4 ms·
> He eventually realized something that seems obvious to any nonacademic, that poor countries are saddled with laws and, crucially, customs that prevent new ide
by jacobolus 15y ago
> He eventually realized something that seems obvious to any nonacademic, that poor countries are saddled with laws and, crucially, customs that prevent new ideas from taking shape. [...] The United Arab Emirates, Hong Kong and Singapore were able to build well-designed cities that housed and employed millions, in part by persuading foreigners to invest heavily.
It’s really obnoxious that the author allows this facile analysis to pass without any attempt to provide context. Hong Kong and Singapore were Western colonial corporate/financial/trade centers for a giant continent which was otherwise mostly blocked off, and so were bottlenecks through which massive amounts of capital flowed (and goods: HK, Singapore, and Shanghai are the busiest ports in Asia). The UAE is a tiny country with one of the largest oil reserves in the world.
The claim that the main problem poor countries have is “customs that prevent new ideas”, as compared to – at least in the case of Honduras – 500 years of quite shocking exploitation and violence (diving into Honduran history books is not for the faint of heart), and for most the last 100 years political control by US-backed strongmen and American fruit companies and frequently the US military, as the original “banana republic”, is offensive. [He did mention that Dole/Chiquita “have controlled its agricultural exports”, but left it at that.] Cf. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Honduras#Honduras_in_the_twentieth_century http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Honduras#Honduras_in...
Disclaimer: I grew up in southern Mexico, and a couple years ago took a course on Mesoamerican colonial history from the former Honduran Minister of Culture, who fled to the US after the 2009 coup.
- its_so_on 15y agoI don't know, what you call "really obnoxious" is, I would say, par for the course in journalism - but not because that's a low standard! The facts are there, and what is missing that you provide is, well, not a low standard. You're just a stranger to me so this is nothing personal, but I would say your analysis is 'particularly deep' and insightful. In other words, it's not that journalistic standards are low: it's that I think you (jacobolus) are inordinately insightful on this front and probably worth millions (over a few years) if you leverage this in the right international context.
- its_so_on 15y agoI don't remember if I was being hasty and didn't read your whole comment, or if you added to it, but I only thought your first paragraph was insightful. ("It’s really obnoxious that the author allows this facile analysis to pass without any attempt to provide context. Hong Kong and Singapore were Western colonial corporate/financial/trade centers for a giant continent which was otherwise mostly blocked off, and so were bottlenecks through which massive amounts of capital flowed (and goods: HK, Singapore, and Shanghai are the busiest ports in Asia). The UAE is a tiny country with one of the largest oil reserves in the world.")
- tptacek 15y agoIs it possible that both things are true? That the current conditions in Honduras are the result of a legacy of imperialist and corporatist exploitation, and that part of that legacy is a system of laws and customs that retards economic development and condemns many of its people to a life lived in shacks or subsistence farms? Your whole comment can be right on the money (I'm inclined to think it is) without saying anything about Romer's belief that the best vector to improve Honduras is "special economic zones" with different laws. (We had to read Eduardo Galeano's last Memory of Fire book in high school; probably the most memorable and durably changing experiences I've had with any book. I'm guessing you're being charitable about how bad Honduran history has been for Hondurans.)
- jacobolus 15y agoI think the omnipresent external force has been much more important in determining outcomes than local culture (but of course these are complex systems which can’t cleanly be broken into parts – “culture”, “law”, “economy”, “government”, “power structure” are all linked together). I do agree though that it’s necessary to have some combination of land reform, capital accumulation and investment (and perhaps local reinvestment of export profits?), education, industrial development, and strengthening of civic and political institutions to build a successful functioning society. These are hard problems for poor countries, and the last 60 years of academic political science have pretty convincingly failed to turn up any easy explanations or solutions. I wouldn’t hold my breath that building a foreign “special economic” enclave unaccountable to the rest of the country will ultimately save Honduran peasants. But that’s not the part of the article I’m offended by.
