6 ms·
Peter Thiel's $100k offer to skip college is more popular than ever
- bookofjoe 3y agohttps://www.wsj.com/finance/peter-thiels-100-000-offer-to-skip-college-is-more-popular-than-ever-162e281b?st=hwmrfze0mk6lsl3&reflink=desktopwebshare_permalink https://www.wsj.com/finance/peter-thiels-100-000-offer-to-sk... https://archive.ph/msrOW https://archive.ph/msrOW
- ldjkfkdsjnv 3y agoThe ultimate red pill in my life has been working with Harvard grads, and being shocked at how mediocre they are.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rdl 3y agoThe top 25% of Harvard grads are impressive. The bottom 25% are not. My experience has been that even the lower half of Waterloo grads, in CS, are solid to good. I'd probably take the 20th percentile Waterloo grad over the 20th percentile Harvard grad absent other information.
- ldjkfkdsjnv 3y agoA well known VC told me that 1/20 is absolutely exceptional. And so they always bet on Harvard grads, in hopes they are backing one of those 1/20.
- throwaway13337 3y agoNaturally, the majority of these students are benefiting from the inability to tell them apart. Alternatives like the Thiel Fellowship might change this. The better students might choose these options instead. This could break down traditional academia and legacy systems, leading to a more efficient society.
- text0404 3y agoso we just swap out a Harvard education for the handpicked acolytes of a single billionaire? also, have we considered that optimizing for efficiency is not the best way to structure a society?
- CPLX 3y ago> leading to a more efficient society Efficient at what? Producing more highly-resourced sociopaths who share Peter Theil's values?
- throwaway13337 3y agoThe parent comment was on how impressive a portion of the graduates were. This presumes the context of able to be successful in business. You may not agree with the values of Peter (I know I don't agree with all of them), but the graduates are often selected for being effective at business. If those kinds of fellowships provide a better signal, then they would be more efficient by definition. Your comment, though, seems to come from a place of political indignation. I hope you can reflect on how those kinds of comments reflect on your own values.
- CPLX 3y agoOf course they represent my own values. Peter Thiel’s approach to business is based on creating monopoly conditions, extracting maximum value from working people, and creating widespread social misery that he doesn’t have to personally experience due to his wealth. Is there a some other way to evaluate a normative discussion of social, business, and educational policy than by bringing values to bear?
- SV_BubbleTime 3y agoI’ll face issue for this, because I’m sure the same people I’m about to complain about post here. I went to a google campus for an automotive liaison trip when working at a BIG3… some smart people for sure, but a lot of kids that could barely tie their pointy elf shoes let alone had any common sense about things outside of programming. Like… You are working on an automotive program and you have no idea which parts under the painted part are suspension? You don’t know what the transmission actually does? Guys, I just need this car backed out and the other one brought in, this isn’t concerning, you and you, swap these. Yes, there is a reason that cars have so many parts. … it was really eye opening. Good programmers, but holy hell I wouldn’t want to be stuck on an island with any of them.
- linehedonist 3y agoLots of people have no interest in cars, just like lots of people have no interest in computers. Not sure that says anything about the people’s intelligence. Plus on a desert island you’ll probably have bigger problems than what a transmission does.
- SV_BubbleTime 3y agoOk. If you want to excuse one example that’s fine. I was there, and those people put all their points into programming.
- CPLX 3y agoNow you're ready for the next observation. Which is to really understand the mentality of people from those institutions. Imagine if you took these two premises as true: 1) Harvard is the most selective and high level educational institution in the world, it's full of the absolute smartest people alive. That's how I ended up here. 2) Now that I am actually here, it appears that there's a bunch of people at Harvard that honestly aren't all that bright. You then have to pick from one of two obvious conclusions: A) Maybe Harvard actually isn't full of the smartest people in the world. B) Wow, since we know the dumbest person at Harvard is smarter than the smartest person at a state school, people who went to state school must be total fucking idiots. Guess which worldview your average Harvard student tends to gravitate towards?
