3 ms·
The only thing I am sure of about copyright law, is that I don't fully understand it. Search engines, for example, necessarily read as much of the internet as
by ben_w 3y ago
The only thing I am sure of about copyright law, is that I don't fully understand it.
Search engines, for example, necessarily read as much of the internet as possible, in order to create an index, which is a derivative of the original content; when giving you results, many show snippets from those search results, so that users have an understanding of why the link is relevant to their query, which is definitely a copyright violation because Google lost (or settled?) on that exact issue with regard to news sites (and image results?).
Search engines are one category of AI. PageRank was a significant improvement over simple indexing, and personalised results are a significant improvement over pure PageRank (and Google's "moat" after Page's patent expired).
So the impression I have is that merely downloading a public page and putting into an algorithm isn't a violation by itself, while repeating even short clips of text verbatim totally is.
But things aren't static, they are rewritten to respond to the possibilities of the world. Is this going be accepted or not, going forwards, given what AI can now do?
I don't know.
I can see the two camps, but I can't foresee which will be the victor; and it won't necessarily be the same in all countries, given the balance of interests between creators and users isn't assured to be the same everywhere.
(And even that's assuming no good models trained on public domain or suitably licensed documents, even though there are already some such models).