3 ms·
Sorry, but the "creator economy" is a mostly-malicious delusion. Sure, it can sound great. And for a very lucky few it probably is great. But the 99% reality
by bell-cot 3y ago
Sorry, but the "creator economy" is a mostly-malicious delusion. Sure, it can sound great. And for a very lucky few it probably is great. But the 99% reality is that it's just hype from techo-utopians, wanna-be's, get-rich-quick salesmen, and a bunch of mega-corporate platforms - whose profits are built on the backs of virtual-slave "creator" labor.
(Yes, maybe this is a bit too cynical. Maybe. A bit.)
- meheleventyone 3y agoI see parallels to the AppStore where the dynamics are similar but the return on spending money to attract attention works much more effectively. Basically discovery is totally screwed because the stores/platforms are oversaturated and no one has figured out a sensible way to curate content in an algorithmic manner. The only thing left is to be a first mover, already have a big audience elsewhere or to be able to pay for eyeballs and focus on retention and monetization metrics to get costs below revenue. For the average “gig work” creator the latter is basically out of reach whereas mobile games spend hundreds of millions of dollars on customer acquisition and got incredibly sad when the privacy changes Apple made reduced the effectiveness of ad tracking.
- bell-cot 3y agoYep. Ignoring stuff like charity raffles, I first saw such dynamics back in the 1980's, with this - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Platonia_dilemma#Luring_Lottery https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Platonia_dilemma#Luring_Lotter... (in Scientific American, back when it was actually respectable). A huge-sounding jackpot, seemingly available to anyone with a postcard and a bit of luck...but that ain't how human nature actually works. A zillion wanna-be's entered, and nobody received enough money to even cover the cost of their postcard.
- pompino 3y agoThat is true, but I'd say that its no different when you're starting any new venture by yourself with the goal of being sustainable. The entertainment business is rough, but it's even harder to sell tangible goods/services and deal with customers, investors, accounting, inventory, shipping, and everybody expecting the perfect shit from you "bEcAuSe tHiS oThEr mEgAcORp dOeS iT". It comes full circle because ultimately you need eyeballs to sell your shit, and its awfully nice when you have creators with an audience, who they can convince to stand in line with an open wallet for the shiny widget that you made. Let me one up you on the cynicism :P
- bell-cot 3y ago> ...no different when you're starting any new venture by yourself with the goal of... Perhaps...but in a healthy economy, >99.9% of jobs are not "start a new venture by yourself, trying to sell to the whole world".
- pompino 3y agoI don't know what your definition of healthy economy is. 90% of startups fail, but people still do it. Is that healthy? Aside - The numbers are a lot more sane than I thought. I think its close to 50% the number of young people who want to become creators or think that being a creator is a viable choice for a career.
- vintermann 3y agoLong before the internet age, it has been the case that there are far, far more people wanting to do creative stuff full-time than there is market support for it. And yes, various vultures who try to make money from this fact - but don't overestimate how much they contribute to artist poverty, compared to supply glut.
- DoreenMichele 3y agoSome people want to do something they believe in or can do which they have reason to believe other people get value out of and they reasonably think that they should be able to support themselves. If they add value, people should tip or whatever so they get something back for making your life better. Monetization has been a hot button topic on HN for a long time. The HN crowd more or less hates any means to monetize content while also decrying the decline in quality writing. And it's not just HN. Journalism is dying. Small town newspapers are going extinct. And then people complain about the poor quality of reporting when the people doing the reporting are typically paid a pittance. I don't know the solution. I took HN's advice and "tried to get a real job" at some point and that didn't solve my problems either. I didn't get the job is the short version of stupid levels of drama.
- xetplan 3y agoThis is obviously true. You just don't see all the people that are getting 50 views per video. It is really just a type of more dispersed state lottery game without the state involved.
- zrn900 3y agoAnd how is that any different anywhere else in the modern economy... At least with the creator economy, content creation (including software) is more democratized and distributed.
- rchaud 3y agoAgreed, the power laws of online content consumption means that the top 10% of creators will accumulate most of the paying suscribers. "Creator Economy" is a term akin to "Gold Rush", in the sense that it's pushed by VCs looking to sell shovels in the form of a Patreon or Substack.