3 ms·
There are probably a lot of people at this point who have never watched one of these types of game shows. Maybe if they thought about it, they'd realize that MH
by ghaff 3y ago
There are probably a lot of people at this point who have never watched one of these types of game shows. Maybe if they thought about it, they'd realize that MH probably will always show a goat but it wasn't explicit in the initial question that Marilyn answered.
Certainly, that constraint is important to the final solution.
- topaz0 3y agoI guess my point is that in the inevitable arguments, whether they are in advice columns or HN comment threads or around dinner tables, sometimes seem to their participants to be about how math works, when they're really about the problem description. Sometimes the disagreement amounts to "I agree that those constraints make sense and I wasn't properly accounting for them" and other times it amounts to "I was actually picturing a scenario where MH might have shown you a car". Either is ok, and there might be room for more discussion after getting there, but it feels like a big waste for either of these to get confused with a fruitless argument where both sides think the other is just doing the math wrong.
- andrewla 3y agoNo, he wouldn't always open a door -- sometimes he'd offer a trade; like "you can take $1,000 cash from me now, or have your door". I wonder if anyone has gone through every episode of "Let's Make a Deal" where this scenario occurs and look at the empirical distribution of switch/not-switch.