3 ms·
This article is wrong, or at least the headline and intro is wrong. You don't need a precise time source to make power grids possible. You don't need any time
by phire 3y ago
This article is wrong, or at least the headline and intro is wrong.
You don't need a precise time source to make power grids possible. You don't need any time source at all, as generator operators simply synchronise with the grid's current frequency (and phase) before throwing the switch that electrically connects the generator to the grid. And once the generators are connected, they are automatically locked to the exact same frequency and phase. It's not possible for them to fall out of phase without the electrical connection being broken (If you try to force a generator out of phase, it will draw more current trying to get back in phase and will eventually blow a fuse)
For engineering reasons, it's useful to keep the frequency within a few percent of a standard, but for most purposes, it doesn't matter if the grid is running at 58Hz, 60Hz or 62Hz and you can achieve way more accuracy with crude mechanical governor. Many simpler backup generators use nothing more than a mechanical governor to maintain their frequency.
The primary reason why power grids used accurate master clocks is actually the secondary reason that this article mentions: Automated time synchronisation.
This predates the days of modern quartz clocks. It was possible to make very precise mechanical clocks (especially for navigation use), but they were impractical and too expensive for every day use. The average clock or pocket watch would gain or lose several minutes per day and required constant manual adjustment. Loud bells ringing each hour would allow a town or small city to keep the same time, but different towns would be out of sync with each other.
There were various competing solutions at this time. Clocks would be synchronized over long distances with time signals transmitted over telegraph or radio. Paris actually had a network of pneumatic tubes that drove synchronised clocks driven with a pulse of air every minute: https://www.amusingplanet.com/2022/02/the-pneumatic-clocks-of-paris.html https://www.amusingplanet.com/2022/02/the-pneumatic-clocks-o...
But the power grid neatly solved this problem.
Not only did it distribute power, but it distributed a synchronised time signal across the entire nation. Your complicated mechanical wall clock could be replaced by a simple electric synchronous motor that drove the clock hands and it would keep perfect sync with every other clock on the same power grid.
All you needed to make this useful was a single master clock that kept the power grid running at exactly 60Hz (well, it actually drifts as load varies, but they deliberately vary it so there are exactly 5184000 pulses per day).
This time keeping service that power companies supplied as a secondary effect of their primary purpose was typically mandated by government regulations, as cheap and accurate synchronized time is a boost to the economy.
- jleahy 3y agoThat’s not correct. The frequency provides an indication of how much power is being drawn. If the frequency is low then generators supply more power to bring it back to 60 Hz. If there was not a well known fixed frequency it would be impossible to evenly distribute load over power stations. All generators have a %load vs frequency delta curve built into them which is precisely calibrated.
- applied_heat 3y agoI think the parent is more correct than you are? The frequency does not provide an indication of load. The frequency can be 60.00Hz with 20,000 MW load in Ontario or with 10,000MW. Changes in frequency provide a measure of changes in the balance between generation and load. The generator’s prime mover’s governor has a droop function set so that typically a 5% change in frequency will result in a 100% change in output. This is how most generators on the grid arrest changes in frequency, but they would not restore the frequency to 60Hz. The droop allows for a steady state frequency error. A handful of special generators are used to restore the frequency to 60Hz or balance the generation and load in an area. The precise frequency does not matter, if one generator thinks the frequency is 59.99 and another thinks it is 60.01 their outputs will only be a little higher and lower than their load setpoint. It does not matter if they share changes in load perfectly evenly, so long as generators on the system in bulk respond according to their capabilities.
- jleahy 3y agoThe point is that they need to be synchronised in order to respond to changes in load.
- applied_heat 3y agoYes, they use the frequency as a common signal to respond to changes in load, that is correct. With gps synchronized clocks and high speed waveform measurement we can see the propagation delay in the frequency across the country when there is a big event. Pretty neat!