7 ms·
“Everyone is competing for the same people, going after the same real estate, the same support services,” Hartz says. “The natural resources of the startup worl
by mgkimsal 15y ago
“Everyone is competing for the same people, going after the same real estate, the same support services,” Hartz says. “The natural resources of the startup world are getting scarcer and scarcer, and the cost is getting higher and higher. It’s all an outgrowth of an abundance of capital.”
And largely still doing this in just a few square miles in California. Are investors so emotionally tied to one geographic area that long-term investing in other areas of the US is strictly verboten? Techstars and other programs should be demonstrating there's 'natural resources' outside of California, no?
- mindcrime 15y agoExactly. Every time I hear somebody talk about the "overabundance of capital" in the startup world, I want to grab them by the shoulders, stare them in the eyes and scream frantically like a mad-man "Have you been to RTP (NC) ?!?!??" OK, not quite that bad, but still, you get the drift. What's happening in California is not necessarily indicative of what's going on in the rest of the world. Research Triangle Park, for example, is FAR from having enough capital freely available, much less too much. Look at the most recent Triangle Startup Factory class... they took, what, six startups out of - IIRC - a hundred and some applications? Now to be fair, probably not all 100 of those startups are worthy of funding... But I know there were more than six worthy startups in the Raleigh / Durham / Chapel Hill area as of March, 2012.
- jonny_eh 15y agoWhat's RTP?
- strife25 15y agoResearch Triangle Park It's the area where Chapel Hill, Durham, and Raleigh, NC are.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- mindcrime 15y agoStrictly speaking, RTP[1] is a small area (mostly) in Durham County, NC, where a research park is located, where a lot of major technology and pharma companies, and tons of small companies, have R&D and/or manufacturing operations. Colloquially, people use "RTP" as shorthand for "The Triangle"[2] which is generally considered an area roughly defined by a triangle of lines connecting Raleigh, Durham and Chapel Hill. Or, depending on your take, connecting Duke University, the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, and NC State University. RTP (or "The Triangle") is a tech hub in the Southeast region, and is becoming quite a startup hotbed. But one of the limitations of this area is lack of access to early stage capital. Of all the things that hurt entrepreneurs in this area, that's probably the single most encountered problem. :-( [1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Research_Triangle_Park http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Research_Triangle_Park [2]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Research_Triangle http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Research_Triangle
- strife25 15y agoI've been living in RTP for the past 2 or 3 years and continue to get surprised by how many well known developers are in the area.
- nupark2 15y agoFor us yankees that exist on the "coasts", anywhere outside of NYC, SF, and LA are foreign lands, and somewhere like NC may as well be the moon. That is a bit unfair, but unsurprising. People choose to work where they want to live, and they'll work with the people they're most familiar with and understand, in the environment around them.
- simplemind 15y agoThis isn't a political statement, it's a comment about culture as it relates to recruiting valuable and scarce talent. Startup culture tends to be highly meritocratic. It lends itself to openness toward who you are as an individual as long as you work hard, work smart and achieve. Given this, I can't imagine trying to recruit the best and the brightest to NC given recent developments when there are more accepting places like NY, Silicon Valley, Seattle, etc. There are a ton of talented people who wouldn't want to live there. I'll concede that there may be others who want to live there more because of what went down, but those same people could be recruited almost anywhere without a meaningful depreciation in quality of life.
- mindcrime 15y agoThere's no question that A1 gave NC a black eye, and it does hurt. How much it hurts is a different question. My perception, having lived in NC my entire life, and having worked in the RTP area for 12 years, is that talent isn't the major holdup here. There is a ton of talent here, at least on a transitional basis, by virtue of the fact that people come here to attend NCSU, UNC and Duke (all 3 are very well respected and regarded schools) and because IBM, Cisco, GSK, and a pile of other companies have large presences here. The big challenge, talent wise, is to keep the folks who are graduating from UNC, NCSU, Duke, etc., here, instead of moving off to $WHEREVER. Not easy, but - believe it or not - NC has a lot going for it, A1 aside.
- impendia 15y agoRegarding the "recent developments", RTP jumps out on the following map: http://www.wral.com/news/political/page/10991843/ http://www.wral.com/news/political/page/10991843/ Durham and Orange Counties voted no by over 2-1 margins. And meanwhile, Proposition 8 passed in California a few years back; indeed, such propositions have been passed everywhere in the US where they've been put to the voters as a whole. North Carolina is not distinguished in this respect. I personally like San Francisco over RTP, despite originally being from Durham, but there is a lot that is very good about the RTP area, and I personally know a lot of very talented people who are extremely happy (if, admittedly, a little bit less so this week...) to call it home.
- mgkimsal 15y agoReplying to my own thread here: If an investor was watching one of their companies continually chasing a limited resource and paying an ever-higher price for those resources just to keep their business going, wouldn't they counsel the company to change their business model some? Look outside the box? Look for different suppliers to keep the costs down, create a competitive advantage, etc?
- spitfire 15y agoI'd counsel the company to turn a profit. But I'm not in silicon valley.
- koglerjs 15y agoThere is a naivete here that thinks geographic distance means the economies of disparate locales are disconnected. As the center of the startup scene, that few square miles in California will set the pace for the nation as a whole.
