7 ms·
Clouds vanish during a solar eclipse
- hilbert42 3y agoI have seen three total solar eclipses and some partial ones. Before every one of these total eclipses the weather was either overcast or had been raining beforehand and there was much angst amongst us onlookers that we'd miss it. But we didn't, the clouds parted and each one was a magnificent and awe-inspiring spectacle. Not only did the clouds part but it got noticeably cold.
- Arubis 3y agoPerhaps more interesting than the ostensible subject of this article is the casual acceptance of planet-scale geoengineering as a likely near- to mid-term occurrence and starting to think through some potentially unanticipated side-effects.
- tenthirtyam 3y ago"Nightfall" by Asimov is a great short story related to solar eclipses. https://www.astro.sunysb.edu/fwalter/AST389/TEXTS/Nightfall.htm https://www.astro.sunysb.edu/fwalter/AST389/TEXTS/Nightfall....
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- kurthr 3y agoClouds can also form during the start of an eclipse, especially near a coastline or ridgeline where humidity is near dewpoint before temperatures fall. This describes how thermally driven cumulus clouds disappear. However, I'd also say that another big effect is that the sun simply isn't there to illuminate the light cloud layer. See Mauna Kea 1991: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_RIMjx8feew https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_RIMjx8feew
- beatthatflight 3y agoBeen claiming this for years - been to 3 total eclipses and found it weird how the clouds seemed to almost make way for it. Nice to see some science behind it.
- geerlingguy 3y agoIf you haven't personally witnessed a Total Solar Eclipse, and haven't seen this Smarter Every Day video, it's worth the watch: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eNK2LI7VeX4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eNK2LI7VeX4 He interviewed the guy who wrote the Solar Eclipse Timer app (https://www.solareclipsetimer.com https://www.solareclipsetimer.com) and also publishes a ton of info about eclipses in general (especially how to spot all the different interesting parts, and how to capture it on camera). That info is in a book here: https://solar-eclipse-timer.myshopify.com https://solar-eclipse-timer.myshopify.com No affiliation with either of them, just they have some of the most succinct and helpful info, especially for sharing with other people too (I hope to have my kids manage a few experiments during totality, assuming we don't get any clouds!).
- staplers 3y agoI hope to have my kids manage a few experiments during totality Honestly, don't ruin it for them. It was a spiritual experience for me and I can't imagine someone pressuring me to do something during it. First time something had genuinely taken my breath away. Felt the enormity of space and my small place in the monumental universe.
- geerlingguy 3y agoMostly for things leading up to it; during totality you just kinda look up, and that's it. The kids won't really notice much until pretty soon before totality, so it's nice to have some activity to occupy them :) Especially things like pinhole viewers to see the partial eclipse image without glasses.
- JKCalhoun 3y agoHeading to the southern end of the state or are you wandering down toward Texas?
- geerlingguy 3y agoSouthern MO. We'll risk the clouds to save a flight or a longer drive—hopefully we get clear skies! I have a friend down in Carbondale who's fortunate enough to be right in the middle of both eclipses. Was considering going there, but it'll be a larger family trip, and it was easier to load into a few hotel rooms in southern MO.
- SoftTalker 3y ago> "If we eclipse the Sun in the future with technological solutions, it may affect the clouds," he explains. "Fewer clouds could partly oppose the intended effect of climate engineering, because clouds reflect sunlight and thus actually help to cool down the Earth." The idea that we'd eclipse the sun to control the climate is just one of the dumbest scifi nerd fantasies I've ever heard. It's a good thing young idealists generally are never in positions of power to actually try their ideas.
- Der_Einzige 3y agoYou must be kidding, since the average age of the folks writing the papers pushing AI forward is likely less than 30.
- seeknotfind 3y agoYes, exactly. Lol. If you can obscure the sun, that is already cooling things down by much greater means.
- hn_throwaway_99 3y ago> The idea that we'd eclipse the sun to control the climate is just one of the dumbest scifi nerd fantasies I've ever heard. Except we basically already did it, just unintentionally. A primary hypothesized reason for the literally-off-the-charts heat of the past 15 months or so is that regulations that cleaned up the amount of sunlight-reflecting aerosols in container ship fuel was having the effect of letting more sunlight reach Earth; the idea is that the aerosols had previously been limiting the amount of global warming that would have shown up earlier. My point is that while geoengineering does sound pretty crazy at first, it feels less crazy once you realize we've already been doing geoengineering on a massive, global scale.
- mynameisvlad 3y agoWho, exactly, is hypothesizing this? Because I couldn’t find any reference to such a hypothesis.
- 3y ago
- jonathan_landy 3y agoSurprised to learn that the clouds are constantly dissipating and have to be fed new vapor from the ground to be sustained; the fact that they go away on the time scale of the eclipse suggests it’a fast process. Then again, when a plane goes by its trail seems to be gone within minutes.
- foofie 3y agoI think there are a few videos on youtube showing clouds just vanishing. I never saw that phenomenon in person but the videos were so unexpected to me that they kept me wondering if they were fake or not. But then again, who would invest so much time and effort in CGI just to show clouds vanishing?
