7 ms·
Deploying fiber in the home
- fbdab103 3y agoWell, I enjoyed the justification for the glorious amounts of over-engineering involved at nearly every step.
- jajko 3y agoI am thinking hard about any use case for mortals (so not pro gamers, not folks running some automated trading from their home or whatever corner case there is) that can't be covered by latest wifi. Even with all the interference everybody talks about yet I struggle to see it happening for us. And there is always next version just behind the corner, ie v7 looks very nice on paper. I go the opposite direction, will eventually rip out/cover all the network cable outlets previous owner put in in various rooms.
- Havoc 3y agoMaybe something like a k8s cluster? Those seem to be more stable with reliable low latency links
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Symbiote 3y agoIn places where homes are built from brick, stone or concrete it can be good to have a wired connection. I don't see much benefit to fibre though. Copper cables and connectors are more durable. If you already have cables, isn't it best to keep them? Connecting the TV to a network socket beats fiddling with the WiFi.
- lmz 3y agoMainstream copper connections can't really go above 10Gbps. Also 10GBASE-T runs hot. If you think you will ever need more speed then just running some fibre makes sense - just a transceiver upgrade required in the future for higher speeds.
- kjs3 3y agoI remember when it was "mainstream copper connections can't really go above 100Mbps" and we ran fiber. Not that there isn't some physical limit to how much data you can reliably push down 4 pairs of copper (that sort of physics isn't my bag), I just wouldn't bet against running 100G over Cat13++ or whatever standard emerges down the road. But, yeah, fiber is always gonna be more 'future proof' and damn my 10G gbics do get annoyingly hot.
- lmz 3y agoYou can get a good idea of the current state of the art in pushing bits over copper in internal PCIe cables. Those are short, thick, and pricy and the connections even within a single chassis often needs a retimer / redriver chip [0] to recover signal integrity. [0]: https://www.asteralabs.com/smart-retimers/pci-express-retimers-vs-redrivers-an-eye-popping-difference/ https://www.asteralabs.com/smart-retimers/pci-express-retime...
- kjs3 3y agoThat's some pretty cool tech, but 'State of the art' wasn't really what I was talking about. I mean at some point, there's likely a physical limit to how many bits per second that can be pushed down an 4-pair copper networking cable of current girth no matter how clever we get. My bet is that it's north of 100G; a beer to the winner.
- Aurornis 3y ago> I am thinking hard about any use case for mortals (so not pro gamers, not folks running some automated trading from their home or whatever corner case there is) that can't be covered by latest wifi. Wired 10G connections are vastly superior for file transfer. It's not even close. Even 1G wired connections feel substantially snappier for remote desktop use than a high-speed WiFi connection 10ft away, in my experience. But for browsing the internet and gaming? WiFi is great.
- ClumsyPilot 3y agoWe have 2.5 gig Ethernet, and even 5 gig - that’s probably close enough
- thworp 3y agoDepends what you're accessing. A top of the line SSD can easily reach speeds of 5 GB/s in the real world, for which you'd need 50GbE for full saturation.
- dietr1ch 3y agoAny real-time game can break badly over WiFi. No one wants packet loss because the microwave is on.
- klysm 3y agoWiFi is terrible for any game that is latency sensitive
- gurchik 3y agoI've been surprised by how many random devices experience terrible wifi interference. I just bought a new Mac Mini that experiences a ton of interference, sometimes going offline completely. I can browse the web fine but I can't screen share on Zoom or even speak in Discord without noticeable lag multiple times a minute. It's not in some Faraday cage or anything, it's just sitting on my desk not 3 feet from my Ubiquiti access point. But I do have a USB dongle plugged into it which I have heard can cause a lot of interference. My phone, even when sitting on top of the Mac, gets a solid 800 mbits down. It's silly to need an ethernet cable for 3 feet of distance from my switch but here we are.
