4 ms·
Free markets help, but are not by themselves sufficient. Equalizing that potential is also not always in the interest of many parties. You don’t have to go bac
by lazide 3y ago
Free markets help, but are not by themselves sufficient. Equalizing that potential is also not always in the interest of many parties.
You don’t have to go back very far in history to find plenty of examples.
Recent history has had massive and rapid technological development, and it’s been relatively easy to find win/win trades, so it’s easy to think it is.
But the Caribbean slave trade, or US Deep South cotton trade, or Indian spice trade? Eh…. A little less clear.
- WalterBright 3y ago> Free markets help, but are not by themselves sufficient. Example? > Caribbean slave trade And yet the free market in the US buried them, and the Caribbean remains poor.
- lazide 3y agoI don’t think you have the history here. Technological development - decent ships, actually good and reliable navigation, and knowledge of exploitable opportunities (sugar markets, and later cotton). Energy gradient - cheap labor (in the form of slaves) in Africa, cheap arable land (Caribbean, US, South America), hungry markets with excess wealth in Europe. First, the Caribbean got exploited (with open markets!) rather brutally, until the slave rebellions starting in 1790, and further escalating. Haiti in particular, won their rebellion - and then were completely economically isolated (by closing the market!) by the European powers. They still have not recovered economically, same for most of the Caribbean. Around this time is when the US markets (less ideal to exploitation, but larger and more controllable) in both sugar cane and cotton started to take off using the same sources. Which fueled significant tension between the northern states (no crops easily amenable to slavery, rather being capital manufacturing, livestock, and secondary goods like weaving/textiles) and the southern states (many labor intensive crops, amenable to slavery). Attempts at controlling the open markets in these crops by dissimilar interests (by either banning slavery or by blockade) is what led to the civil war. The south couldn’t ban slavery without bankrupting their economy. The north couldn’t allow free trade/slavery continue without making themselves less competitive, as Europe has more developed textile mills and heavy manufacturing. So them getting the goods directly was undercutting northern US competitiveness. Notably, the British, being the first into the Industrial Revolution and the furthest along, were also the first major European power to not just ban slavery in their country - but all their colonies, and everywhere else they could reach. To cut off the ‘energy gradient’ of cheap labor, and make their products (more capital intensive manufacturing) more competitive. The Caribbean is poor because they rebelled against exploitation, but couldn’t capture the economic engine that was exploiting them - they got bypassed by a competitor. And by the time their competitor (US Deep South) also got broken, the underlying energy gradient that led to them being exploited at all was cut off. So all they had left was ruins, debt, and disease. Sucks to be them. So, depending on how you measure ‘good’, they’d have probably been a whole lot better off with a closed market that would never have let the initial energy gradient be formed to begin with, eh? Or at least not allowed the extremely rapid and rapacious exploitation. Think of open markets as a full open floodgate, and closed ones as having a valve at various degrees of closed off. Flooding is very ‘profitable’ if you can somehow harness it (very difficult to do), but can be very unpleasant and destructive for those caught in its path. It’s nearly impossible to die of thirst in a flood. Restrictive flow doesn’t product as much ‘profit’ but has the potential to produce more desirable outcomes if used effectively. As long as the dam doesn’t burst of course. If the valve is misused or turned off, it’s easy for some (or even all) to die of thirst. Pick your poison.
- WalterBright 3y agoAnd yet the free Northern economy buried the slave Southern economy. How does that fit into your theory? And how the entire country boomed after slavery was abolished? Free economies always outperform slave labor, by a large margin. > Technological development Oddly enough, happens first in free market countries. Turns out, you can't build a technological economy using slaves. The Caribbean countries would be prosperous if they'd try free markets instead of socialism and communism.
- lazide 3y agoHuh? The northern economy was MORE CLOSED than the South. For one, they banned slavery first. They had more import/export controls. The south was as free and open* as you could imagine - anyone with the Capital could buy a slave, or sell goods, etc. Trade was minimally restricted. (* Notably, if you were a "free man". Slaves, Women, Children, and sometimes Indentured Servants all had significant restrictions on rights across the board in both locations that were very similar - both de jure and de facto). The North were the ones blockading the South, not the other way around. [https://history.state.gov/milestones/1861-1865/blockade https://history.state.gov/milestones/1861-1865/blockade] The current Caribbean countries are also currently free markets? At least from what I can see. Plenty of 'international banking' in many of them too. Haiti finally paid off the restitution the French have been making them pay since the slave revolt back in 1947 [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haiti_Independence_Debt https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haiti_Independence_Debt], and seem to be slowly gaining ground again. The Dominican Republic (on the same island, other side of the fence, different government due to a revolt in the ~1850's) has been doing quite well for a long time, I think partially because they don't have to pay that debt back, being a "different country" and all. And they generally don't have the various travel blacklists that Haiti has had. I suspect the argument you're trying to make is that mechanization/automation (and it's helpful companion, Capitalism) beats slavery. Which I definitely agree with. One beneficial advantage being that it frees up people to do more thinking (and less, well, slaving away) and benefits significantly from economies of scale - both for the Capitalists, and everyone else. Which is why inventing is so useful (when it won't get stomped on by monopolies, anyway). So it's mostly a beneficial cycle, as long as monopolist tendencies get reined in and someone is watching things to ensure it doesn't get too abusive. Unlike Slavery. Slavery is also despicable in general, so I personally am glad to see it gone. Free/Open/Closed/Restricted markets are not necessarily good or bad, independent of the circumstances - same as guns, IMO. They do have predictable outcomes, if used in predictable ways though. The more closed, the more problematic IMO, but I have yet to see a truly open market (aka a black market, perhaps?) without some really nasty abuses of it's own. So YMMV.