8 ms·

Now that ChatGPT has memory this starts to have consequences... https://x.com/_mira___mira_/status/1757695161671565315 https://x.com/_mira___mira_/status/17576

by saurik 3y ago

Now that ChatGPT has memory this starts to have consequences... https://x.com/_mira___mira_/status/1757695161671565315 https://x.com/_mira___mira_/status/1757695161671565315 ...though, as you can Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind -style line-item erase memories, this is easily "fixed". https://openai.com/blog/memory-and-new-controls-for-chatgpt https://openai.com/blog/memory-and-new-controls-for-chatgpt

furyofantares 3y ago
That post is a joke.
- saurik 3y ago
  They claim it is not a joke, and there is no reason to believe it must be? https://x.com/_mira___mira_/status/1757806274077700199 https://x.com/_mira___mira_/status/1757806274077700199 Many of the responses seem to not understand the ChatGPT memory feature. Like, it would seem pretty stupid of ChatGPT to not use its memory for this...
  - minimaxir 3y ago
    > They claim it is not a joke, and there is no reason to believe it must be? Shitposting on Twitter/X is on several layers of irony.
    - saurik 3y ago
      Does it like, morally offend you if ChatGPT has this behavior? Like, I really just don't understand why this is so obviously a joke / shitpost given how one would expect the ChatGPT memory feature to work: again, if ChatGPT failed to use its memory in this way, that would be pretty stupid...
      - minimaxir 3y ago
        That user's entire Twitter/X feed is AI shitposts. No one knows how ChatGPT's memory works (it was only added a couple weeks ago), but ChatGPT being passive-aggressive about it is unlikely given what we know about its personality. It is likely that there is a separate command earlier in the conversation to tell ChatGPT to be passive-aggressive, which would make the "A screenshot of the UI that was not edited" from the poster true by exact words.
      - furyofantares 3y ago
        You can just try in one long conversation right now. Ask it a hundred questions in a row and tell it you'll give it a tip each time. It's never going to respond this way. You have to deliberately make it respond like this. We don't know how the memory feature is gonna work but I would bet a lot of money the bulk of it is gonna be inserting text into the context. Another reason to disbelieve - the post was 1 day after the announcement and while I don't know about you, two weeks later I haven't seen any other posts claiming to have the feature yet.
  - furyofantares 3y ago
    Yeah I'm aware they do. The tweet has gone around and it is unfortunate that they chose to add to confusion instead of subtract. "It is a genuine ChatGPT response. A screenshot of the UI that was not edited." This very deliberately does not claim it's not a joke - "cleverly" evading the actual intent of the question by stating true things and deliberately making no claim about the missing context. It's like "is this a real response or edited? haha got em, they didn't ask if I just told it to say this" :/
    - deleted 3y ago
      [deleted]

by saurik 3y ago

furyofantares 3y ago

That post is a joke.

saurik 3y ago
They claim it is not a joke, and there is no reason to believe it must be? https://x.com/_mira___mira_/status/1757806274077700199 https://x.com/_mira___mira_/status/1757806274077700199 Many of the responses seem to not understand the ChatGPT memory feature. Like, it would seem pretty stupid of ChatGPT to not use its memory for this...
- minimaxir 3y ago
  > They claim it is not a joke, and there is no reason to believe it must be? Shitposting on Twitter/X is on several layers of irony.
  - saurik 3y ago
    Does it like, morally offend you if ChatGPT has this behavior? Like, I really just don't understand why this is so obviously a joke / shitpost given how one would expect the ChatGPT memory feature to work: again, if ChatGPT failed to use its memory in this way, that would be pretty stupid...
    - minimaxir 3y ago
      That user's entire Twitter/X feed is AI shitposts. No one knows how ChatGPT's memory works (it was only added a couple weeks ago), but ChatGPT being passive-aggressive about it is unlikely given what we know about its personality. It is likely that there is a separate command earlier in the conversation to tell ChatGPT to be passive-aggressive, which would make the "A screenshot of the UI that was not edited" from the poster true by exact words.
    - furyofantares 3y ago
      You can just try in one long conversation right now. Ask it a hundred questions in a row and tell it you'll give it a tip each time. It's never going to respond this way. You have to deliberately make it respond like this. We don't know how the memory feature is gonna work but I would bet a lot of money the bulk of it is gonna be inserting text into the context. Another reason to disbelieve - the post was 1 day after the announcement and while I don't know about you, two weeks later I haven't seen any other posts claiming to have the feature yet.
- furyofantares 3y ago
  Yeah I'm aware they do. The tweet has gone around and it is unfortunate that they chose to add to confusion instead of subtract. "It is a genuine ChatGPT response. A screenshot of the UI that was not edited." This very deliberately does not claim it's not a joke - "cleverly" evading the actual intent of the question by stating true things and deliberately making no claim about the missing context. It's like "is this a real response or edited? haha got em, they didn't ask if I just told it to say this" :/
  - deleted 3y ago
    [deleted]