5 ms·
Thank you, I came here to post exactly this! None of the examples in the article actually support the hypothesis described, that "institutions will try to pres
by crazygringo 3y ago
Thank you, I came here to post exactly this!
None of the examples in the article actually support the hypothesis described, that "institutions will try to preserve the problem to which they are the solution".
The very first one is about how tax-filing companies don't want the government to make filing taxes easier, but that's because tax-filing companies aren't non-profits dedicated to making taxes easier to file -- they're corporations dedicated to making a profit.
The same with the bus company wanting to eliminate competition. The story about the cobras is a tangent about unintended consequences that has nothing to do with the supposed Shirky principle (it's actually an example of perverse incentives [1]), and so forth.
If you peel the layers back, you realize that this is essentially just the age-old conservative ideology that government intervention is bad because it never solves the problem but just makes government bigger.
And then you realize that counterexamples abound. Did the history of vaccines in the 20th century just wind up sustaining the ravages of smallpox and polio? Of course not. Does investment in a military lead people to attack you? Of course not. Do incentives for solar power actually play a role in preserving fossil fuel usage that otherwise could have been eliminated? Don't be ridiculous.
And guess what? The IRS is currently piloting programs to make filing taxes simpler. Despite the lobbying efforts of tax-filing companies.
The "Shirky principle" is something that sounds really clever, and it's so cynical you almost think it must be true... but that doesn't mean it is true. The evidence that seems to support it doesn't, and the massive evidence against it seems to be ignored.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perverse_incentive https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perverse_incentive
- ars 3y agoThe unrwa is an example of this. An agency created to help Palestinians ends up perpetuating the conflict by generating ever increasing numbers of refugees who can't work in their country of birth (Lebanon, Syria, etc) because they are denied citizenship. More reading: https://pij.org/articles/1168/the-discrimination-against-palestinian-refugees-living-in-lebanon https://pij.org/articles/1168/the-discrimination-against-pal...
- crazygringo 3y agoIt's actually quite the opposite. There's a great recent analysis in the Economist that disagrees [1] -- it claims the problem isn't with the UNRWA at all (as Israel has been claiming), but rather with neighbor states actively blocking solutions that would therefore allow the UNRWA to disband. Key quotes: > Some Israeli officials have wanted to shut down UNRWA for years, accusing the agency of helping to prolong the conflict. They have seized the moment to press their case. For its supporters, meanwhile, the agency is above reproach, a group of selfless humanitarians doing vital work. As ever, life is more complicated than a morality play. The continued existence of UNRWA is a problem—but not for the reasons its critics think... > This is a problem—but not one of UNRWA's making. Blame instead the Arab states that have refused, for decades, to offer citizenship to the Palestinians in their midst. The 1.7m registered refugees in Gaza (or their ancestors) lived under Egyptian control for almost two decades until 1967. Instead of offering them rights, Egypt left them in squalor. Similarly: > In many ways, UNRWA was the government. Hamas officials have all but admitted this in interviews over the past few months. They said Hamas’s role was to build up its military capabilities, not to care for their people—they had do-gooders for that. Israel, too, relied on UNRWA to mitigate the consequences of the draconian blockade that it (along with Egypt) imposed on Gaza. Even today, as Israel tries to abolish UNRWA, it still relies on the agency to prevent mass starvation in Gaza. It's not the UNRWA that is trying to perpetuate itself. It is the actions of several countries that force the continued status of refugee on the Palestinians, Hamas not taking over basic governmental services, and Israel not providing humanitarian services in Gaza. The UNRWA is doing its best to do necessary humanitarian work when others aren't stepping up. The idea that UNRWA is the primary party responsible for perpetuating the situation, in order to therefore perpetuate its existence, couldn't be further from the truth. [1] https://www.economist.com/middle-east-and-africa/2024/02/15/the-real-problem-with-the-uns-agency-for-palestinians https://www.economist.com/middle-east-and-africa/2024/02/15/...
- ars 3y agoThat's a creative way of explaining things, but if you were correct the unrwa would have long since disbanded and all the refugees handed over to the unhcr for integration into their country of birth. That this has not happened is the clearest proof against what you wrote. Tell me: If what you said is correct, why does the unrwa even still exist as a separate entity? The unrwa has a policy of always expanding the number of refugees, the unhcr has the opposite policy. Yes, it's true the Arab states have not made things easy, but the unrwa is not even trying - it's simply not part of the mandate. It is however the mandate of the unhcr. Do you think host countries want to admit refugees as citizens? They never do, but the unhcr manages to make things work. If the unrwa would try as hard they would cease to exist, which is a perfect example of this article.
- dcow 3y agoThe article isn’t as hyperbolic as you’re suggesting it is. It admits that there are cases where the benefits of solving the problem outweigh sustaining it. The existence of a generalizable pattern does not imply the wold reduces solely to the pattern. It is not conservative to say institutions try to preserve themselves nor to suggest that government institutions, systems, and entities are equally susceptible to the plight of preservation, even inadvertently. Traditional conservatives are allergic to change and the conservative mindset may be at fault for institutions behaving conservatively… but we won’t have that discussion if you write off a rather wise observation as politicized anti-government propaganda.
- barrysteve 3y agoSo you want to preserve a problematic principle to keep talking about it's contents? How terribly meta. The shirky principle is not needed. Shirk is already an English word meaning 'avoid or neglect responsibility'.
- dcow 3y agoOr, you’re preserving the HN community by finding some absurd hyper reductionist way to turn an interesting subject into a problem. We could go on… There are numerous and quite normal unproblematic examples of how self-preservation is unwanted and destructive. I for one am interested in learning how and why these incentives evolve and how to structurally combat them so that we never have to talk about harmful examples of the Shirky principle ever again. Concretely apropos and not one whiff of meta.