7 ms·
Trevor Noah has a bit about how 'muricans are the only ones that sing the national anthem all the damn time. He adds how it's also the only anthem where it is s
by dylan604 3y ago
Trevor Noah has a bit about how 'muricans are the only ones that sing the national anthem all the damn time. He adds how it's also the only anthem where it is sung differently each time depending on the performer.
Personally, I have always felt very strange in the entire concept of having to sing this at various events or in school as well as the pledging of allegiance. It just feels very cultish or something you'd expect a dictatorship to make its citizens do. Like when we are shown videos of the North Koreans lined up praising the dear leader, the videos of US school kids doing their version of it just rubs me the wrong way
- cooper_ganglia 3y agoThe anthem uncoupled from what it stands for may seem strange, which is why it’s so important to remember the lives of the fathers, brothers, and sons sacrificed at Fort McHenry holding up the flag through the night, and all the lives lost since then holding up the foundations of freedom and our way of life. If you’re living in America enjoying the (ever shrinking) bounty of liberties we have, it’s good and healthy for yourself and for the country to reflect on that every now and then, and kids should absolutely have a love of their country (and thus their fellow countrymen) reinforced daily. I think falling away from a national identity hurts everyone.
- dylan604 3y agoyeah, no. not for me. just reading what you've written gives me flashbacks to all of those uncomfortable moments of having to perform some oath and pledge my allegiance to something i did not choose. nobody chooses where they are born. why would someone else expect they'd pledge their fealty to something they didn't choose to be apart of just because of their place of birth? to me, it's just weird that anyone would pledge their blind loyalty to something that doesn't give a damn about them
- kbos87 3y agoI've always thought of the national anthem as more of a collective show of appreciation for the good parts of the US, which is probably why I've always been OK with it. The pledge of allegiance, on the other hand, feels like a forced statement of blind loyalty. Gives me the same ick I get whenever I've been at some sort of rally or protest when they try to hype up a crowd. I've never been to church but I'd imagine it's the same thing.
- networkchad 3y ago[dead]
- dctoedt 3y ago> all of those uncomfortable moments of having to perform some oath and pledge my allegiance ... FWIW, I seldom if ever say the Pledge of Allegiance — I took the oath to support and defend the Constitution many years ago when I joined the Navy, and then again as a lawyer; I figure that ought to be plenty ....
- dylan604 3y agoYeah, luckily, that seems to have stopped for the most part after grade school. I have been to a couple of events as an adult that did that, and it felt very bizarre. My "favorite" part is that they are having kids recite a pledge knowing full well that most of them have no understanding to what it actually means. Taking a pledge should be one of those "I, state your name, of sound mind and body, pledge allegiance..." It's just one of those things that is so illogical to me that I don't get how it's not for everyone else
- mtrower 3y agoI would guess that having it drilled in from childhood probably has something to do with it. By taking issue with it, you're going against the flow and people in general seem to be uncomfortable with that sort of thing. It also seems to me, that people tend to associate it with something other than the actual words that are being spoken.
- qotgalaxy 3y ago[dead]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mtrower 3y agoThat may be true, and it may be of personal value to pursue this for yourself. That's different from socially badgering others into it at group events.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- GiorgioG 3y agoIf it bothers you so much don’t go to these events.
- dylan604 3y agoSomeone's not allowed to go to a sporting event because you say so? That's a load of crap. I'll go to whatever event I want. If they have one of these dear leader performances, I just stand there thinking about whatever is on my mind. If you like it, you can sing your little heart out. But I'm not going to not go to something I enjoy because you might get offended at my non-participation in your cult-like ritual
- jvanderbot 3y agoHow did we jump from "this is not mandatory" to "you're not allowed"
- dylan604 3y agoBecause the person suggested that I not go to the event. Also, as "not mandatory", have you ever chosen to remain seated and experienced the reaction from those around you? You'll definitely get the feeling "not mandatory" is a very much incorrect description.
- jvanderbot 3y agoI'll quote myself from another comment: > haven't sung a hymn, pledge or anthem since I was 11 or so. I just stand there and watch, be it church, baseball, hockey, whatever. 32 years and nothing bad has happened yet. (Hooray freedom?). I don't believe there is any pressure whatsoever. YMMV, but I do just stand up and not sing. It's not the end of the world. And some people always keep their hand down, instead of over heart. Again, I'm really not experiencing difficulties here, but I respect that there might be other factors. Like, do you live in the deep south?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 3y ago> I think falling away from a national identity hurts everyone. I agree but it’s the basic defect at the heart of America. It’s a country founded by anti-social individualists, replenished by waves and waves of the sort of anti-social people who would leave their kin and move to the other side of the world. Christianity was the only thing keeping the country from declining into pure atomized individualism, and the hold of that is on the verge of collapsing.
- tptacek 3y agoFrom where are you getting this idea that America was founded by "anti-social individualists"? What I was taught is that it was founded by people with immense faith in innate goodness of people and the rightness of governance by the people.
- cjbgkagh 3y agoThere may be a conflation of the founding fathers with the initial stock of pilgrims which is understandable given the ambiguity of the term ‘founded’. I guess the pilgrims would be considered anti-social as they didn’t ’go along to get along’ but AFAIK powerful trade guilds dominated a large part of the economic private life and the people persecuted/excluded from them may not have had much choice in the matter.
