5 ms·
An air breathing engine is used early in a launch. That means it's in competition with a rocket propelled first stage. But first stages are the least sensitiv
by pfdietz 3y ago
An air breathing engine is used early in a launch. That means it's in competition with a rocket propelled first stage. But first stages are the least sensitive part of a rocket to Isp. They are more sensitive to thrust/weight ratio of the engines, and on that metric air breathing engines are grossly inferior to rockets.
- sigmoid10 3y agoI think this is not meant to directly replace the first stage engines for a conventional rocket. Instead you'd use an approach like SpaceShipOne where you launch like a normal plane using jet engines and then only fire rocket engines once you run out of air. It would be cool to have this approach in a single vehicle. Thrust to weight is less of a consideration there. Although it will still be expensive to carry two radically different types of engines. I'd love to see an engine like this that can seamlessly switch to burning oxidizer that was brought along for the ride. Maybe even combined with an aerospike to get every last bit of efficiency out of higher altitudes. Then we might get true scifi SSTO spacecraft. Think of a 737 but it can go to space.
- schnitzelstoat 3y agoBut instead of using the aeroplane you could just use a conventional first stage rocket? I don't think I understand what advantage the aeroplane gives.
- defrost 3y agoLift from wings means overall less fuel usage, launch from an aircraft increases the choice of "launch rockets from here" locations. ie. Can presumeably get closer to the equator and choose the desired "west to east" ascent line (and fall to earth line for debris in case of rocket failure).
- Timshel 3y agoVideo on the subject from EverydayAstronaut https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=AAt9WDQEMoA https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=AAt9WDQEMoA Those gains appear more marginal than expected.
- coryfklein 3y agoAfter watching the video I'm left wondering how k2pilot would respond to the analysis. Is the idea that you could use these jet engines as part of a vertical takeoff?
- pfdietz 3y agoThrust/weight ratio of a Merlin engine: 184 (sea level), 214 (vacuum) Thrust/weight ratio of a military jet engines: ~9 Thrust/weight ratio of a commercial turbofan: ~6 Merlin also has a much lower cost per unit thrust, 200x lower than a military jet engine, 400x lower than current commercial high bypass turbofan engines.
- cm2187 3y agoStupid question but don't the wings make most of the work in term of lift? I would assume you need less energy to pull some weight up in the air, obviously a lot slower also.
- alexey-salmin 3y agoThe thing is, the goal of a rocket is not to "lift things off the ground", it is to "speed up things to an orbital velocity" -- around 8km/s for LEO. From this point of view starting the rocket engine in the air at 0.2km/s speed is a marginal improvement compared to starting it on the ground. It still can be an improvement if executed correctly but it's hard to make it big enough to justify the complexity.
- pfdietz 3y agoAnd any gain in the very first part of a flight can also be achieved by just making a cheap rocket first stage slightly larger. Being able to propulsively recover rocket first stages, as Falcon 9 demonstrated, has destroyed pretty much any rationale for winged or air breathing first stages.
- mapt 3y agoWinged and air breathing first stages are a square peg round hole situation because high altitude and runway technical requirements are so different, and at low altitude reaching mach 0.8 is all you get to do cheaply - a negligible benefit considering the extreme costs associated with either horizontal plane-style integration or high TWR turbines. If you're going to optimize for getting useful delta V out of them, you need to do it in the stratosphere with ramjets/scramjets, which have minimum airspeed requirements on top of the minimum glide airspeed requirements necessary to keep a heavy aerodynamic body from falling to earth. You're best starting out at extreme speed and high altitude by launching from a hydrogen or vacuum filled maglev at Chimborazo or Kilimanjaro, and using the scramjet to get from the summit launchsite at a muzzle velocity of atmospheric-mach 3 up to the Karman line at mach 10. The initial speed provides the ability to go directly to hypersonic engines, the ability to trivially maintain altitude and build speed with only modest TWR and small light wings, and the ability to minimize drag losses by going through very thin air. Can it beat reusable rockets? Noone knows.
- rsynnott 3y agoThe aeroplane takes off from an airport, lands back in the airport, turned around ready to go in half an hour (this is assuming a multistage arrangement where only the first stage is a plane; if you're talking SSTO it's a different story, but that's always been a _bit_ of a pipe dream).
- tekla 3y agoIt's almost none. I've done the numbers, its an irrelevant amount.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> you'd use an approach like SpaceShipOne If that’s where they’re going they’re fucked. What kills air launch (specifically, an airplane first stage and conventional second) is the second stage must withstand stress in two dimensions; most rockets wouldn’t fair well being hung horizontally because they don’t have to design to withstand stress in that dimension. Most airliner airframes wouldn’t deal well with being hung from tail or tip; that’s strike fighter stuff. Air launch combines the worst of staging (complexity) and SSTO (dual dimensioning). What I'm reading is turbojets supplementing rockets to reduce fuel burn.
