4 ms·
The Tech Industry Doesn't Understand Consent – Opt-Out Is Not Consent
- mouse_ 3y agoIf I see one more popup with the only available responses being "Yes!" and "Maybe" I am going to go ballistic.
- jjgreen 3y agoTry AllWaysKillSticky: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-GB/firefox/addon/alwayskillsticky/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-GB/firefox/addon/alwayskillsti...
- phone8675309 3y ago"Yes!" in Green "Remind me Later!" in Blue Tiny X in top right corner of the box that's as close to white as possible without actually being white Honestly should be a prison-worthy offense to display a dialog like that
- beeboobaa 3y agoAnd no means no. It doesn't mean "sure you can neg me later".
- lifestyleguru 3y agoUpsss missed that, we're updating your operating system right now.
- JohnFen 3y agoI think the tech industry understands this perfectly well. Large parts also understand that actually asking for and respecting consent will reduce their income stream some. The primary directive of the tech industry is to profit regardless of the cost or harm to others.
- pacmanincarnate 3y agoAs a consumer, I agree with this take. Looking at it from the other side though, many businesses simply wouldn’t exist online with opt-in. To some extent, you need to understand that companies need to make a profit and we’ve developed a market where that’s not going to be direct payments by users.
- JohnFen 3y ago> many businesses simply wouldn’t exist online with opt-in. If a business can't exist without abusing people, perhaps it shouldn't exist.
- __loam 3y agoThe kicker is that a lot of this stuff isn't even profitable.
- nonrandomstring 3y agoThat is interesting, because I think you're right, and so it raises the question, what for? Is is just a kleptomaniac instinct to hoard data, despite the fact that it is really a liability [0] in most cases? [0] https://www.schneier.com/essays/archives/2016/03/data_is_a_toxic_asse.html https://www.schneier.com/essays/archives/2016/03/data_is_a_t...
- __loam 3y agoI think it's a mix of: 1) True believers who think anything that can be done to get us further to AGI should be done. 2) Business types who think this could be the next internet and don't want to miss the train and who are willing to lose some money to get in early.
- nonrandomstring 3y agoBoth of those camps terrify me. :)
- AdamH12113 3y agoImagining an opt-in policy highlights how unethical these AI data-harvesting schemes really are. It's blindingly obvious that almost nobody would actively choose to donate their work to enrich AI companies without getting anything in return.
- resizeitplz 3y agoGuess I'm 'almost nobody'. I see zero issue with AI farming Stack Overflow, Twitter, Reddit, and the like - publicly accessible forums. The value to me was in the discussion. It's happened; I've extracted my value from that engagement. If an AI company can also extract value from that collection of discussions, it costs me nothing and I expect no compensation. Thought AI companies farming copyrighted work on the other hand, that's a different story.
- JohnFen 3y agoIn the US, everything you write anywhere online is copyrighted by you, unless you sign a copyright assignment agreement. It's automatic any time you put an expression into a fixed form, and there is no way to revoke that copyright.
- nonrandomstring 3y agoAs I understand it copyright has failed. Or rather we are into an age of naked double standards where courts will enforce the copyright of big-tech against you for "stealing" a movie, but will not enforce your copyright against big-tech for "stealing" your data for its AI. EDIT: some links [0,1] [0] https://www.reuters.com/legal/litigation/us-judge-finds-flaws-artists-lawsuit-against-ai-companies-2023-07-19/ https://www.reuters.com/legal/litigation/us-judge-finds-flaw... [1] https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/business/business-news/artists-copyright-infringement-case-ai-art-generators-1235632929/ https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/business/business-news/art...
- danaris 3y agoCopyright has absolutely not "failed". Copyright is still deeply important to prevent behemoths from just straight-up taking stuff individuals wrote and profiting from it with no consequences. For instance, without copyright, traditional publishers could just take everything the authors they currently contract with have written, and every other current author, and publish it without paying the authors a cent. ML training is a legal gray area right now, because it's a new thing, and we haven't had time to properly sit down and both understand what its effects are, and how it should be treated legally. It is possible that this process, when it ends up happening, will be captured by corruption; it is possible that it won't. But using the current frustrations and anger about ML training as evidence that copyright has "failed" is a vast oversimplification that ignores the very real good that copyright does in our society.
- nonrandomstring 3y agoWe're properly into the age of all-out "lawfare" now. I wonder what happened to the likes of Lawrence Lessig and Pamela Jones, and all those legal minds who used to weigh in on the side of ordinary decent people. We could use some easily deployed retaliatory weapons and countermeasures about now.