- ImaCake 3y agoThey do this all the time in sub-tropical locations. Cooler moist air from the ocean brings clouds which dissapate over the hot dry land. Mostly you don’t see it because clouds change at just the right pace for us not to notice them changing.
- plantain 3y agoAny soaring pilot could have told you this...
- kazinator 3y ago> It's not all types of clouds, obviously; otherwise, we'd never hear complaints about eclipses being spoiled by overcast weather. Yes, why it's the eclipse-disappearing type of cloud that disperses during an eclipse, don't you know? Clouds that don't disappear are of other types. This is one of the axioms of the cloud type system which ensure its soundness.
- ajmurmann 3y agoI always finds it astonishing how quickly it gets significantly colder during an eclipse. It's so rapid that it's somewhat unintuitive that we don't freeze to death every night.
- thaumasiotes 3y agoWhy would velocity of temperature be informative about position? Assume that during an eclipse, the temperature will approach normal nighttime temperature, and stay there.
- seszett 3y agoOf course, but what the GP means is that it's a wonder that nighttime temperature isn't colder than it is, if we didn't know better (of course, we know that nighttime temperature isn't absolute zero) it wouldn't be absurd to think that since temperature goes down that fast during an eclipse that lasts a few minutes, it could reach barely above absolute zero in just an hour or so during night. But on Earth it doesn't, for many reasons that are not all that obvious or intuitive.
- thaumasiotes 3y agoBut if you're surprised by that, you should also be surprised that the surface of the earth isn't just heat-blasted stone as far as the eye can see. Unmediated temperatures occur on the moon, and they swing from around 90 K at night to around 380 K during the day. Temperatures on the surface of the earth just aren't closely related to insolation. We've got a biosphere - and an atmosphere - for that.
- kombookcha 3y agoI really, really think the first poster is expressing a sentiment about the sensory awe from experiencing an eclipse, not about a faulty and extremely literal temperature model.
- adrianN 3y ago
- trklausss 3y agoAs a glider pilot, this doesn’t surprise me at all…We are always on the lookout for those clouds and learn to interpret when they “pull” and when the cloud is dissipating (which means there is little chance of updraft under it). Also, not all cumulus come from heated floor, it could be formed by different in temperatures and pressures in upper layers that pull hotter, stationary air from below, but there is no clear updraft from the ground up to be expected (usually common post-warm fronts or in troughs).
- bloat 3y agoThey certainly didn't vanish for me in Cornwall in 1999. I hope you have better luck in the US in April!
- emursebrian 3y agoProbably high altitude clouds. An eclipse isn't going to make clouds vanish that are the result of a larger weather pattern. The air cools down so the warm moist air settles as it cools. As a result, clouds stop developing.
- gandalfian 3y agoYup, any astrological phenomenon seems to attract clouds here. The red arrows too.
- macartain 3y agoTell me about it! At least I got to see Orbital...
- openrisk 3y agoExperienced somethink like this once and it definitely added to the feeling of profound awe that comes with a total solar eclipse. Not sure it was exactly and solely this phenomenon though. It was a mostly rainy, overcast day, pressumably featuring multiple types of clouds. It may have been combined with an element of pure chance for the lower cloud layers.
- nonrandomstring 3y agoSo do the birds. Dunno if anyone else noticed this. Back in August 1999 in UK we were in a woodland clearing near the sea for the event. The sky was full of birds. When the sun dimmed, they all landed and fell silent. When the sun came back, the birds all start singing again like it was dawn. That rapid change of soundscape was both creepy and beautiful.
- ImaCake 3y agoI noticed this in Australia during the recent eclipse. It was only partial and fairly subtle in my location but the birds went into evening chorus and increased activity before resuming normal behaviour once the eclipse ended.
- BurningFrog 3y agoWhatever you do on April 7, do NOT settle for a partial eclipse! Annie Dillard said it best: "I had seen a partial eclipse in 1970. A partial eclipse is very interesting. It bears almost no relation to a total eclipse. Seeing a partial eclipse bears the same relation to seeing a total eclipse as kissing a man does to marrying him, or as flying in an airplane does to falling out of an airplane. Although the one experience precedes the other, it in no way prepares you for it." From https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2017/08/annie-dillards-total-eclipse/536148/ https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2017/08/annie-di...
- AbraKdabra 3y agoI went to see the Piedra del Águila total eclipse in Argentina (December 2020) and it was something out of this world, like really, I'm there for every partial eclipse and this experience was worth the money spent, the distance I traveled, the absurd amount of sand I've eaten that day, the heat, the sudden freezing temperatures, every negative thing before the actual eclipse was instantly vanished when I looked up and saw the ring of fire, you're suddenly not in this planet, all the people near you are screaming with tears of joy, clapping, hugs everywhere, it's just incredible. If you're in a relative near location to the path, leave everything you're doing and go see it, this is not just an astronomical event for astronomy fans, it's a social gathering to see the most amazing thing in your life.