3 ms·
It's a worthwhile trade. I've been able to produce a substantial amount of reliable, working code with the assistance of LLMs over the past year - code I would
by simonw 3y ago
It's a worthwhile trade. I've been able to produce a substantial amount of reliable, working code with the assistance of LLMs over the past year - code I would have not been able to produce otherwise simply due to lack of time.
Why review code at all if you think your coworkers are infallible?
- dartos 3y agoI’m fine with LLM code as long as someone actually understands what it’s doing.
- bee_rider 3y agoI think you are both saying that it is OK to use LLMs, but you have to check the output. It looks like there’s been a communication hiccup or something; I think you are saying that the LLM user should treat LLM code as if it is written by an unreliable team-mate who might copy-paste from the internet, and check it. Jprete seems to be talking about just receiving a PR from a person who didn’t do that checking and just directly is using the LLM code. I agree with you, but I think it is worth noting that > This is not a worthwhile trade > It's a worthwhile trade The difference here is not in whether or not the trade is worthwhile; you are just talking about two different trades .
- simonw 3y agoYeah, I think you're right. I don't think it's OK for a coworker to contribute a PR generated by an LLM without having already reviewed it and being ready to declare that they are confident in its quality.