3 ms·
hopefully we can agree that tarquin was roman? caesar had control over a very different territory than tarquin, very different styles of art, and a very differ
by kragen 3y ago
hopefully we can agree that tarquin was roman?
caesar had control over a very different territory than tarquin, very different styles of art, and a very different government and military than tarquin, and although he spoke tarquin's language, his subjects mostly didn't speak sabine and etruscan like tarquin's subjects did. i think you can make a case that basileios's government was a lot more similar to caesar's than caesar's was to gaius marcius rutilus's; certainly the justification caesar's assassins gave for killing him was that his government was uniquely un-roman
so sure, ship of theseus, but that didn't start with caesar. caesar was already five centuries of radical changes past tarquin (who also barely had a foothold in italy) and seven centuries after the mythological romulus
- acjohnson55 3y agoWeren't the Tarquins Etruscans?
- kragen 3y agooriginally, yeah
- acjohnson55 3y agoRight, so even pre-Republic, the Roman purity test is kind of problematic.
- kragen 3y agoagreed
- mcmoor 3y agoI guess it can already be argued that Roman Kingdom != Roman Republic != Roman Empire. And if we continue this logic even further, they are all != Eastern Roman Empire. But the name itself is a source of pride and everyone after still wants to claim that they're continuation of it, so much that we have more than one ship of Theseus by the end.
- kragen 3y agoi don't. fuck the romans. all of them, as well as anyone who aspires to be like them