6 ms·
I really wonder who takes the plane when a train does it in under 2.5 hours... It feels very, very hard to be faster than 2.5 hours with a plane to go pretty mu
by palata 3y ago
I really wonder who takes the plane when a train does it in under 2.5 hours... It feels very, very hard to be faster than 2.5 hours with a plane to go pretty much anywhere (including going to the airport, check-in, security check, boarding, flight, and going to the city from the destination airport).
So yeah, 2.5 hours seems ridiculous. 4h made much more sense, because many people consider that a 4h journey in the train is "very long" and won't do it. Spoiler: it is actually really fine, and it would have been good to force people to realize it.
- novia 3y agoIt is often cheaper in the US to fly than to take the train. If it is the same in Spain, it might have been price conscious consumers.
- jncfhnb 3y agoIt’s not like the US passenger trains have the capacity to absorb those fliers though. I’m guessing Spain is the same…
- vidarh 3y ago> I’m guessing Spain is the same… Spain has massively expanded a high-speed rail network in recent years, and now has the largest high-speed rail network in Europe, and second longest in the world after China. A lot of that has been built separately to the pre-existing rail network, and so has added a lot of additional capacity.
- Manuel_D 3y agoThe US often has cities spaced too far apart to make trains effective. The one exception is the Northeast corridor, which consequently does have a passenger rail line.
- vidarh 3y agoVery few rail corridors in the US are so sparsely populated that they can't be as cost-effective as in Europe, with the caveat that this doesn't mean cheap - a whole lot of European routes are heavily subsidised. E.g. even the old closed Amtrak corridor through Southern Montana would today serve more people than some perfectly viable routes in Norway, over a similar stretch (and there is work underway to try to resurrect it). But flights are often cheaper in Europe too despite subsidies for rail. Outside of the busiest corridors trains works best in those places where it's competing with cars or buses, not planes.
- theluketaylor 3y ago> But flights are often cheaper in Europe too despite subsidies for rail That's because intra-EU flights are also highly subsidized, especially around taxes for fuel. Decades ago the EU punted on the complex topic of charging taxes on avgas and that is a key contributor to the existence of cheap airlines like ryanair.
- redeeman 3y ago> That's because intra-EU flights are also highly subsidized, especially around taxes for fuel. okay, so by not taking money from them, we are... giving them money?
- novia 3y agoWhy not just remove the subsidies for domestic flights that are 2.5 hours away by train instead of banning them?
- acdha 3y agoIt’s not fast enough any more. The fossil fuel companies were successful at preventing action for decades and in the intervening half century multiple generations of people have grown accustomed to cheap air travel. Making it more expensive will gradually reduce usage but that’s a slow process and there are a number of companies which didn’t even exist back when the science denial campaign started who would be trying their hardest to slow it down.
- theluketaylor 3y agoThe CityNerd youtube channel recently did a list of city pairs ideally suited for high speed rail based on Spain's own network. spoiler alert: the northeast corridor plays a pretty heavy part, but it's not the only place in the US high speed rail makes a ton of sense. Highly recommended. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wE5G1kTndI4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wE5G1kTndI4
- Cheer2171 3y agoNope. City distance in the continental US excluding the Northeast is similar to China. Distance is just the excuse.
- Manuel_D 3y agoThis is not even remotely true. China has 4x the population in roughly the same landmass. And most of that is concentrated in the eastern part of the country (Tibet and inner Mongolia are sparsely populated, but very large). I'd be very, very interested in where you found this claim that China's cities have the same average distance between them as US cities. Wouldn't be surprised if they used totally different criteria for a Chinese city and a US city. I would be astounded if the median distance between cities of >500k people is the same in China as in the USA.
- vidarh 3y agoI have no idea about how reasonable or not their claim is, but I'd note that most of the US population is, while not concentrated only in the East, concentrated heavily. Even in most the lower population density states, most of the population is within tiny part of the area of those states, often in corridors where most of the larger towns are still relatively close to at least a few other large towns. So whether or not they're right, distance largely is an excuse. Trains will not work between every pair of cities in the US, but it doesn't need to - very few US cities are so isolated that train will not work to several nearby cities. The average distance isn't very important, as long as the cities are clustered enough to create viable lines.
- Manuel_D 3y agoMeasuring average distance between cities is incredibly naive, that's my whole point. If countries A and B both have 100 cities in the sam land area, except country A has 50 cities over 1 million people and country B only has 10 cities over 1 million then one of these is still much more viable even if average distance between cities is the same. You're right that if all 10 of those larg cities in country A are really close then it may be viable. But that's not the case in America, save for the Northeast corridor which is already served by passenger rail.
- beretguy 3y agoI’m from US. I didn’t know we have passenger trains.
- mandeepj 3y ago> I didn’t know we have passenger trains. Amtrak
- kjkjadksj 3y agoAnd much faster. It takes almost a full day to take amtrak from the west coast to denver. Not much has changed since the transcontinental railroad opened I guess.
- raybb 3y agoBarcelona to Madrid flights are around 10-20 euros and 1.5 hours (in the air). The train is 20-100ish euros and takes about 2.5 hours. Though many trains are a hair over 2.5 hours so maybe that's exempt from this plan. Wonder what leads to trains costing more than flights like that.
- beretguy 3y agoThat pricing feels backwards.
