4 ms·
Actually, it’s the “separation of church and state” that’s more analogous to the civil war memorials being a 20th century creation. “Separation of church and s
by rayiner 3y ago
Actually, it’s the “separation of church and state” that’s more analogous to the civil war memorials being a 20th century creation.
“Separation of church and state” isn’t in the Constitution. It was something Jefferson said, but he was not representative of the founding fathers on that point. John Adams, by contrast, said: “Our constitution was made only for a moral and religious people. It is wholly inadequate to the government of any other.”
Public schooling was invented in Massachusetts for the purpose of educating kids about religion. Massachusetts had an official state church (the Congregationalist church) until 1824! The “Establishment Clause” says: “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion.” That’s not old-timey speak meaning separation of church and state. It literally just says the federal government can’t interfere with the official state churches, which were called “established churches” (and that the federal government couldn’t establish a church itself).
For the first 170 years of the nation’s existence, nobody thought the Establishment Clause meant that state governments could not teach kids religion in state schools. That was invented pretty much out of thin air in the mid-20th century.
- selimthegrim 3y agoIt sounds like you’re perfectly fine with secularism being removed from Bangladesh then.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 3y agoI think imposing secularism on an overwhelmingly Muslim country was overreach by western-influenced elites. But nonetheless, Bangladesh’s Constitution, which was legitimately adopted by a government that had the support of the people, expressly incorporates a principle of “secularism” (using those words). Article I of the French Constitution likewise states that France is a secular republic: “La France est une République indivisible, laïque, démocratique et sociale.” Secularism in France, too, was legitimately adopted into law by elected governments. By contrast, the US Constitution doesn’t mention secularism or anything like it. It has a prohibition on the federal government interfering with established state churches, and a protection of freedom of religion. In that respect, the First Amendment is more comparable to the German Basic Law, which guarantees freedom of religion but lacks any requirement of secularism. And the Basic Law has been understood to allow quite a bit of public religion. Religion classes are required in school (though you can opt out and take a class in secular morality instead). Government buildings in Bavaria are required to display crosses. There is a church tax. I think the German approach better fits America both as a legal matter and in terms of what the people want. (America is by far the most religious developed country—the percentage of Americans who pray daily is comparable to Iran!) What happened with the Establishment Clause in the US is more like what Ershad did in Bangladesh: he changed the constitution from its original meaning, without going through the proper means for amending the constitution. At least in Ershad’s case, the public probably supported theu result. Even as of 2013, most Americans still opposed the prohibition on school prayer.
- selimthegrim 3y agoThanks for the detailed reply.
- dctoedt 3y ago> ... what Ershad did in Bangladesh: he changed the constitution from its original meaning, without going through the proper means for amending the constitution. Tangential: Seems analogous to changing code without changing the documentation — if the change makes things run better, well .... (And saying, "you're never, ever allowed to change the code unless you change the documentation first" seems to have priorities backwards.)
- tptacek 3y ago"It if proper to take alarm at the firft experiment on our libertief ... Who doef not fee that the fame authority which can eftablish Chriftianity, in exclufion of all other Religionf, may eftablish with the same eafe any particular fect of Chriftians, in exclufion of all other fects? That the same authority which can force a citizen to contribute three pence only of hif property for the fupport of any one eftablishment may force him to conform to any other eftablishment in all cafes whatsoever?" Jamef Madifon. Checkmate, theist. (Pulled from Engel v. Vitale, one of the "thin air" cases you allude to.)
- pvg 3y agothink you have a typo in theiſt
- Nevermark 3y ago> “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion.” Right > It literally just says the federal government can’t interfere with the official state churches, which were called “established churches” (and that the federal government couldn’t establish a church itself). You are down selecting only half of what the simple statement says. You are making a distinction of “interference” not in the text. No religious establishment based “interference”, yes that is consistent with the phrase, but less general than the actual phrase which includes no such restriction. It also is consistent with no establishment based “preference”. “No law…” is the actual clear, simpler, and more general wording.