3 ms·
I think the tech industry understands this perfectly well. Large parts also understand that actually asking for and respecting consent will reduce their income
by JohnFen 3y ago
I think the tech industry understands this perfectly well. Large parts also understand that actually asking for and respecting consent will reduce their income stream some. The primary directive of the tech industry is to profit regardless of the cost or harm to others.
- pacmanincarnate 3y agoAs a consumer, I agree with this take. Looking at it from the other side though, many businesses simply wouldn’t exist online with opt-in. To some extent, you need to understand that companies need to make a profit and we’ve developed a market where that’s not going to be direct payments by users.
- JohnFen 3y ago> many businesses simply wouldn’t exist online with opt-in. If a business can't exist without abusing people, perhaps it shouldn't exist.
- __loam 3y agoThe kicker is that a lot of this stuff isn't even profitable.
- nonrandomstring 3y agoThat is interesting, because I think you're right, and so it raises the question, what for? Is is just a kleptomaniac instinct to hoard data, despite the fact that it is really a liability [0] in most cases? [0] https://www.schneier.com/essays/archives/2016/03/data_is_a_toxic_asse.html https://www.schneier.com/essays/archives/2016/03/data_is_a_t...
- __loam 3y agoI think it's a mix of: 1) True believers who think anything that can be done to get us further to AGI should be done. 2) Business types who think this could be the next internet and don't want to miss the train and who are willing to lose some money to get in early.
- nonrandomstring 3y agoBoth of those camps terrify me. :)
- bmer 3y agoIt is, in that it takes advantage of peoples' speculative nature. "What if we had all this extra data on our customers?! Then we could do a lot more to make more money! So, it makes sense we ought to pay more for that data too!" The data provider gets to profit based of this speculative "of course more information/more stuff is better!", while the data purchaser doesn't really have a chance to test whether their speculation is well-founded. (How precisely do you test what the causative effect of changes to your ad campaign are? If you make a change, and numbers go up, how do you separate numbers going up caused by any of the other parallel factors? It's hard to be scientific with advertising.) The person selling the tool always wins, even if the tool is nothing more than a placebo effect. The person buying the tool on the other hand...well, good thing they have deep pockets, and don't really know how to spend their money well, and good thing too that there's always more more suckers ready to take their place (as long as we keep the birth rate up)!
- __loam 3y agoIt's a good point that data providers can make a profit opening this as a new revenue stream. We'll see how they end up working out for the end users of that data I guess.
- bdw5204 3y agoCase in point would be when Apple implemented a change to iOS requiring apps to ask if you want to be tracked. I believe almost everybody says no which cost the industry a great deal of ad money.
- tmcdos 3y agoIn essence, this is equal to slavery - "someone pays me to flood you with SPAM - if you refuse that SPAM, I will starve to death; so please don't refuse the SPAM" We know that bees fly to the flowers by their own wish. Imagine how bees are sitting in their hive and out of nowhere thousands and thousands of flowers are coming to the hive and advertising "Here, be-be-be-beees, the best floral pollen for you! Take 3 for the price of 2!" If you were a bee - would you consider this normal?
- nonrandomstring 3y ago> regardless of the cost or harm to others Interesting choice of words. As I understand it, and I do not have the judgement transcript, in the British Post Office case those were the words on which Judge Fraser acquitted the postmasters and found against the Post Office. I think the key words may have been "above all else" with respect to the "interests of the Post Office". You don't get to say that. Ever. In law, at least in Britain as I can see it, you don't get to put reputation or profit or anything else "above all else" or "regardless of the cost or harm to others". YMMV elsewhere.