8 ms·
For Car Thieves, Toronto Is a 'Candy Store,' and Drivers Are Fed Up
- bookofjoe 3y agohttps://archive.ph/BUjPI https://archive.ph/BUjPI
- Kenji 3y ago[dead]
- anonymousDan 3y agoSurely the car manufacturers must share some responsibility here? It's not like they weren't forewarned about the security issues with keyless systems by academic security research.
- gambiting 3y agoIn the UK basically what happened was that Range Rovers became literally uninsurable in London, so I guess it started finally hurting their bottom line and they had to do something about it - JLR announced a program for free security improvements for owners(including replacing the entire keyless system for a more modern one) as well as their own insurance offering so that owners could actually continue driving the cars they bought. So as always, car manufacturers are willing to do something about it if it starts hurting them financially. I'm surprised the same thing isn't happening here - how are people on Toronto getting their cars insured if theft is so rampant?
- simonsarris 3y agoIt's truly bizarre how pro-crime you'd have to be to allow this to continue, but it seems like a common position in some western countries. People will try to blame literally any other part of a formerly high trust society (the owners, the car manufacturers, etc) before coming down on the criminals. A concerted team of less than 50 people with a budget for costumes and a couple cars and surveillance tech should be able to put an end to most of it. This is one of the most interesting parts: > But the police in Ottawa stumbled on it when an officer noticed a Range Rover being backed into a shipping container on a rural property. A second car in the container was Mr. Elworthy’s Ferrari. > “I was absolutely ecstatic when I got the call from that officer,” he said. “I was literally jumping up and down.” What happened to the shipping container? Who owned the rural property? Who was working with that person? Where was the shipping container going? Did they catch more than one person in this operation or what?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- akamaka 3y agoThere’s no need to invent some pro-crime society narrative, it just took time to investigate: https://www.thestar.com/news/crime/project-mamba-york-police-bust-auto-theft-ring-run-by-prolific-crime-group/article_80a00078-b949-11ee-9fa0-6f9e992754ce.amp.html https://www.thestar.com/news/crime/project-mamba-york-police...
- BrentOzar 3y agoI had to laugh at the photos of "high end luxury vehicles" - Subarus.
- surge 3y agoSome DA's are absolutely pro crime and you find out its the same small number of ppl stealing cars and getting released after charges are dropped or reduced after they've gotten caught.
- simonsarris 3y agoThat's some answers. It's surprising that the NYtimes article didn't at least say they ultimately arrested 11 people and recovered almost 100 vehicles. Though it's also surprising they don't give an idea of the scale, either (over 11,000 carjackings a year, not mentioned in either article).
- Zigurd 3y agoIt's good they finally, in one city (Montreal has a similar problem), caught a theft ring. But this success just highlights the lack of action against crime that has scaled up to a business. Bicycle theft at scale - easy to find on Craigslist in any college town, corrupt ramp employees at airports steal from checked bags, etc. This stuff is obvious. Yet it goes on and on. Are police resources unbalanced and if a patrol cop can't bluster his way to an arrest it just doesn't happen? Are cops themselves too corrupt and afraid that overtime and detail fraud would start being investigated? What keeps economically significant crime in business?
- michaelt 3y agoI thought modern cars all had built-in immobilisers and chips in the keys? A few years back I was reading reports saying that car theft had dropped substantially as it was nigh-impossible to move a car without the key, to the point thieves were even resorting to breaking into homes to get the car keys.
- bitexploder 3y agoKey fob cloning attacks on many nicer cars, like say Ford Raptor. Cheaper cars with easy to physically defeat systems.
- nervousvarun 3y agoNSIS..but if you are, all of that tech is circumvented if the key is cloned...which is increasingly easy to do (TFA mentions this when it talks about storing keys in a Faraday cage): https://www.cbsnews.com/newyork/news/security-experts-police-offer-advice-on-how-to-prevent-keyless-car-thefts/ https://www.cbsnews.com/newyork/news/security-experts-police...
- LanceH 3y agoAnd yet it costs $400 to replace your key at Toyota. These guys should not be stealing cars, they should be selling replacement keys if it's that easy.
- gambiting 3y agoWell it got very easy to do for a while with the early keyless tech, then it got very hard or impossible again recently with the advent of certain tech. In particular the "relay" attacks are now impossible with the advent of UWB tech in keys as Time of Flight response can be measured accurately enough that a relay won't work. Some of it got better with some really brain dead improvement to security - like just making the keys sleep and not respond to commands if they haven't been moved for more than 10 seconds, that alone eliminated the entire model of stealing cars from people's driveways by just using a relay with a key inside the house. Unfortunately thieves always seem to be a step ahead and figure out things like location of CAN buses to connect diagnostic equipment and clone keys that way, that's why you sometimes hear about cars with ripped out headlamps because there is a CAN bus connector behind them.
- Ligma123 3y agoIt's not just car theft. Same happens in stores in specific states of the US. Obviously there's no patterns to be recognized in there. Nothing whatsoever. Move along citizen.
- sbdaman 3y agoSorry?
