3 ms·
Nope! It states you opened a door and then Monty opened a door. It does not state that Monty would have opened a door if you had picked a different one. If t
by jncfhnb 3y ago
Nope!
It states you opened a door and then Monty opened a door.
It does not state that Monty would have opened a door if you had picked a different one.
If this is not communicated you don’t gain any knowledge from his reveal.
The typical proper Monty hall formula states this assumption clearly that he will always open a goat door. The original one does not state this.
- tshaddox 3y agoI don’t disagree that adding “always” to every clause of the problem statement technically makes it less ambiguous.