- sigmoid10 3y agoWell, SpaceShipOne shows it does work for suborbital flights. All they really need is higher efficiency for the engines.
- heads 3y agoPut wings on it and go up sideways. It solves the thrust/weight issue the same way a hill climber does: instead of going directly up they zig zag. You need the lateral velocity anyway, for orbit.
- MrSkelter 3y agoThis would be used in something like Starraker. That design can get 100 tons to orbit with a single stage much more efficiently than any rocket. Take off like a plane, climb to high altitude. Enter a supersonic dive. Pull up and ignite your rockets from high in the atmosphere when travelling relatively fast. You need much less fuel that way. The wings get you the first 30k mètres.
- rjmunro 3y agoOrbit is not about height, it is about speed. You have to get to almost 30km/s otherwise you aren't in orbit and you fall back into the atmosphere.
- 3m 3y agoI think you are confusing the speed at which the earth orbits the sun (~29.8km/s) with the speed at which an object needs to travel to maintain earth orbit (~7.8km/s).
- rjmunro 3y agoWhoops, you are right. I think it's too late to edit my original post. The point still stands, though, you have to get to nearly 8km/s otherwise you aren't in orbit and you fall back into the atmosphere. You can't get to anywhere near that speed while still in the atmosphere - SR-71s only manage about 1km/s, and because kinetic energy is proportional to the square of the speed, at that point you are only 1/64th of the way there.
- seabass-labrax 3y agoTo get to an appropriate speed, you need to accelerate eventually. But it's easier to do that at a higher altitude, where you have thinner air to travel through: less drag, less severe transonic effects to mitigate and, on the way up, a wider variety of air-breathing engine types to choose from (including the Astro Mechanica one).
- 3y ago
- HPsquared 3y agoThe mention of SSTO is my annual reminder to check on the Skylon project, using the SABRE air-breathing rocket engines. A hydrogen-fueled engine which can transition between fully air-breathing (for runway takeoff) to pure rocket mode at high altitude. Has a pre-cooler in front of the compressor to improve operation at high Mach number (otherwise the air coming the inlet is too hot when going fast). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skylon_(spacecraft) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skylon_(spacecraft) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SABRE_(rocket_engine) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SABRE_(rocket_engine) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Precooled_jet_engine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Precooled_jet_engine
- ed_blackburn 3y agoI came here to say the same thing. Since the UK Govt granted Reaction Engines £60m to invest in SABRE, I've been infrequently checking in. https://reactionengines.co.uk/advanced-propulsion/sabre/ https://reactionengines.co.uk/advanced-propulsion/sabre/ The SABRE stuff looks _almost_ too good to be true.
- NikkiA 3y agoIt's been 40 years, it IS too good to be true... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_Aerospace_HOTOL#Engine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_Aerospace_HOTOL#Engine
- pfdietz 3y agoSkylon was basically knocked out by Falcon 9, and even more so by Starship. Skylon doesn't even save on propellant cost. It uses more expensive liquid hydrogen in order to save very cheap liquid oxygen. The only reason to continue to invest in this is if one imagines there's some cruise mission application for the technology, say hypersonic cruise missiles.
- cm277 3y agoThis; plus you need to duplicate structures to make the launch vehicle work in both air-breathing and rocket mode. This whole approach (incl. SpaceShipOne and Pegasus) was trying to disrupt non-reusable rocket launch. Re-usable rocket launch is a much better/greater disruptor than some sort of hybrid vehicle. Possible exception of course are hypersonic military vehicles (spyplanes or missiles). So there's that.
- pfdietz 3y agoAir breathing is a much better match for cruise missions (that sustain a speed for long periods of time) than it is for acceleration missions (that bring a vehicle to a high speed over a shorter period of time).
- Kim_Bruning 3y agoDepends on your launch profile, of course. You could try to stay air-breathing as long as possible while building some of your orbital velocity. I'm not saying there's One True Mission Profile here. Depending on your needs and constraints, it might be a good plan in some cases. See also: https://xkcd.com/1244/ https://xkcd.com/1244/ (sometimes)
- cryptonector 3y agoWorse, as the vehicle ascends the atmosphere gets thinner and thinner, and the benefit of not having to carry O2 for that stage vanishes, so the amount of O2 that you save not carrying isn't worth the weight cost of the engines.
- dotancohen 3y agoI actually asked why jet engines were not used in place of the SRBs on the Space Shuttle on space.SE a few years ago, there were two really good answers: https://space.stackexchange.com/questions/6256/why-were-jet-engines-not-used-in-place-of-the-solid-fuel-in-the-sts-srbs https://space.stackexchange.com/questions/6256/why-were-jet-...