- huppeldepup 3y agoOn my 2017 macbook pro, the wifi drops completely when I plug in a usb3 external hard disk. The connection is still up but data doesn’t get through. And because the connection remains I have to manually switch to 5.5GHz
- massysett 3y agoI had bad latency issues on WiFi with wireless. It made video calls bad. The problem went away completely with a MoCA wired connection. The fact that the computer in question is an ancient PC running Windows 10 on some old WiFi standard surely does not help. Probably a new computer would fare better on WiFi. But going wired allowed me to keep using ancient hardware that is practically free. A better PC would have cost hundreds of dollars more.
- kjs3 3y agoWiFi is fundamentally shared media. If you're in a relatively populated area and competing with a ton of neighbors all streaming 4k and playing CoD, there comes a point where no amount of new computer will make it faster.
- creshal 3y agoIf you have a home built out of proper materials, it'll need a wifi AP in every other room for coverage, and those still need uplinks.
- jajko 3y agoNo it doesn't. Concrete floor and structural walls, rest is some form of bricks, typical European modern building (Switzerland), absolutely good enough wifi signal in all rooms, on 2 storeys, no repeater or anyhow enhancing the reach. Router is in a far corner of whole structure, as far as possible from being in the center. This is just basic phone company wifi router provided to us. It works well with all laptops, at least 20 different phones based on various visitors, desktop with some basic external wifi antenna (this one is farthest, 11m and 1 wall). But we don't have any 'smart' crap in our house, no zigby stuff, no fridges with tablets in front or similar. Interesting how many downvotes this triggered on all of my comments on HN that could still be downvoted.
- thworp 3y agoAccessing a NAS at decent speeds. Even for a single 7.2k rpm drive that's rated at 120 MB/s, a gigabit link speed is a bottleneck (120 MB/s = 960 Mbit, add protocol overhead and you're over 1 Gigabit). If you have any kind of array (zfs, raid ...) of drives you need more speed again. If you have an SSD cache (an option even in Consumer NAS now) not having a multi-Gbit/s link is essentially a waste. Of course you can send 10GbE over copper, but the needed amplification is a major heat source. So if you're running cables anyway you might as well run fiber and be prepared for 100GbE.
- executesorder66 3y agoHere is a use case that almost any office worker encounters, and measurements to show that a wired connection is better : https://www.jefftk.com/p/ethernet-is-worth-it-for-video-calls https://www.jefftk.com/p/ethernet-is-worth-it-for-video-call... Got any measurements to the contrary?
- jsjohnst 3y ago> I am thinking hard about any use case for mortals … that can't be covered by latest wifi. My home WiFi network is running Enterprise grade Aruba hardware using latest WiFi spec gear, where I did intelligent zone planning with no rooms not near max RSSI for devices, proper handoffs between APs, and 2.5GbE or faster backhauls to the controller, yet can still get SIGNIFICANTLY faster access to my NAS over even gigabit Ethernet. Hell, I can’t even consistently have my internet connection be the bottleneck over WiFi. So yes, “mere mortals” can saturate a consumer grade wifi ap quite easily, using latest specs or not.
- fleventynine 3y agoDuring a renovation, I ran 6-strand single-mode fiber to various locations in my home. I found the termination process (using an inexpensive Chinese fusion splicer) to be somewhat of a pain, especially for connections behind wall jacks rather than in a proper splicing cabinet. What I found worked best was to buy a bunch of 50 meter pre-terminated plenum-rated cables and cut them in half. I'd plug the pre-terminated ends into the wall-jack coupler, then weave the cut end through the walls back to the splicing cabinet, where I'd leave several turns of slack and fusion splice the pigtail which I plugged into the patch panel.
- michaelt 3y ago> using an inexpensive Chinese fusion splicer How inexpensive are we talking here? $30? $100? $300? $1000?
- navaati 3y ago500$ apparently: https://www.alibaba.com/showroom/cheap-fusion-splicer.html https://www.alibaba.com/showroom/cheap-fusion-splicer.html. Not too bad, way less than what I imagined !
