6 ms·
Honest question: Is this any different from on iOS? Are you allowed to create native code-generators on iOS? If not, why do we all of a sudden care about this
by josteink 15y ago
Honest question: Is this any different from on iOS? Are you allowed to create native code-generators on iOS?
If not, why do we all of a sudden care about this now?
- masklinn 15y ago> Is this any different from on iOS? No. > Are you allowed to create native code-generators on iOS? Absolutely not (unless you jailbreak of course). In fact, due to this UIWebView are not JITed either and in-application browsers have significantly worse performances than the standalone Safari application or pinned "offline web applications": the latter two are "opted out" of sandbox restrictions and can generate executable code at runtime.
- taligent 15y agoIt is NOT significantly worse otherwise nobody would use it. But lots of apps do use it e.g. Linkedin, Facebook, Reeder, Google Search, iCab Mobile etc and it is not noticeably worse.
- trevrr 15y agoName dropping doesn't prove anything.
- masklinn 15y ago> It is NOT significantly worse It's a fourfold difference (~2200ms versus ~9100ms on three runs of each) on synthetic benchmarks (Sunspider 0.9.1 on an iPhone 4S running iOS 5.1.1, UIWebView was tested through Instapaper 4.2), which I would call significantly worse. > otherwise nobody would use it. Performance is not everything: they are convenient especially given iOS's debatable story for switching between applications (especially back and forth between an application and a web browser). > But lots of apps do use it e.g. Linkedin, Facebook, Reeder, Google Search, iCab Mobile etc and it is not noticeably worse. It's "not noticeable"[0] for JS-light websites because... well the JIT is for javascript code, running JS slower doesn't matter if there's no JS code. [0] it is most definitely noticeable, many sites — especially full-page non-mobile ones with ads shit — load significantly faster using Safari than using embedded UIWebView.
- gurkendoktor 15y agoI just downloaded Facebook from the German App Store today and spent some time reading the reviews. The app averages at 2 stars and most people complain specifically about terrible performance. I can confirm this on an iPad 1, FWIW. Hard numbers would be more interesting.
- mikemike 15y agoYes, this is the exact same situation as on iOS. But 1. the mobile app market was even more locked down before Apple entered it and 2. Apple is the media's darling.
- taligent 15y agoYes. Because the media very much cares about native code generators on ARM chipsets.
- cooldeal 15y agoThey sure seem to, for Windows RT. That was the point.
- roc 15y agoOr more accurately: "2. We've already had threads and threads of criticism for Apple over this subject. They're not changing and we've moved on." The reason this is worth talking about re: Windows 8 ARM, is that people are optimistic they can still convince Microsoft to take a different approach.
- 4ad 15y agoWhen the Windows ARM port was announced, many people had hoped for general purpose ARM devices that could replace their cheap laptops. This is not the case, so people complain. Also, the fact that Apple does it doesn't mean it's right. People complain about the Apple situation all the time as well.
- rwmj 15y agoThey can run Android on them, which is open (I'm typing this comment on a Samsung Galaxy Tab 10.1 w/ keyboard running a CM9 nightly build). Or they can run real Linux distros ... Fedora, Debian, Ubuntu, Linaro are all excellent working distros for a variety of ARM devices. I have a Trim Server running Fedora 17 which is just one open source graphics driver away from being a nice general purpose low end desktop replacement.
- delroth 15y agoThey can't, Win8 ARM devices will have a locked bootloader according to the OEM recommandations sent by Microsoft.
- rwmj 15y agoDo "Win8 ARM devices" actually exist? Maybe there are a handful of them, but there are a huge number of ARM devices available right now to buy that don't have locked bootloaders (or are trivially breakable like most Android devices). Who cares about what Microsoft are doing in an already overcrowded market, bringing along a new OS that has no installed application base? There's no reason to imagine that Win8/ARM is going to become an important platform, just like WinNT/PowerPC and Alpha never went anywhere.