- ldjkfkdsjnv 3y agoYeah, a lot of them also have a really strong network of ivy league grads, and really only associate in those circles. What happens is they develop all sorts of ideas about "outsiders". You see this in NYC a lot. The network is where alot of the success comes from. I'm also not doubting that many Harvard students are exceptional students
- demondemidi 3y agoThat’s what the legacy rulings are about. But there will always be stupid rich failsons and faildaughters that magically find an acceptance letter and a new facility with their last name on it.
- silverquiet 3y agoI have to say that the last decade or so of my life has been one confirmation after another that the parable of “The Emperor’s New Clothes” is about the most accurate bit of folk sociological wisdom that exists.
- consumer451 3y agoSounds like a great reason to end legacy admissions.
- SV_BubbleTime 3y ago[flagged]
- _aaed 3y agoWhy go to college and develop critical thinking when you can just accept the doctrine of state capitalism and make money for the big guys leeching off the state and weakening our institutions?
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 3y agoLooking at undergrad college students, I don’t think critical thinking is being developed. Entitlement and easily taking offense yes, but not being able to critically consider and evaluate competing ideas.
- fuzzylightbulb 3y ago[flagged]
- text0404 3y agomaybe they're taking offense because the critical thinking skills they receive from higher education enables them to understand the nuances of the world better than you do? or maybe your "competing ideas" aren't as compelling as you think?
- BurningFrog 3y agoFrom what I hear, not much critical thinking is learned in college in 2024.
- consumer451 3y agoWho exactly have you been hearing that from?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rdl 3y agoThe optimal path (at least if you're not going into a regulated/gatekept profession, or not from a very poor/disadvantaged background on a full ride, or using the university program as an immigration pathway) seems to be: 1) Get accepted to a top school 2) Enroll and then drop out (figure out the minimum for your school to consider you a dropout -- I think you probably have to register and take classes for a semester, but you may be able to simply not pay the bill) 3) 20 under 20 (or just do a startup/get a job/continue with life directly) You get >50% of the value of the school (proxy for an IQ test, basically, although with the decline of testing this is less obvious -- still, even without rigorous testing, many people, especially those far from academia, consider "accepted to top school" to be valuable.) I basically did this (out of necessity; I couldn't afford to pay for MIT), but it's worked out well, and it's worked out pretty well for other people I know. With dropout you need to distinguish between "dropped out to do X, or for decent extenuating circumstance" vs "too much drugs", though, when looking at stats.
- endisneigh 3y agoThat’s not a strategy - it’s just selection bias.
- usaar333 3y agoNo,OP is arguing that conditioned on being able to get into a good school, it makes sense to just drop out as that captures enough of the signaling value.
- endisneigh 3y agoI understand what they are saying and I’m saying the outcomes they are referring to are simply selection bias.
- criley2 3y agoAnd the replier to OP is arguing that just because it worked for OP and a friend doesn't mean it's a good strategy. This is selection bias. I also think of it as a survivorship bias and some correlation/causation violations: Me and my successful friends (I don't hang out with unsuccessful people) have similar stories, therefore our choices are a pattern which can be followed to our successes. I could say "every successful engineer I know either abuses drugs or has in the past" and it could fundamentally be true for me and the group of people I know. But would you agree with me if I said that abusing drugs is a smart strategy to succeed?
- wslh 3y agoAs the article says: "College is not for everyone" but I think the article should be more balanced because there are areas of study that you (most people) could only grasp going to college. It is not the same studying operating systems in college, do the study and the practice, "suffer" exams that just reading information on Internet. There is a pressure and specific topics when you study that produces a deep effect in the brain and makes you click. I also think there is a third way with open universities and new pedagogical material. For example, when cybersecurity started gaining tractions, a friend was concerned about having more people understanding how to develop exploits and put exercises online [1]. It started with relatively easy exercises and moved to advanced ones. [1] https://web.archive.org/web/20150123211322/http://community.coresecurity.com/~gera/InsecureProgramming/ https://web.archive.org/web/20150123211322/http://community....