- BadHumans 3y agoLegalEagle on Youtube speaks on cases from a laymen perspective.
- karaterobot 3y agoAt the very least, an action which is effectively instantaneous should never be opt out. That is, if they can flip a switch and scan millions of blogs in a few hours, or days, or even weeks, you need to be able to opt out before that happens. It shouldn't be a race between you and the website to see if you can find the opt out toggle before you lose control of your property. A lesser example of this is when you sign up for a website, and are immediately opted in to their newsletter and various other spam email lists. The opt-in happened in ~1ms, but even if you opt out immediately after your first login, you'll still get added to their list by default.
- bradleyankrom 3y agoI've always been amused by the fact that they'll newsletter and product sales bomb me within a minute of signing up for their service, but removing me from their lists may take up to 5-7 business days.
- karaterobot 3y agoIt made more sense when I understood that saying it may take up to 10 business days to opt me out was a statement recognizing the legal requirements rather than the technical requirements. I'm sure some companies just wait exactly 9 days, 23 hours, 59 minutes and 59 seconds to instantaneously opt me out. Malicious compliance, or as we used to call it, passive-aggressiveness.
- nonrandomstring 3y agoWe need a legally enforcible mechanism to make anyone think twice before using data without consent. This must have the effect with AI training models, that if a persons data has been incorporated without consent, or they legally revoke assumed consent, the data must be removed. At present, AFAICS that would mean voiding an entire model. That would be expensive and so be a stiff deterrent against abuse. Copyright has failed. But there are sutely other tricks to play.
- pacmanincarnate 3y ago
- cs702 3y ago"It Is Difficult to Get a Man to Understand Something When His Salary Depends Upon His Not Understanding It"[a] [a] https://quoteinvestigator.com/2017/11/30/salary/ https://quoteinvestigator.com/2017/11/30/salary/
- renewiltord 3y ago[dead]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- __loam 3y agoYou can really only laugh when companies like OpenAI say they're working on this problem, and them working on this problem is a tedious opt-out form that you need to fill out for each and every piece of work they may or may not have ingested, and no they won't be retraining the model. It's obvious they are acting in bad faith to anyone with a brain.
- AlienRobot 3y agoPersonally, I feel it would be a much smaller problem if Tumblr had an internal AI thing going on. What users REALLY don't like is that they have confided a post with one website, and that website just shared that post with a third-party because if opens up infinite possibilities. If Tumblr can take your post and give it to OpenAI, they can take your post and give it to anyone, and that's the problem. Because for users, what they post is "between them and Tumblr" and not anybody else. I'll even say more. Artists don't care if you scrape their art to make AI generated art with it. Because when this happens, it's "between artists and scrapers" and not anybody else, so it's fine. What they do care about is when people post that AI generated art on the internet, or publish it professionally, or do basically anything with it. In other words, there's a sense of privacy when there is only two parties involved, no matter what is going on, but the instant a third party gets into the system, the first party will freak out, because then you lose that sense of privacy.
- nonrandomstring 3y agoYou're saying consent isn't transitive. That's why they always ask for (or more frequently just take) "a paid up, non-exclusive, irrevocable, worldwide license"
- AlienRobot 3y agoI think "consent" is not the right word for this, because it's never simply "consent" it's always boundaries and expectations. Consent implies there's always one yes/no answer for a process. In practice the process is always so complicated that it would require countless yes/no questions, to the point nobody sane would want to deal with it. Just look at cookie banners and imagine if we had a consent popup for every single thing that needs to be download to show a page: do you consent to download the HTML? Do you consent to download the CSS? Do you consent to download the Javascript? Do you consent to download the images? The user just wants the see the page. You have to make assumptions about how far that consent goes, so it's absolutely transitive, the problem is at what point it crosses the line.
- 3y ago
- some_furry 3y agoAmazing that this has 69 upvotes in under an hour and still isn't on the front page. Algorithmic suppression much?
- HeatrayEnjoyer 3y agoConsent tea https://youtube.com/watch?v=Exobo1GmYjs https://youtube.com/watch?v=Exobo1GmYjs
- xg15 3y agoLike sexual consent, they understand it perfectly well, rather, it just goes directly against their plans.
- anotherhue 3y ago“It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends on his not understanding it.”
- tamimio 3y agoI didn’t give any consent for any taxes either, but oh well..
- throwaway092323 3y agoPress X to not be violated