- groovy2shoes 15y agoThey don't really exist yet (in the general availability sense of existence), because no Win8 device really exists yet (Win8 hasn't gone gold). The point is that they will exist, and if manufacturers plan on supporting Win8, they'll have to put the bootloader locks on. Once a Win8 device, always a Win8 device. (Though I'm not convinced at this point that people won't be able to hack their ways around it).
- cooldeal 15y agoAnother honest question, are alternative browsers allowed on Chromebooks running ChromeOS?
- Karunamon 15y agoThey're not disallowed, if that's what you mean. You flip a switch on the back in order to enable developer mode, and then you can do whatever you want with the machine. There are already a couple of Ubuntu releases for Chromebooks.
- luser001 15y agoWhat about without flipping the switch? What (security?) do you give up by moving to developer mode?
- cube13 15y ago"Sure, if you install OS" is always the wrong answer to "Can you run X?" The answer, apparently, is no, you cannot run Firefox with CromeOS. You can root the device and install it manually, but I'm not sure how well that works. MS is doing the exact same thing as Apple with iOS Safari and Google with ChromeOS. Not sure why they're evil here, but oh well.
- Karunamon 15y ago>You can root the device and install it manually Some clarification is in order here. Flipping an explicitly provided and documented switch is not "rooting" the device. That carries the connotations of hacking around some form of enforced security getting in your way. And yes you can install it manually without hacking the OS... It's just a form of Linux after all. Go bug Firefox and get them to offer a package that works with the OS if this is too much trouble. Now, is your problem that they don't go out of their way to add compatability for random third party packages on a cloud based OS? You're not the target market, then :P
- cube13 15y ago
- eighthNote 15y agoFor Windows RT, is iOS the standard of comparison, or is Windows 8? We were excited that Windows for ARM was going to be a full OS, rather than a mobile one. Microsoft will be offering tablets with the full Windows 8 via x86 tablets in addition to the ARM ones with Windows RT. In other words, there will be a full OS in direct competition with a crippled/mobile version, and they will look exactly the same. In the end, consumers will buy Windows RT tablets, expecting Windows 8, only to realize that they can't run their preferred programs such as Firefox or Chrome, and Microsoft and Windows 8 on the whole will come out looking really bad.
- mletterle 15y agoWell, it'd be nice to see Microsoft try to make something that's an alternative to how iOS does things, for one. For two, this part worries me: "Note that Windows 8 for x86/x64 has similar restrictions for applications distributed via their Windows Store." I think that's actually a far bigger deal.
- wvenable 15y agoHonest question: How do you miss the constant bitching about the walled garden of iOS? The endless articles complaining about the lack of emulators, development tools, and yes even browsers. There was even a period 2 years ago with dozens of articles about how Firefox would never be available for iOS. The sudden care about Windows 8 now is because it's about to be released and developers are just now starting to work on it.
- mikeash 15y agoI think the pertinent question is, does .NET get to JIT? If so, you're right, same basic situation as iOS. But if .NET doesn't get to JIT either, then you have the OS vendor's flagship language/platform being crippled by this policy. Apple doesn't support any managed language on iOS (Objective-C is purely compiled ahead of time), and so the lack of JIT doesn't hurt iOS apps developed with the officially supported language.
- recoiledsnake 15y ago>...OS vendor's flagship language/platform being crippled by this policy Are you referring to performance? If so, WinRT supports C++. http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/windows/apps/hh441569(v=vs.110).aspx http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/windows/apps/hh44156...
- mikeash 15y agoYes, performance. And I never doubted that it supports C++, but the point is that it also officially supports C# which, if it can't be JITted, will take a nasty hit. iOS has no equivalent to C#, since the only officially supported languages are compiled ahead of time.
- contextfree 15y agoCLR works as it always has, i.e. uses JIT compilation.
- randomfool 15y agoNot necessarily- CLR could ngen on install. I'd actually say this is most likely. You get a hit on install times but after that startup times get much better. Getting fast app launch times are incredibly important.