5 ms·
> As mentioned, most of the world doesn't apply US standards and laws. EU environmental protection rules are, generally, rather stricter than those in the US,
by rsynnott 3y ago
> As mentioned, most of the world doesn't apply US standards and laws.
EU environmental protection rules are, generally, rather stricter than those in the US, and Europe does mostly manage to build proper train systems (though not nuclear plants, unless one happens to be France).
It's worth noting that the US has no particular problem building _roads_, visiting from Europe, as a country it seems to be about 50% road. I don't think environmental rules are as big a factor as you think they are in the US's train-y woes.
EDIT: An interesting point of comparison might be Ireland; like the US, Ireland is a wealthy country which can't build infrastructure to save its life. It has pretty much the same environmental rules as other highly-developed European countries, but hyper-local politics and extreme NIMBYism makes doing anything impossible.
There's a proposal at the moment to build a high-speed (ie 300km/h) line from Cork to Dublin to Belfast, but it's more or less tacitly acknowledged that that's the sort of thing you just can't do here, so there is a parallel plan, which may actually happen, to upgrade the existing Cork to Dublin line to fake high speed (ie 200km/h); this is kind of within the realm of the possible in Ireland, in that it doesn't require a new line, so may eventually happen at huge expense. Sound familiar?
- sarchertech 3y agoThe US appears to be 50% road due to sampling bias because you travel everywhere by road. The US also also has far more freight rail per capita than the EU. It’s less a matter of who is better at building rail, than it is prioritizing freight over passengers.
- trelane 3y agoKinda. If "road" includes parking, they're not that far off, hyperbole aside. https://parkingreform.org/resources/parking-lot-map/ https://parkingreform.org/resources/parking-lot-map/
- rsynnott 3y agoSo, funny thing. Most of my experience of the US has been San Francisco and its immediate area. From my perspective, it's very road-oriented, and has an astonishing amount of space given over to parking; giant tech company offices and new apartment blocks are side by side with massive parking lots. You just don't really see that much in large European cities. Anyway, looks like it's 3% based on that map (though the area I was primarily thinking of falls just outside their definition of 'central', I think), compared to _26%_ for Atlanta. I'm having trouble visualising what that even looks like.
- sarchertech 3y agoI went to school right in the middle of that map. It’s very selectively picked to get to 26%. The boundary includes a very small percentage of the city which happens to house a large sports stadiums, local and federal government buildings, a large hospital, and one of the largest universities in the country that is primarily a commuter school. Also the map seems to count some of the underground parking at GSU as taking up space above ground.
- sarchertech 3y agoI don’t think they are talking about parking because parking has nothing to do with a government being able to build roads vs rails. Parking essentially has none of the problems of building across the boundaries of multiple land owners that makes building a road or rail difficult. Even if you do count roads if you move that boundary out just a little the number will drastically drop. It’s essentially a boundary drawn around some government buildings, sports arenas, and one of the largest Universities in the world which also happens to be a commuter school (I went there for undergrad btw).
- rayiner 3y ago> EU environmental protection rules are, generally, rather stricter than those in the US, and Europe does mostly manage to build proper train systems It’s not a question of US laws being stricter (i.e. more protective of the environment), but rather requiring a process that is more onerous and expensive. In France, for example, the government does whatever environmental review is appropriate in deciding whether to build something. It then passes a law to build the thing, which preempts all local laws that could hold up building of the thing. Once the decision has been made, you can’t easily sue to stop the project in its tracks. In the US, the government’s decision to build something is just the first step in a process that involves many layers of review and phases of litigation that takes years before you can start digging.