- bookofjoe 3y ago>What's really going on with San Francisco Walgreens closures? https://www.sfgate.com/bay-area-politics/article/San-Francisco-Walgreens-closure-retail-theft-16533142.php https://www.sfgate.com/bay-area-politics/article/San-Francis... https://archive.ph/5Qp13 https://archive.ph/5Qp13
- wonderwonder 3y agoSeems pretty clear Quotes from the article you posted: "FBI data from 2017 showed that of the 20 biggest cities in the United States, San Francisco had the highest rate of property crimes per capita" "Walgreens could argue that the level of retail theft in San Francisco remains so high that year-over-year decreases are not moving the needle and operating in San Francisco remains unprofitable" another link in the article: SF ranks high in property crime while it ranks low in arrests https://archive.ph/MJO1C https://archive.ph/MJO1C
- yread 3y agoJust looked into it recently, internet is full of stories like https://www.kiaownersclub.co.uk/threads/warning-to-kia-owners-also-nissan-mitsubishi-hyundai-cars-stolen-without-relay-using-gameboy-device-security-breach.74382/page-5#post-514783 https://www.kiaownersclub.co.uk/threads/warning-to-kia-owner... Here is one paper describing how shit is car security "We discovered that Kia and Hyundai immobiliser keys have only three bytes of entropy" https://tches.iacr.org/index.php/TCHES/article/view/8546/8111 https://tches.iacr.org/index.php/TCHES/article/view/8546/811... It literally takes <1 minute to steal the car https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PQPMbYUOrwk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PQPMbYUOrwk
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- debacle 3y agoCashless bail, dead neighborhoods, and an overwhelmed law enforcement system have led to this. The barrier to be arrested and held with even cash bail, let alone without bail, is startlingly high.
- Zigurd 3y agoCops are the biggest or second biggest line item in most municipalities. It is more likely a problem of misallocation where crime that is actually economically significant gets short shrift because cops stay busy with activities that don't have a positive effect.
- tastyfreeze 3y agoOr a DA that doesn't prosecute "low level" crimes. No point in making an arrest if all you are doing is giving the a ride across town.
- Zigurd 3y agoA massive car theft ring isn't "lower level crime." That's the problem. Cops seem to have a difficult time identifying crime that scaled up in a way that matters.
- debacle 3y agoI think part of the problem is that you can't properly contextualize the issue without badmouthing police. Most police, like most people, are good and want to do good. The US (and likely many other countries) is being plagued by activist DAs who see letting crime slide as a form of restorative justice.
- Zigurd 3y agoIn many PDs, "most" is debatable. Do a quick experiment: in how many cases of police misconduct did the other cops in the PD with together to remove a miscreant among them, compared with the cases of cover-up, collusion, delay, denial, etc.? Do a search. What's the prevalent case?
- yodon 3y agoAre people that excited about remote keyfobs that no manufacturer will go back to conventional keys that need to be physically inserted in the lock? The advantages of physically inserting the key in the lock are so numerous.
- gambiting 3y agoI mean, yes, obviously yes. Even ignoring fully keyless solutions, having a remote key is a massive quality of life improvement, I can't imagine going back to a car where you have to put the key in the door. And just having a remote key is not really a security risk, the problem starts with keyless-start systems, but even those have been mostly resolved now with most recent tech.
- LeifCarrotson 3y agoIt's fascinating that it's obvious to you! I travel a lot for work and drive a lot of rentals with giant fobs and keyless start. It's just not that great. The fobs are bulky and heavy. My pants pockets are neither baggy nor tight, but the fob is more bulky and awkward than my wallet or phone, and doesn't fit a pocket with either. You still have to handle it, the fob just goes in a cupholder instead of into the receiver in the steering column, and you start by pushing a button instead of turning a key. I just don't perceive any advantage to a remote. Many rentals get a bulky cable with the valet key and the fob and the rental tag, but you have to disassemble the door handle and remove the plastic cover clip thing to insert the key, and I miss my 2003 Vibe back home, with the simple, flat, light, mechanical key. Insert and turn to unlock. That, a house key, and a Tile or Airtag fit on a split ring in a pocket next to my wallet and weigh less than 40g. My bag has a big ring with all the other keys that one accumulates, but I really, really value being able to travel light. When do you find value in the ability to lock or unlock the car from a distance? If it's unlocked and you want to lock it, just lock it instead of walking 30 feet away and then trying to lock it. If you are going back to the car and want to unlock it, wait 10 seconds until your hand is at the door handle and then unlock it.
- Eddy_Viscosity2 3y ago
- dreamcompiler 3y agoThe fact that modern cars can be stolen at all is ridiculous. Hanlon's Razor only goes so far; this has to be malice either on the part of the car companies (because every theft results in a new sale) or the insurance companies getting a kickback from the thieves. The solution is regulatory penalties and/or higher insurance premiums that have to be paid by the manufacturer until their cars are certified by something like the UL as having their security systems designed by somebody who went to college. But of course what will happen is the politicians will ban Flipper Zero and call the job done.
- ChrisArchitect 3y agoRelated: Canadian government banning Flipper Zero to combat auto theft https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39308731 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39308731
- pbmonster 3y ago> Whenever Dennis Wilson wants to take a drive in his new SUV, he has to set aside an extra 15 minutes. That’s about how long it takes to remove the car’s steering wheel club, undo four tire locks and lower a yellow bollard before backing out of his driveway. At that point, why not just disconnect the spark plugs or wire up an electric switch into the starter motor/fuel pump cabling. No way those thieves pop the hood and troubleshoot your car for 15 minutes if it doesn't start. People really treat their cars like magic boxes. And if some wizard has the key to the magic box, their first thought is to build a wall around it...
- secstate 3y agoI wonder how many people in 2024 don't know what a spark plug is, or how their car works at all. I don't mean that in a snarky way, it just seems like increasingly people treat modern technology like magic rather than something that does a thing easier than if you tried to do it manually. Makes me appreciate the Amish perspective on technology [0] more the older I get. [0] https://www.wired.com/story/virtually-amish-hacking-innovation/ https://www.wired.com/story/virtually-amish-hacking-innovati...