- romafirst3 3y agoDon’t you guys also do a pledge of allegiance and other weird stuff? Also, in most every other country, the national anthem is only ever sung when the country is playing an outside country not for internal competition.
- labster 3y agoYes we do a pledge of allegiance every day at school, and many government meetings and social club meetings. A lot of that stuff is early adopter weirdness. You see, other nation states have things like a historical culture or common language to unite them, but the US had to invent a national identity out of whole cloth when no other nation was doing nationalism yet. We need rituals to affirm that we are the members of the in-group.
- vunderba 3y agoThe really crazy thing is that the original pledge of allegiance made no reference to god at all. It was added as late as 1954, when Congress passed a law which added the words “under God” after “one nation.” A year later Emmett Till, a 14-year-old African American boy, was brutally murdered in Mississippi after allegedly flirting with a white woman. His killers were acquitted by an all-white jury. But ya know, at least we shoehorned religion into our pledge. Following a "symbol" (a religion, a flag, whatever) that can't be properly quantified scares the shit out of me.
- mp05 3y ago> But ya know, at least we shoehorned religion into our pledge. "that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness." Look I find it way overplayed to the point of losing any meaning, and a lot of people (civilians) assign some deeper meaning to the ceremony than is likely warranted, and probably partisan. But like it or not, America's middle finger to England asserts that some higher power endows us with rights that may not be infringed. It's the basic premise of the whole damn thing. I'm not here to argue whether this is good or bad, but insinuating that it was "shoehorned" doesn't seem fair to history.
- dylan604 3y agoBut it was shoehorned in. The founding fathers very much did not want the government to be dictated to by religion. They also very much wanted people to be able to practice which ever religion they wanted. This is why there is the concept of separation of church and state with the establishment clause. The pledge itself wasn't even around until the Civil War, and was worded differently than what is used today. There's a lot of things that people accept as "always been that way" because it was that way when they were kids. It's not dissimilar to how most of the Civil War memorials weren't actually installed until the 1950s.
- rayiner 3y agoActually, it’s the “separation of church and state” that’s more analogous to the civil war memorials being a 20th century creation. “Separation of church and state” isn’t in the Constitution. It was something Jefferson said, but he was not representative of the founding fathers on that point. John Adams, by contrast, said: “Our constitution was made only for a moral and religious people. It is wholly inadequate to the government of any other.” Public schooling was invented in Massachusetts for the purpose of educating kids about religion. Massachusetts had an official state church (the Congregationalist church) until 1824! The “Establishment Clause” says: “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion.” That’s not old-timey speak meaning separation of church and state. It literally just says the federal government can’t interfere with the official state churches, which were called “established churches” (and that the federal government couldn’t establish a church itself). For the first 170 years of the nation’s existence, nobody thought the Establishment Clause meant that state governments could not teach kids religion in state schools. That was invented pretty much out of thin air in the mid-20th century.
- rayiner 3y ago> Personally, I have always felt very strange in the entire concept of having to sing this at various events or in school as well as the pledging of allegiance. We live in a society. The government takes 40-50% of your income every year so you can support the other people who are part of the same society. It allows you to survive and protects you from those that would harm you both internal and external. Saying a short affirmation of loyalty to that entity once in a while seems pretty mild in comparison. Relevant: https://youtu.be/hopNAI8Pefg?si=6e0CPUfD15Mf30ol https://youtu.be/hopNAI8Pefg?si=6e0CPUfD15Mf30ol
- dctoedt 3y ago> Saying a short affirmation of loyalty to that entity once in a while seems pretty mild in comparison. Faux performative patriotism. You took the oath to support and defend the Constitution when you were admitted to the bar. That ought to be enough.
- rayiner 3y ago> Faux performative patriotism Shared rituals reinforce shared values.
- archagon 3y agoEvidently not. Among all Americans, I have the least in common with those who are most passionate about these rituals.
- dylan604 3y agoI say a prayer every time I enter a bar. Probably not the same prayer though
- henriquez 3y agoNone of us asked for this. Sure you can argue that we’re lucky. That would be like chiding a clinically depressed person for “feeling down” because other people in other countries have it worse off. Performative chants serve as a form of mass hypnosis - to solidify the legitimacy of a batshit insane society in the weak minds who just want to go along to get along. Our society is fucked. And those of us fortunate enough to be in the creative class can wax philosophical about it in our luxury boxes while everyone else gets fucked.
- cjbgkagh 3y agoThe morning pledge was intentionally pushed during a time when it was considered people were insufficiently patriotic. To make it even more fascistic it used to be the Roman salute pre-WWII. The US is surprisingly Germanic. I think the multitude of anthems are pushed by military funding to intentionally conflate patriotism with support for the military. One thing I especially don’t like is the reflexive ‘thank you for your service’ that has entered into polite behavior. I believe that was an intentional and highly effective campaign. I personally refuse to do it even to be polite. I take the Smedly D Butlers view that ‘War is a racket’.
- rldjbpin 3y agoyou'd be surprised to learn how some countries treat their national anthems. if you watch cinema in India, you have to stand up for the national anthem before the movie starts lol. similar situation in Thailand iirc.