4 ms·
There, you're doing it. It is all right for someone to be skeptical about any commonly held view, except when it's about sex with minors. In any discussion ab
by skrebbel 15y ago
There, you're doing it.
It is all right for someone to be skeptical about any commonly held view, except when it's about sex with minors.
In any discussion about any kind of sex with anyone under 18 whatsoever, if you're not 100% fully completely convincedly against it, then you're a bad person!!1
Why can't we just discuss this? Like we can discuss anything else? Especially in the US, where the norm appears to be that the KKK people and the Westboro Baptist nutcases are insane, but they should still be allowed to say what they think? Why is that ok with nazis and homo haters, but not for people who are merely skeptical about the current social norm wrt sex with minors?
It's this same attitude that allows governments to block half the internet, it's to seek out the child pornographers! What, you're against my law? Hey guys, this one here is in favour of child pornography!
Note: I completely share the common opinion that sex with minors is bad and that there are only very few edge cases to be found where it isn't (e.g. a sexually active couple, both 17 years old, one turns 18 and is now a peadophile? surely not). I just think that, like everything else in the world, if we're civilized, we'll allow the discussion.
- excuse-me 15y agoYou can get married at 16 in the UK (and most of europe) but if you took a picture of your wife giving birth you would be an evil child pornographer.
- linuxhansl 15y agoAnother data point: Sex at age 14 is legal in Germany (as long as both parties consent, and it does not involve a position of power - such as a teacher). Even sex at younger ages is not illegal per se, but parents can choose press civil charges (which they rarely do).
- raganwald 15y agoWell actually, I haven’t expressed an opinion about whether his words are acceptable or whether he’s a bad person, whatever that means. I have heard more than a few people taking me to task for wishing him good health on account of his words, and one of the reasons I posted this was to hear from people like you.
- skrebbel 15y agoGenuinely curious, because I don't think I understood this: what do you mean with "people like me"?
- raganwald 15y agoHN readers, especially those who might contruute another perspective. e.g. reg: Stallman is an important voice. detractor: He’s also advocating pedo. reg: He’s still an important voice. HN reader: Actually, he isn’t advocating pedo. <- new perspective
- skrebbel 15y agoah right! thanks for elaborating. in fact, i'm flattered! :-) also, my compliments for not turning this into a flamewar. in retrospect, it would seem that i was about to.
- skrebbel 15y agops. I really don't understand why people downvoted your comment.
- kprobst 15y ago"HackerNews isn't Reddit", until it is.
- mhartl 15y agoThanks. That's useful context.
- vacri 15y agoYou have, actually. Your statement can't even be charitably called 'loaded' - you explicitly state "he has advocated for truly awful practices?". Just throwing in the word 'allegations' doesn't mean that you're presenting a neutral point of view, as all shock jockeys are fully aware.
- DanBC 15y ago> I just think that, like everything else in the world, if we're civilized, we'll allow the discussion. He's not discussing it. He's just expressing an opinion. It's an opinion which appears to be based in ignorance. Without any reference to evidence it's just an opinion, and it's unfortunately close to the opinions given by paedophiles. People have spent many years trying to get the harm done by paedophiles taken seriously. It's frustrating when someone with a large audience blurts out the same ignorant nonsense that victims have been fighting for years. So, feel free to say that sexual abuse with children is not harmful - just make sure to read some of the extensive evidence before you do.
- sp332 15y agoActually in New Hampshire you can get married at age 14 (with parental consent) and up here I don't think it's illegal to have sex with anyone under 18 as long as you are within 1 or 2 years of them in age. I've heard in Florida it can be suddenly illegal though, birthdays must be awkward...
- icebraining 15y agoI don't know if RMS said it in this sense, but pedophilia is actually the sexual attraction to prepubescent children. Attraction to 17 year olds is ephebophilia.
- olalonde 15y agoYou can be skeptical about paedophilia just like you can be skeptical about evolution. The thing is that there is a lot of science and solid arguments why voluntary paedophilia is a bad idea.