3 ms·

As the others have said, your criticism is silly. If a human had done this piece, one would say they simply made an artistic choice to have the head extend bey

by qarl 3y ago

As the others have said, your criticism is silly. If a human had done this piece, one would say they simply made an artistic choice to have the head extend beyond the bubble. But just to nail this point home, here's what I get when I explicitly ask that the bubble cover the entire head: https://i.imgur.com/oizqMbU.png https://i.imgur.com/oizqMbU.png

jiggawatts 3y ago
Now its tail is outside of the suit. Sure, it’s just dead hair, but there would be no way to seal the air in around where it exits the suit. I’m as impressed as you are at the quality. Where I’m dubious is whether this confabulation problem can ever be made to completely go away. Perhaps we need much larger models that can better understand the world. I’ve always thought it weird that we use much smaller models for image generation than text generation!
- qarl 3y ago
  As the others have said, your criticism is silly.
  - jiggawatts 3y ago
    Granted, they said it silly, so it must be so.
    - qarl 3y ago
      Ok - here let me explain. It's a ridiculous situation - a horse in outer space in a space suit. But you want the image to be hyper physically accurate. That's fine, but it's a little incongruous. I wouldn't expect a human artist to be able to guess your requirements, let alone an AI. So no, I do not believe any amount of computer resources will let the AI guess your requirements. You'll have to spell them out, as I did with the bubble for you once already. If you want the tail to be enclosed as well, you'll have to spell it out. The whole point of this discussion is to determine whether the AI is simply copy/pasting images it's seen before. We've determined that it does not - it is able to synthesis new images by understanding what it's seen. Whether it can read your mind is a silly digression.
      - jiggawatts 3y ago
        “Have the protective clothing actually cover the body” is something you think a human couldn’t figure out on their own?
        qarl 3y ago
        Yes. I think an actual artist, if you simply requested "a horse in a space suit" would not think that you were worried about literally protecting a horse in space. Because, as I have repeatedly tried to explain to you, the idea of a horse in space is ridiculous and tends toward ridiculous renditions. I'm going to stop replying to you now. Have a nice day.

by qarl 3y ago

jiggawatts 3y ago

Now its tail is outside of the suit. Sure, it’s just dead hair, but there would be no way to seal the air in around where it exits the suit. I’m as impressed as you are at the quality. Where I’m dubious is whether this confabulation problem can ever be made to completely go away. Perhaps we need much larger models that can better understand the world. I’ve always thought it weird that we use much smaller models for image generation than text generation!

qarl 3y ago
As the others have said, your criticism is silly.
- jiggawatts 3y ago
  Granted, they said it silly, so it must be so.
  - qarl 3y ago
    Ok - here let me explain. It's a ridiculous situation - a horse in outer space in a space suit. But you want the image to be hyper physically accurate. That's fine, but it's a little incongruous. I wouldn't expect a human artist to be able to guess your requirements, let alone an AI. So no, I do not believe any amount of computer resources will let the AI guess your requirements. You'll have to spell them out, as I did with the bubble for you once already. If you want the tail to be enclosed as well, you'll have to spell it out. The whole point of this discussion is to determine whether the AI is simply copy/pasting images it's seen before. We've determined that it does not - it is able to synthesis new images by understanding what it's seen. Whether it can read your mind is a silly digression.
    - jiggawatts 3y ago
      “Have the protective clothing actually cover the body” is something you think a human couldn’t figure out on their own?
      - qarl 3y ago
        Yes. I think an actual artist, if you simply requested "a horse in a space suit" would not think that you were worried about literally protecting a horse in space. Because, as I have repeatedly tried to explain to you, the idea of a horse in space is ridiculous and tends toward ridiculous renditions. I'm going to stop replying to you now. Have a nice day.