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- fleventynine 3y agoI think I paid $800 for a brand new SignalFire AI-8, but that was 5 years ago. Compared to the $9,000 Fujikura units used by pros, it was inexpensive :)
- smartbit 3y agoI did an half hour ‘training’ with this $/€950 https://www.amazon.com/dp/B09ZL6KGQW/ https://www.amazon.com/dp/B09ZL6KGQW/ https://elfcams.com/en/product/3881 https://elfcams.com/en/product/3881. It was used by students to setup internet on campus dormitories and they were satisfied with it.
- 3y ago
- Chris2048 3y agoIs there a justification for this? What are the chances your CAT cable is a bottleneck to network speeds?
- bombcar 3y agoRunning fiber will get you above 10Gb if you need that, and for longer. It also completely removes certain electrical grounding issues, and makes connecting separate buildings easier (there are requirements for wires connecting different buildings, like a house and a detached garage; most people ignore these requirements).
- chrisBob 3y agoI am about to put in a garage 300' from my house. I will already have a trench for power and water. What kind of network cable can/should I drop in the same trench?
- LorenDB 3y ago300 ft. is long enough that fiber will be the better choice if only to reduce signal loss. CAT6 has a maximum length of 328 ft., so while it would work, you're going to have a faster, more reliable connection all around with fiber.
- bombcar 3y ago300 feet is at or beyond the edge of copper CAT cables, I'd run multimode fiber of the appropriate type (run a few to be safe?) - fiber doesn't care about power interference. NOTE: See comments - I ran multimode because that's what the connectors in the off-lease hardware I had came with. Seems single mode is better in general. https://www.lanshack.com https://www.lanshack.com or similar should have something in the $400 range. You could be super cool and run conduit, but that itself has a cost (spooled conduit is what I'd do, but costly)
- fleventynine 3y agoMulti-mode standards change too frequently, and it's not really much cheaper. Prefer single-mode.
- riskable 3y agoI just spent a few hours in my attic running Cat 6 but before I did that I actually did some research to figure out what it would take to run fiber instead: Too much. Not way too much. Just "too much" compared to cheap cat 6 (of which I already had a spool and tools; sunk costs and all that). In theory, modern fiber is fantastic! You no longer need incredibly expensive tools and the cable itself isn't really any more expensive than Cat 8 (the current standard you should aim for if you don't already have a spool of Cat 6). It's also much more flexible than in the past and less fragile. There's still some big issues making it problematic for DIY home installation... You gotta be careful and thoughtful. With something like Cat 6 or Cat 8 it's stiff enough that you can just push it through from above/below, go into an attic/crawl space and just tug on it. Yank that sucker! If it gets caught, push it back and yank again... It'll probably be fine! Even if it's not (you pulled too hard on a loop and kinked it), you can always just cut off that end of the cable or use a coupler and you won't lose much other than your time. Fiber isn't like that: You need to attach it to something like a solid metal cable snake while you fish it through a tight spot otherwise there's a good chance it can get caught and kink/break. Forget pushing it through from below something! It's just too floppy. You also shouldn't let it dangle! Be very careful and use proper screw-in or nail-in wall fasteners. Very few things accept the various fiber cable connectors/standards. The modern solution to that is to wire your home switch-to-switch, using fiber as the back end connection between them. You buy switches with SFP/SFP+ ports and use fiber SFP adapters with your connector/standard of choice. This isn't really a problem per-se but it means that instead of "just" having a keystone outlet on the wall near the device-to-be-connected you'll have a little switch there and your device(s) will connect to that. Aside: SFP is fantastic! It's absolutely awesome that even cheap, consumer switches have SFP ports now. Just bought a 2.5GBit ethernet switch for $50 the other day that had 4 2.5Gbit ports and 2 10GBit-capable SFP ports :thumbsup: It's way too easy to break your fiber cable when you need to run something else alongside it. For this reason, when you're running your cables make sure you drill separate holes for all your fiber runs. Don't just shove it through the hole that already has your home's coaxial cables and other wires (e.g. phone, alarm, smoke detector wires). In fact, go the extra mile and install a grommet in any holes you drill (or just use some PVC/PEX/PTFE pipe/hose with couplers to prevent it from coming out) and WRITE WITH A SHARPIE on or near it, "FIBER ONLY!". Make it glaringly obvious that it's a bad idea to try running anything other than fiber through that hole. Anecdote: A friend of mine ran fiber through their attic and an air conditioning repair technician stepped on it and broke it. Keep those wires up high and out of the way of possible accidents like that.
