dollars, a dozen would come out with 1 million. One of them would be name Elon. He’s a lucky psychopath, not a misunderstood genius.
- leereeves 3y agoWhere do you think Tesla stock would be without Musk? Would it have gained over $500B in value over the last 6 years? > if you sent 1000 gamblers into a casino with 1000 dollars, a dozen would come out with 1 million. No. The odds of winning a 1000x return in a casino would be less than 1 in 1000, and you'd be lucky if one of them came out with a million (as the others lost it all).
- browningstreet 3y agoFarther ahead. Musk has messed up so much it’s unbelievable. He promised $25K cars and FSD and instead got distracted by Twitter and instead shipped an overpriced truck. He’s suing OpenAI for going off-mission but that’s also exactly what he’s done. He also keeps messing with the residual value of the cars people bought and I, for one, love my Model Y but would never buy anything from Musk again. That said, I would also not buy any EV that connects to any other charging network, so Tesla the company can build great stuff but he keeps the company off-kilter.
- leereeves 3y agoMusk makes big bets. 1000x bets, as GGP said. You can't expect all of them to work out. If you ask for a CEO who would keep the company on a steady course, you'll get a CEO who doesn't make those bets. Actually it might be time now for Tesla to switch to that CEO. It's hard to imagine another 1000x bet paying off for Tesla from its current value. But that wasn't the case in 2018 when this pay package was decided, when Tesla was valued at only $50B (and that value was already factoring in high growth expectations).
- cute_boi 3y agoHow can board be misled by elon musk. The board took action on behalf of their own self interest. And, if there is voting again I am sure Elon will win.
- jeffreportmill1 3y agoMisled? They were self dealing. The board returned 750M of stolen funds just to avoid prosecution. Friends and relatives of Elon, awarding themselves billions because they were guarding the vault and they could.
- Arnt 3y agoAre they asking for actual money, or best-case money? It seems like the former from the text in the article, but that's hard to believe. I was of the impression that the case was about contingency payout. If Tesla stock appreciates by 600% in the next few years, then Tesla has to pay Elon Musk a fantastic amount. 600% if kind of fantastic too. If the lawyers are asking for conditional reimbursement that can be that large in the same fantastic circumstances then I don't see what's wrong about it.
- neom 3y agoTwo things that made me giggle: "Still, the lawyers described the nearly $6 billion in shares as “conservative” under Delaware law, which they said entitles them to 33% of the 'quantifiable conferred benefit.' - “Nevertheless, in an effort to be conservative, Plaintiff’s Counsel does not seek the 33%” warranted by previous cases, they wrote. " - "The lawyers wrote that, throughout the history of the case, they collectively logged 19,499.95 hours — meaning that a nearly $6 billion award would equal a per-hour rate of $305,550. They argued, though, that the hours worked was of secondary importance, if it was worth considering at all. " A nice and conservative $300k an hour.
- neom 3y agoHere's another fun thing (can't edit my comment) - I decided to go look at who exactly are these lawyers, It's a collection of lawyers across 3 firms (as is common in a case this large), I went and looked at the firms they used, and if you add up every single lawyer at all 3 firms, it's 91 lawyers total (including associate lawyers - two of the firms are tiny and specialized). If they get it, that would be what... 65 million per lawyer in all the firms involved... not a bad exit ;)
- leereeves 3y agoHere's another: the best case value of Musk's "unconscionable" pay package (in the form of conditional stock grants) at the time it was offered was about $5B, roughly the same amount the lawyers are asking for. Now they argue that the amount "would be justified given how much value they delivered to Tesla shareholders"! That sounds like a great argument for paying Musk, who delivered 10x the value. And another hilarious bit: “Delaware seeks to incentivize, not punish, efficient litigation.” Litigation, but not business.
- bradley13 3y agoMusk's pay increments were tied to performance milestones. Which he achieved. It really is not the court's role to say the compensation was excessive. This will likely be overturned on appeal. The hypocrisy of the lawyers to expect pay of $300k/hour is breathtaking.
- jjeaff 3y agoIt definitely is the court's place to rule on excessive compensation packages. Musk and the board have fiduciary responsibilities to the other shareholders. The other shareholders can sue if they believe they are being stolen from. The court found that there had been no real process to decide if that much compensation was in the best interest of the shareholders because it seems they are all just Musk puppets.
- leereeves 3y agoMusk more than met his fiduciary responsibilities when he increased the stock value tenfold. In what world is that not in the best interest of the shareholders? And wasn't the board elected by the shareholders? It seems likely that the shareholders supported Musk so they chose a board that also supported him. What's wrong with that? (Unless Musk somehow selected the board without shareholder approval, which I agree would be wrong.)
- aw1621107 3y ago> Musk more than met his fiduciary responsibilities when he increased the stock value tenfold. The important part is not the absolute benefit, but the proportion of benefit to cost. Elon's pay package was 12% of total outstanding shares at some point in time; would he/the board have still met his fiduciary responsibilities if the pay package were 15% of total outstanding shares? 20%? 50%? 100%? 200%? Higher? And what about the other direction? Wouldn't shareholders have benefited even more if they had received the same increase in shareholder price but only giving Musk 11% of outstanding shares? What about 10%? 8%? 5%? 2%? 0%? More to the point, there's some limit to how many shares could be granted to Elon, as at some point the dilution is too severe even if the share price skyrocketed the same way. And on the other side, there might be a point where the offered compensation is too low, so you may not see a benefit. The issue was that there was no effort to find the best cost/benefit ratio (or even a good cost/benefit ratio) for the shareholders, and since the deal was assumed to be unfair and the burden of proof was on Elon/Tesla to prove their price was fair, that results in the package being rescinded. > And wasn't the board elected by the shareholders? Sure, but that doesn't necessarily mean the board has the shareholders' best interests in mind for every action they take. As an example, the board composition was mostly the same during the SolarCity acquisition as when negotiating the 2018 compensation plan, but the board behaved very differently during the acquisition (e.g., pushing back on Elon's asks), so they were deemed to be sufficiently independent for that transaction. > What's wrong with that? It works as long as "supporting Elon" happens to be what works in the shareholders' interest, but there's no reason the two have to be the same thing.
- stevespang 3y ago[dead]