- chgs 3y agoAirlines don’t pay their externalities
- bsder 3y agoIt may feel backwards, but it is real. While we never saw the 20 Euro airplane fares, for some reason the train fares were almost always more 20-50 Euros more expensive than the plane fares given the same lead times. It was quite irritating.
- verzali 3y agoSpeaking from experience, the 10-20 euro fares are not always available on flights. But then again, cheap fares are not always available on the trains either, especially at the times most people want to travel (Friday or Sunday evenings, etc). Also flying takes longer because the airports are not as central as the train stations, and you need to go through more luggage checks, board with more time to spare etc. I think competition has helped drive down flight prices, and since they opened the Madrid-Barcelona high speed line to competition prices have dropped a lot for the train as well. If you compare Madrid-Barcelona to Madrid-Sevilla for example, the price difference is really high and much more than the distance would imply.
- georgeplusplus 3y agoTrain systems are basically governement monopolies and thus run super inefficiently.
- vidarh 3y agoKeep in mind they're not leaving from or going to the same places - usually. Depending on where you live/travel relative to the aiport vs. train station the numbers can come out very differently. E.g. I live in London - a train or plane* going from the "wrong" station/airport both adds about 1h15m in travel compared to a train or plane going from the nearest station or airport, and that difference could be substantially bigger if I lived a little bit further south. Do that both ends, and suddenly that plane starts looking more attractive to a lot of people. I'd personally still tend to prefer the train in a lot of circumstances even when it's not the fastest option, because I do agree it's fine.
- palata 3y ago> I'd personally still tend to prefer the train in a lot of circumstances even when it's not the fastest option, because I do agree it's fine. I now have gotten used to spend 10 hours on a train trip. I can work most of the time, so it's basically a work day. More than 10 hours starts to be a lot, though.
- kjkjadksj 3y agoPrivate jet users routinely shuttle their planes a few dozen miles to more personally convenient airports in the area. The celebrity plane tracker accounts have put a lot of focus on this sort of usage.
- The_Colonel 3y agoTransfers... You're already in the airport, getting to the railway station will take time.
- lxgr 3y agoMany airports in Europe already have high-speed connections and reasonably short walking times to the gate, but the real issue is liability for missed connections: In Germany, Lufthansa and German railways have had a cooperation called "Rail & Fly" for many years now, and they even assign IATA "flight" numbers to some trains and (I believe) allow checking baggage through in some instances. But last time I used it, the ticketing conditions said that it was my responsibility to take an early-enough train and allow for three hours of buffer, or I'd risk having to pay for a lost connection out of pocket. That's compared to connections of as little as 45 minutes when changing planes in the same terminal. Airlines are incentivized to make that connection if at all possible, since they have to pay a compensation for any delays of more than three hours in the EU, including delays for missed connections.
- The_Colonel 3y agoI mostly fly from Vienna, Prague and Budapest and none of them have fast rail connection. I think this is a hard problem, since the rail lines naturally converge in the city, at the airport you'll get one rail line at best and quite likely need to change in the city again.
- lxgr 3y agoVienna airport is definitely serviced by Railjet trains (Austrian railways' high-speed product) stopping directly at the airport railway station. The same is true for Frankfurt am Main (one of the largest airports in Europe, serviced by ICE trains from all over Germany). The point here is to replace a shuttle flight from a hub to a satellite airport of an airline/alliance, and for that to make sense, there needs to be both high-speed rail infrastructure from a given city to such a hub airport, and a train station at the hub airport.
- coldtea 3y ago>I really wonder who takes the plane when a train does it in under 2.5 hours... People who know the plane is cheaper. Didn't use to be, but the cut-throat budget airlines and the greed and privitization of train networks made it so.
- awesomeMilou 3y ago> People who know the plane is cheaper. And almost always on time. And won't get cancelled as often... People like flying because unlike railways services, it's a method of transport you can actually rely on.
- noahtallen 3y agoSpanish high speed rail is incredibly reliable and normally on time. Not really a concern.
- The_Colonel 3y agoI don't know how it in Spain (but I heard their rail system is good), but in my country it's the opposite. Trains sometimes have small-ish delays of 5-60 minutes, but longer delays are rare and there are usually other trains running the same route, so you can easily switch (for free if it's the same company). I've never experienced a cancelled train. With airplane, you often get these small delays as well, but there's also the risk of a very long delay. I had the pleasure of waiting 12 hours for a (connecting) 50 minute flight.
- cafard 3y agoThere have been summers in the US when "almost always on time" was a real stretch.
- awesomeMilou 3y agoTo clarify, I was talking specifically about domestic flights within EU countries. Here in Germany you're often paying about double for a train ticket, even if you book early.
- 3y ago
- snicky 3y ago> It feels very, very hard to be faster than 2.5 hours with a plane to go pretty much anywhere Unless you are already at the airport, transferring.
- danielfoster 3y agoA bus is a reasonable alternative to a 2.5-hour train ride, but would be too long to really compete with a 4-hour train ride. If the law were extended to 4 hours, then trains would have a monopoly on these journeys and consumers would suffer.
- palata 3y ago> then trains would have a monopoly on these journeys and consumers would suffer. Trains should be public, that's all.
- camillomiller 3y agoI don’t think that in Germany or Italy that’s even possible. Either travel times are longer, or you just don’t have any airport option. Spain is big though, and has a lot of smaller airports. Wonder how many flights this would affect, and what the actual potential impact in CO2 reduction is.