4 ms·
As much as I foam at the mouth around here against many law enforcement actions, both parties did the right thing here. It's not like they showed up in the mid
by ck2 15y ago
As much as I foam at the mouth around here against many law enforcement actions, both parties did the right thing here.
It's not like they showed up in the middle of the night and yanked their entire servers out of the office without a warrant and covered it up under "homeland security" or other nonsense.
They did it the proper way through the courts with a judge and public documentation of their actions, and asked for only a subset of the data (limited to a year and GA).
Kudos to SparkFun for responding with caution.
That said, I think the lead will be useless to them because the person could have bought it anywhere, even outside the USA and brought it into GA. Apparently there are also clones now of sparkfun boards complete with logo.
- jsprinkles 15y agoIt went this well because no copyright was violated.
- rickmb 15y agoNot quite the right thing: the subpoena is too broad. This is very typical for law enforcement everywhere these days. Luckily SparkFun was diligent enough to negotiate it down to relevant information, but it the "gimme all your data" attitude is a fundamental problem. This also extend to seizures ("gimme all your servers", not just the ones involved). The courts should never allow this, so although this is the proper process, it is failing. There's no point in insisting law enforcement goes through the proper channels if those proper channels don't do their job properly.