5 ms·
In OoL, there will be steps. Some could be easy, others potentially very hard. By their very nature, the easier steps will be understood first. Understanding
by pfdietz 3y ago
In OoL, there will be steps. Some could be easy, others potentially very hard.
By their very nature, the easier steps will be understood first. Understanding them therefore doesn't say much about how the hard the overall process is.
An analogy is those collect-all-the-letters games one sometimes sees from grocery stores or fast food restaurants. If you collect all the letters in some phrase, you win a big prize. When you start playing the game, the letters come quickly, and the phrase fills in promisingly. But there's one letter that never seems to show up. The contest ends and your phrase is still incomplete. What happened, of course, is that all the letters except that one were just distractions. That one letter was very rare and controlled how many times the prize would actually be awarded. The contest exploits the unconscious bias that the letters have to show up with the same probability. They're all just letters, right? There's a feeling that when you get a letter you're closer to winning, but unless it's that rare letter you're not significantly closer at all.
- blackbear_ 3y agoThat's just how it is when you are studying the unknown. Good thing that there are people who do stuff without letting such thoughts stop them.
- pfdietz 3y agoAnd bad thing that people overrepresent what's been found so far.
- blackbear_ 3y agoIn general I agree, although neither the scientific article nor the press release seem misleading to me. In any case, you seem to be assuming that the most important part is still missing, but do you actually know?
- croes 3y agoJust because a step is easy doesn't mean it's easy to understand and vice versa. Just because you understand something doesn't you it's easy or hard. Or to use your letter game: You got an E, without knowing the phrase you don't know if it's a rare letter or a common one, especially if even don't know the language of the phrase.
- pfdietz 3y agoThe question is how hard is it to get experimental evidence for the thing. If it occurs under a wide variety of circumstances at a high rate, it's easy. If it involves an extremely unlikely set of circumstances, it's not easy, and will be hard to replicate.