4 ms·

nvm

• topaz0 3y ago
  Actually it does matter. If you lose automatically when a car is shown, that will happen in 1/3 of games: none of the times your first pick was a car (0 * 1/3 = 0), half of the times your first pick was a goat (1/2 * 2/3 = 1/3). The remaining 2/3 are equally split between the times you chose a car first (which are guaranteed to complete) and the times you chose a goat first and MH randomly chose the other goat rather than the car. (Note: this analysis does depend on the constraint that MH doesn't open your first pick door! Edit: actually the answer also becomes equal odds if he can pick any door, regardless of whether it was your first pick or the car. In that case, 1/3 of games will not complete, and the rest will be 50/50 between the unopened doors.)
• graeme 3y ago
  Monty never shows the car. That was stated in the original reply from Marilyn, and it should be obvious to anyone who's watched a game show. Why on earth would monty open a door, show you the prize (which you now can't get) and then ask you if you want to switch your door? No one would design a game show like that, so it means the question only has sense if interpreted as "Monty always opens a goat door".