3 ms·
I think there’s a missing element on the pro side—putting aside whether or not it is a waste for the hunter, it is wildly unethical to injure an animal and then
by bee_rider 3y ago
I think there’s a missing element on the pro side—putting aside whether or not it is a waste for the hunter, it is wildly unethical to injure an animal and then leave wandering around slowly dying. If we’re going to have hunting, we should be extremely reluctant to limit the ability to find the injured animals.
- godelski 3y agoThis is the bigger aspect to me. "All for nothing" is not the right description for failure to recover. Hunting is actually an important part of maintaining a proper ecosystem. It still serves as a management tool even if the animal dies in needless pain. Counterintuitively, hunting can often be an ethically right decision to make (depending on animal). This is because we humans have displaced natural predators and these prey will tend to over populate, over consume their food sources, and then starve. Remember that hunting is limited to seasons and that these seasons are decided per species and the population of that species. There are a lot of regulations around this and it isn't simply kill anything you want. Similarly there are even moral big game hunting, where they specifically target aggressive and harmful animals, and use the money to fund the nature preserve. In this manner, the ethical obligation is then to do the least harm and make the most out of it. If we need to cull some populations, it should be done as humanely as possible. Applying the same ethical ideals (distinct from practice) that we apply for livestock. Some articles if anyone wants to read more. This is a controversial topic still but I'm providing this information because there is legitimacy to this side of the argument that many may not be aware of. I'd encourage discussion, but not bashing. Unfortunately, like most things, there's a lot of complexity and nuance to all these things. The claim is not that there is no abuse, but that there is a difference between abusing a practice and a practice being useful. https://dnr.maryland.gov/wildlife/Pages/hunt_trap/deerhuntastool.aspx https://dnr.maryland.gov/wildlife/Pages/hunt_trap/deerhuntas... https://www.npr.org/2018/03/20/593001800/decline-in-hunters-threatens-how-u-s-pays-for-conservation https://www.npr.org/2018/03/20/593001800/decline-in-hunters-... https://thehill.com/changing-america/opinion/539071-misinformation-about-trophy-hunting-is-wrong-dead-wrong/ https://thehill.com/changing-america/opinion/539071-misinfor... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9y7YFjisSTg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9y7YFjisSTg
- hk1337 3y ago> it is wildly unethical to injure an animal and then leave wandering around slowly dying. It's only unethical if you do it on purpose and do not make an honest effort to find the animal. It can happen that you shoot an animal and cannot find it because it ran off.
- margalabargala 3y agoYour intentions behind the injury, and the effort you put into the search, are irrelevant to the amount of suffering experienced by the animal if it is not found. Perhaps one person's behavior is more ethical with regard to the decisions they made, but their effect on the world is not different. Thus, we should make it easier for people to use tools to find such injured animals, so their effect on the world will be more positive (or less negative) than otherwise.
- mlyle 3y ago> ...do not make an honest effort to find the animal... And here we're talking about the law forcing unethical behavior by limiting honest efforts to find the animal.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> the law forcing unethical behavior by limiting honest efforts to find the animal Fair enough. On one hand, you have the harm caused by animals I found. On the other hand, you have the blanket plausible deniability granted to anyone using drones to find targets. Perhaps there could be a rule about not discharging a firearm while a drone is in flight. I don’t see how that would be enforceable, however, inasmuch as it requires LE to witness the illegal kill, which almost never happens.
- mlyle 3y ago> On the other hand, you have the blanket plausible deniability granted to anyone using drones to find targets. Yah, I appreciate the problems; perhaps you can't have a weapon on your person while doing certain permitted recovery things. In this case, it's some poor SOB who got a phone call from some hunters^H^H^H^H^H^H agents who wanted help finding a hurt animal.
- op00to 3y agoIt was unethical to hunt prior to the cheap availability of drones? How about not killing the animal unless you’re sure you can recover it.