- duxup 3y agoI like this as great hobby project. As a former network engineer ... at home I've just gone with wi-fi. A nice mesh system isn't very costly and depending on your situation IMO is the most bag for the buck and a whole lot less hassle. Good mesh systems are crazy fast / capable now, I'm not sure I'd see any real performance increase if I bothered with rewiring the house.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- SkyPuncher 3y agoThe only time I curse my mesh network is when I’m gaming. I get excess jitter and latency spikes. For everything else, mesh is amazing
- duxup 3y agoThat’s interesting, I haven’t seen that at all personally. But Wi-Fi reliability and performance is very much dependent on the environment you are in.
- johncalvinyoung 3y agoAgreed on that. A friend of mine was recently renovating his house on a budget, and I pushed him really hard to put in ethernet. Somewhere on our third discussion, I realized: - he lives on a 5acre tract in the absolute middle of nowhere. He can see other houses from his, but not many--and subdivision of those properties is prohibited. - neither he nor his family are big gamers or streamers - the best internet service he can get is Starlink, by a significant margin. In a low-noise environment like that, wi-fi was going to work fantastically well for all his anticipated uses and then some. There was literally no point in installing Ethernet for him, while I've been longing for ethernet for years.
- bradgessler 3y agoPoE wired access points are the next best thing if you’re not afraid to run some Ethernet cable, which is why I run in my home.
- kkfx 3y agoWell... Fiber means active apparatus that do last far less than copper, for normally sized homes they might be interesting if you have enough ground around the home to need fiber links to the portal or some perimeter cams and sensors, but inside a home IMVHO sound a nice things but not worth the price...
- zamadatix 3y agoRespect for referring to layer 1 of the TCP/IP model instead of the OSI model. Functionally the same usage at that layer but the TCP/IP model is both simpler and almost always what people actually use when they talk about OSI layers.
- wkat4242 3y ago> Unlike copper Ethernet cables, which are very bulky, warm up, [...] Ummmm warm up?? You're really using it wrong :) Unless you try to really pump a lot of PoE++ power over totally inadequate CCA perhaps (copper-clad aluminium rubbish), it really shouldn't warm up at all. The other drawbacks are true though. Ps never use CCA for PoE for anything but patch-length runs unless you like dealing with random brownouts. Unfortunately real copper cable is very hard to find these days.
- klysm 3y agoI had the same reaction lol, something is very wrong if your Ethernet cables have enough current going through them to heat up!
- thworp 3y agoSure, if everything is installed properly with proper cables you'll be fine. But if there is any damage the cable could get hot. With fibre you don't need to spend a single thought on fire safety. In my experience, if you go anywhere near max length on Cat6(a) and need SFP+ modules, those modules will get insanely hot and probably start dropping packets.
- DeathArrow 3y agoI have FTTH and I am in the process of installing fiber connections in all the rooms of my apartment. I am using single mode fiber with 2x fiber connections to each room. I am going to run them at 1 Gbps for now and upgrade to 10 Gbps in a few months when I 'I'll buy some better equipment. I don't need huge speeds for now, but I want something future proof and since I am renovating the apartment, it was a good occasion.