2 ms·
Seems to me, that the auto industry is paying for the mistakes, made by congress when it came to the Wall Street bail out. The financial industry got a blank c
by vaksel 18y ago
Seems to me, that the auto industry is paying for the mistakes, made by congress when it came to the Wall Street bail out.
The financial industry got a blank check for 700 billion bailout almost overnight w/o any questions, they produce nothing tangible, and there is nothing preventing another bank from replacing any of the big ones. Its an industry that scales easily.
The auto industry on the other hand, is getting grilled left and right over a measly 15 billion. The money comes with a ton of strings attached. Even though unlike the financial industry they produce a tangible product. And there are no other competitors waiting to fill the big boy's shoes, because it takes billions to scale.
So it seems to me that the Congress is being penny smart and pound foolish, they give away vast sums w/o a second thought, and then turn around and penny pinch when it comes to a tiny amount.
- programnature 18y agoI don't think its the amount so much as who it is going to. The republicans are itching at a shot to break the backs of these unions, and this is their golden opportunity.
- SwellJoe 18y agoThe unions broke their own backs. Republicans (and Democrats) didn't make the big three into horribly managed, debt-laden, corporate pigs producing products that no one wants, but they both helped--but the ways they helped make them soft-headed and inefficient are probably things you approve of (like protectionist tariffs on imports, stricter immigration laws, trade restrictions of various sorts, etc.). The management and the unions at those companies worked hard for many years to destroy the US auto industry. Neither bailout is a good or fair solution, but deciding that every broken industry ought to be able to extract limitless funds from innocent taxpayers in order to continue with business as usual, merely because one broken industry is getting a bailout, borders on evil. Two wrongs don't make a right.
- mattmaroon 18y agoThe difference is our financial industry may be salvageable, and not trying is disastrous. Whether or not that bailout is a good idea is certainly debatable. But it has nothing to do with a different bailout that, without some serious provisions to ensure long term viability, has no chance of working. FWIW, most economists seem to be for the financial bailout and against the auto one. Also the financial one is not a give away, it's an investment. They're taking equity stakes in bailed out companies and enforcing rules to ensure long term viability. The Senate wants the same exact thing with the auto one.
- anamax 18y ago> FWIW, most economists seem to be for the financial bailout and against the auto one. Most economists think that they understand the financial system and its effect on the economy better than they understand domestic car makers and their effect. Even if they're correct (about their relative knowledge), their ignorance about the latter makes their conclusion suspect. "Follow the money" is a dumb rule. "Follow self-interest and self-perception" is a great rule.
- anamax 18y agoIt's unclear why the financial industry bailout is relevant. If the financial bailout was a mistake, it's unclear why that mistake is an argument for giving money to GM. If the financial bailout was a good idea and implementation,it's unclear which reasons (and mechanisms) also apply to GM. In other words, "he got some" is not actually a valid argument. (FWIW, that's true whether "some" is money or sex.)
- lacker 18y agoThe auto industry is not doing that bad. It's just GM and Chrysler that are bankrupt. Ford will survive on its own and so will Toyota and Honda. If they were all in danger of bankruptcy it would be another story.