- bluekeybox 15y ago> I think the omnipresent external force has been much more important in determining outcomes than local culture Maybe, but you seem to assume that the impact of an omnipresent external force is always negative. The more I read about history, the more it begins to appear to me that today's economic boom in Asia is in no small part due to the British imperial system a century ago which first set things in motion.
- 15y ago
- moldbug 15y agoThis is standard 20th century history. It's also the standard Communist line (Galeano, Zinn, etc). Its only correspondence with reality is the statement that everything wrong with Latin America is the US's fault. While this is true, everything else is a lie. The truth about Latin America is that it's suffering from 200 years of revolutionary ideology exported from El Norte. All its functional institutions date to Spanish rule (which is why "colonial" is applied indiscriminately to anything that isn't ugly in Mexico). Things started to suck in the 19th century when revolutionary Enlightenment ideology, all of Anglo-American origin, destroyed first colonial, then clerical and aristocratic rule, in the process producing approximately a zillion very very nasty civil wars. And of course comparing 19th-century revolutionary ideology to its 20th-century successor is like comparing strychnine to cyanide. Where did all these ideologies come from? Dude, do you really have to ask? Ergo "pobre Mexico, tan lejos de Dios, tan cerca a los Estados Unidos." For instance, it's grimly hilarious that today, with Mexico the world capital of decapitation, anyone could conceivably praise the Mexican Revolution. If Woodrow Wilson and Americans like him hadn't been so intent on "teaching Mexico to elect good men," the Porfiriato could easily have lasted another century: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Porfirio_D%C3%ADaz http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Porfirio_D%C3%ADaz Instead, thanks to John Reed and his ilk: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Reed_(journalist) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Reed_(journalist) You wind up with this dude: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Teodoro_Garc%C3%ADa_Simental http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Teodoro_Garc%C3%ADa_Simental whom I'm pretty sure neither the Porfiriato nor New Spain would have wasted much time in hanging. Etc, etc, etc. took a course on Mesoamerican colonial history from the former Honduran Minister of Culture, who fled to the US after the 2009 coup. And no doubt wishes the State Department would repeat its usual trick of deposing all Latin American governments which aren't headed by Harvard professors, or completely Americanized natives acceptable to such. Strangely, this position is commonly referred to as "anti-Americanism" - possibly for the same reason tall men are called "Tiny." Needless to say, the golpistas in Honduras are a hell of a lot more Honduran than anyone who has ever taught a course at Harvard (or wherever). If you prefer them to the Harvard professors, you're an imperialist. Hell of a world we live in, ain't it? Disclaimer: my father was a US vice-consul in the Dominican Republic. Don't hate the player, hate the game.
- Perceval 15y ago
- kanwisher 15y ago2009 was hardly what I would call a coup, only people not familiar with Honduras politics would call it that. The president was trying to rig the election so they made sure to get him out so they could resume legitimate elections and not have a puppet government in control by Hugo Chavez
- jf271 15y agoThey deserve a lot of praise for defending their constitution without violence. The interim president stepped down when he said he would and did not run for the office. Elections went off without problems. It should serve as an example for the rest of the world.
- rbreve 15y agoYou can't imagine all the pressure the country had after the coup, almost every embassy and organization got out of the country, we stopped receiving aid, all the development programs were paralyzed, all the funds for help were cut off. The interim had to step down. I am afraid to tell you that in Honduras the constitution and the law are violated everyday, impunity is so commun here, so that argument "defending the constitution" that the people who were in favor of the coup is bullshit.
- jf271 15y agoOK, I'm confused. Are you saying that it would have been better for Honduras to allow Zelaya to install himself as a dictator for life, Chavez style?
- rbreve 15y agoChavez is there because he got elected with the majority of votes, he also have the support from congress and the military. Mel wasnt that popular, so he was not a real threat. The coup was very hurtful for the country.
- rsanchez1 15y ago
- dudeguy999 15y agoWhen Singapore became independent, GDP per capita was $500.