4 ms·
Great. Now I have to avoid the elevators -- if I go in and a female feels harassed by being "trapped" with a guy in an elevator I get kicked out. If I don't, I
by tomjen3 15y ago
Great. Now I have to avoid the elevators -- if I go in and a female feels harassed by being "trapped" with a guy in an elevator I get kicked out. If I don't, I get kicked out because I won't share an elevator with a female.
Not to mention the crap about respecting peoples religion. It is literally impossible to do that while being inclusive of LGBT people since homosexuality is an abomination in Christianity and Islam (or Islamic customs) mandates separation of the sexes. Not to mention that religion is a choice, whereas the race you were born isn't.
I am not advocating tricking muslims to eat pork at the conference or anything, but some groups happen to complain a lot over relatively insignificant things.
And in the end the goal is not inclusivity. It is the sharing of code, tools and practices related to these things.
- tptacek 15y agoI'm from a huge Catholic family and my life is full of people who (a) go to church and (b) are horrified at discrimination over sexual orientation. I'm sure there are plenty of Muslims who are equally frustrated over being automatically judged by the standards of the worst members of their community. Similarly: I know plenty of people with moral dietary restrictions --- and the hipster-friendly vegan mentality is surely more common than Kosher and Halal/Haraam --- who don't make a giant stink over pork being served at conferences. I don't keep vegan, Kosher, or Halal, but I'm not enough of a close-minded idiot to literally be offended that those people exist. Incidentally: accused of harassment just for getting in an elevator with someone of the opposite sex? Huh?
- parfe 15y agoIncidentally: accused of harassment just for getting in an elevator with someone of the opposite sex? Huh? He's referring to an incident where a conference speaker had drinks in the hotel bar with other attendees and at 4am said she was tired and left to go to her room. A man left the bar and followed her into the elevator and only after being secluded asked to continue talking with her in his room. edit: Found the video http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=uKHwduG1Frk#t=241s http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v... Her point was that his approach made her uncomfortable. He had the opportunity to speak to her in a public place in the bar but chose an elevator. I think he chose the elevator because it was less stressful to approach a stranger with no one to witness a probable rejection. Of course it made it more stressful for her to turn down a stranger while trapped alone with him. She received some serious backlash from men who think it was perfectly acceptable to tail a woman into an elevator to engage them in conversion while they are trapped with you, and she would be completely wrong for feeling threatened. Coincidentally it's the same type of guy who would have told her it was her fault for getting attacked if the man had raped her. Edit: Also, I can't believe HN is supporting tomjen3's comment. It's borderline parody, but not.
- tomjen3 15y agoThe reason there was a huge shitstorm over it was that all he did was to ask -- he didn't do anything else. And yeah he asked her out in a situation where he wouldn't be humiliated if she turned him down. And jumping from the conclusion that I support rapists because I think it is okay for men to choose a place that is reasonably private to ask females out -- well I just can't see a productive debate springing from that, so I will refrain from commenting it.
- tptacek 15y agoDo we really have to have a debate about "don't follow lone women into elevators at 4AM to ask them out at tech conferences"? I'm sorry, I don't think we seriously have to debate this.
- chc 15y ago> Coincidentally it's the same type of guy who would have told her it was her fault for getting attacked if the man had raped her. You're way over the line with that one. It's one thing for a man to think, "I don't owe it to women to walk on eggshells around them." That view might be a bit naive, but it is a very different and much less despicable thing than supporting rapists and blaming rape victims for what happened to them. I thought what he did was poorly considered, but he didn't show any ill intent, so it's very unfair to associate him with men who harm women. Why do I care about this? Because drawing that association actually plays into rapists' common delusion that trying to rape women is a normal and acceptable thing. It is important to draw the line between behavior that is merely inconsiderate and behavior that's actually evil, even if you dislike both.
- parfe 15y agoI agree with most of your comment, thank you. It was a good response to what I wrote. >so it's very unfair to associate him with men who harm women. I wasn't associating the person in the elevator with people who victim blame. I was speaking of people who responded in a backlash to her video describing the incident. Allow me to expand on that line you quoted to clarify. Let's take this comment, for instance: >The reason there was a huge shitstorm over it was that all he did was to ask -- he didn't do anything else. What he's doing here is invaliding her discomfort. He's implying she should have some way to detect a rapist and her danger-detection is faulty. She shouldn't have been uncomfortable because he didn't rape her. It only works in hindsight and it's "not" victim blaming only because she wasn't victimized. Claiming a person should know someone is not a rapist necessarily requires thinking a person can know someone is a rapist. edit: removed repetitive sentence for clarity.
- alinajaf 15y ago> I'm sure there are plenty of Muslims who are equally frustrated over being automatically judged by the standards of the worst members of their community. I don't believe this is true. I'm from a huge Muslim family. The majority of the women/girls in my family are not educated, had marriages arranged from birth (usually to first cousins) and the men in the family genuinely believe that this is the in their best interest. This is somewhat representative of life for girls/women in rural Pakistan, a country of 180,000,000+ people, 95% of which are Muslim. My family is full of people who find homosexuality repugnant. Homosexuality is a crime against nature in Pakistan, punishable with a prison sentence. All Muslims I've met, in my family or otherwise, inside and outside of Pakistan, believe that this is a perfectly good state of affairs and have no interest in inclusivity for groups they deem inappropriate.
- adrianhoward 15y agoNot to mention the crap about respecting peoples religion. I'm sorry - I've looked a few times. I don't see anything there about "respecting peoples religion" in there. It's an anti-harassment policy. It's about actions - not thoughts. I can disrespect Christianity (or whatever) as much as I like. I just can't be an asshole about it.
- rmc 15y agoA lot of members of privileged groups sometimes retort that "You can't say anything anymore!" or "Politicial Correctness has gone too far!" to any attempted You're talking about straw men that don't exist. Please be more honest in your debate. There is currently much much much more sexism going on against women than crazy rules that stop people from saying anything. (e.g. Speeches at Dell Denmark telling everyone that it's great there's so few women and they need to keep the women out). (The same can be said about other forms of opression (race/sexuality/gender expression/abelism/etc.))