- nirvana 15y agoI really don't understand the over fixation on Silicon Valley. I lived there for awhile. Its got high population density is full of a lot of fake people (people who are happy to "help" your startup for just a taste of the equity), fake investors, and an extraordinary amount of noise. I'm sure there are many people who love it for the same reasons that high pressure finance types love new york city. But this seems anathema to building a good startup- where you need some isolation some time to focus and to keep a broad and rational perspective, not to be high on each others fumes. Plus, the bay area is very expensive, it attracts engineers who are more likely to jump to the next hot startup, its hard to find good office space, etc. It isn't like you can't get broadband everywhere. And I think people really misunderestimate the importance of good engineers who stick around. Turnover means critical knowledge is walking out the door. This makes bumfuck Ohio[1] a better place if retaining talent is important. The idea that only Stanford educated engineers are good enough to work at startups is silly. (my experience- finding the best engineers is not correlated with ivy league degrees.) Bumfuck Ohio may not have the cool meet ups that SV has, but it doesn't have the two orders of magnitude more distractions that SV has as well. Nor does it have the jealousy driven culture where every 4th person has an overpriced show off car, etc. The reason everyone focuses on the Valley? People are focused on venture capital, not building profitable businesses. Venture capital lives in the valley because for a lot of these VC firms a 90 minute flight to Seattle for a board meeting is just too much effort. That's it. [1] Nothing against Ohio, never been there, just picking it for an example.
- yardie 15y agoEvery place has a specialty so I wouldn't say everything happens in SV. They just happen to be more web focused than a lot of other places. Want to do finance computing? NYC. Government and aerospace? DC-Maryland-Virginia metro. Movies and VFX? LA. Obviously there are outliers, which have a rich cross section of talent, Miami, Chicago, Charlotte. But if you want to get a web-based business up and running and need a deep pool of talent there is no better place than Silicon Valley.
- sabat 15y agoI really don't understand the over fixation on Silicon Valley. I think the rest of your comment is elaboration on this theme. You don't understand, mainly because your views are distorted. A couple of examples to give you the idea: it attracts engineers who are more likely to jump to the next hot startup Untrue. Certainly you can find those types, but the Bay Area is full of people who are willing to stick with a company they believe in. It's just that you're focussing on smaller, more questionable startups. They're not the majority. This makes bumfuck Ohio[1] a better place if retaining talent is important. But you are much less likely to find talented engineers who just happen to live in Bumfuck, Ohio. Nerds tend to flock, because flocking is important. Startups need an ecosystem. Nor does it have the jealousy driven culture where every 4th person has an overpriced show off car, etc. I've been a Bay Area professional for 20 years, have worked at multiple startups, and have yet to see "every 4th person" with a show-off car. I think I know two or three people with super-expensive cars. Most people in the Bay Area who are involved in startups are serious about business and technology. That's why we have so many major success stories, and smaller ones you probably haven't heard of — for example, have you heard of Workday? It's a SaaS company started by Dave Duffield, who founded and ran PeopleSoft previously. Workday is growing like a weed, not because of wild infusions of crazy venture cash, but because it's a good service and the customer base is expanding. The reason everyone focuses on the Valley? People are focused on venture capital, not building profitable businesses. Wholly untrue. The entire focus is on building successful, profitable businesses, not on raking in VC money. That's why Heroku, Salesforce (which bought Heroku), Evernote, Dropbox, and — since history matters — Apple, Oracle, and even HP are here. I could make a much bigger list of successful and up-and-coming startups, but you can do the research if you actually are interested. You're focused on trivial companies and outlying flakey people. They're not the majority.
- jnorthrop 15y ago> Are investors so emotionally tied to one geographic area that long-term investing in other areas of the US is strictly verboten? I don't think it is quite as conspiratorial as you make it out to be. I was speaking to an active angel investor last night. He said he won't do a deal that is much more than an hours drive away. He feels like he can't really participate (as an advisor) to a company that he can't easily reach. It is not unlikely that many (most?) of the Silicon Valley investors feel the same way.
- davidw 15y agoSome companies and businesses manage to cobble together globe-spanning supply chains, so the excuse that they can't interact with "far away" people seems a bit dubious. Sooner or later, there will be VC's that figure out how to interact in a way that, while not 'as good' as being there in person, will be 'good enough', and will reap some nice profits from it. There are a lot of good things about SV, but there are also some good reasons to get out and go to smaller hubs - stuff like Boulder, Portland, and other places like that where life is more enjoyable.
- WiseWeasel 15y agoAngels are early-stage investors, and are often close advisers to the people they invest in.
- mgkimsal 15y agoI didn't say it was a conspiracy, but emotional ties. His wanting to stay in a particular geographic area plus his desire to only invest in projects he can drive to is limiting him. That's fine. I'm not even suggesting he's complaining about a talent shortage. But others are. Might he not have a similar quality of life and have access to some other great companies to invest in within an hour's drive and have less investment competition should he choose to move to, say, Louisiana? Or Mississippi? Or Tennessee? Or Texas?
- sabat 15y agoIt's not about emotion. It's about concentration of talent and drive, and geography does matter. People here in California, particularly in the Bay Area, think differently (apologies to SJ). Great startups are usually based on some sort of rule breaking, game change, or disruption. The non-conformist culture in CA especially lends it to this. That's why startups thrive here. Edit: it's no coincidence that the startup hub in Texas is in Austin, the only place in Texas I'm aware of that has a non-conformist culture.
- irunbackwards 15y agoI agree, the rest of the world is dying for these new products being created in SV, however they're being bought up and rolled up or snuffed out before the rest of the world really experiences them. This is especially true for the hyper local products that only service major metropolitan areas and some of the more "techier" social mobile products. Of course, I understand the rate of adoption in more rural areas doesn't fit the bing bang boom business model, but there is a crap ton of money to be made in the long haul. </rant>