- doubloon 3y agoyes. college should be for everyone. alot of american public colleges have open to the public libraries and continuing education classes for adults. Thiel is a neo-nazi allegedly in minecraft who wants to attack the intellectual class, like every nazi before him allegedly in minecraft.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- typon 3y agoYou don't need college if your goal in life is to be a corporate drone. It's a huge waste of money. If your goal is to be a critical thinker with a diverse education and social experiences, college is one of the lowest barrier to entry (not necessarily best) ways to achieve that.
- fullshark 3y agoHow do you become a corporate drone without a college degree? Also the primary purpose of college seems to be to create corporate drones these days, also what a lot of the student body is after.
- insane_dreamer 3y ago> You don't need college if your goal in life is to be a corporate drone. It's a huge waste of money. If your goal is to be a critical thinker with a diverse education and social experiences, college is one of the lowest barrier to entry (not necessarily best) ways to achieve that. I'd argue the opposite: you need college to become a corporate drone (you're not getting in otherwise); forging your own path provides many more opportunities to learn critical thinking and social experiences (provided you have the guts to strike out and not stay at home working at McD).
- DueDilligence 3y ago[dead]
- hdhdhsjsbdh 3y agoThere seems to be a false dichotomy here, where you either 1. go to school or 2. start a business fresh out of high school. At this age, a person’s frontal cortex has not even finished developing, and yet we culturally treat the moment as a final decision point that determines the outcome of the rest of one’s life. Thiel seems to sell this as option 2.; the final defense against “woke” is to abandon the institutions entirely and forge your own determined path like a little 18 year-old John Galt. But depending on how one uses the resources, it may actually provide a third option: to fuck around and experiment for a little while with low risk of life-ruining failure, while you figure out what it is you actually want to do with your life. This is a privilege afforded to many in non-US countries where gap years are the norm, or where family wealth and connections can accommodate it.
- spatley 3y agoAnd for that matter, I did my fucking around working low stakes jobs in packing warehouses and going to house parties. Goofing off does not require 1%er priveledge.
- trident5000 3y agoI think colleges have purposefully positioned themselves as they are today as a business strategy, specifically ivy leagues or top tiers. They know nearly all information is online now and taught even more effectively in many cases. And once inferior colleges and professors can also harness this and compete on near even footing on the knowledge front. That was not the case just 15 years ago. So they now lean into an area that they think the internet and those who harness it cannot compete. They lace every discipline with philosophy and sell it as an ivy league education. But really they're just bamboozling people with an inferior education and destructive cognitive habits.
- fullshark 3y agoThey are selling the name, and the connections (you will become friends with the child of a billionaire / high status individual, possibly a student who is a high status individual themselves already). These will be immensely valuable forever as long as they keep the club largely exclusive. Everything else is just noise.
- trident5000 3y agoI suppose. I have old friends who are pretty up there. One of them (a very best friend and childhood friend) in a family that’s very wealthy. Think Waltons. Never once did I lever this relationship or any others I have. I think the network thing is overrated. Wealthy and connected people mostly want to be left alone and very rarely do favors for people not independently at their level. Also I’m trying to think how many close friends I kept from college or even in contact with. I think maybe 5 and none of them were well off or connected. But yes, that is part of what is sold as well. Or at least the idea of it. There’s no question about that.
- dachworker 3y agoI don't have much again Thiel's program but US college is only four years. People talk as if that's an eternity. At 22 you're still basically a kid. If you are a genius of geniuses, you can even speed run college and finish sooner. That said, the article is talking about the big picture and missing all the important details. These Thiel fellows think that Thiel's connections and network, which is basically SV startup scene aristocracy, are worth more than what connections than can gain at a top-10 US college. They probably aren't wrong.
- ldjkfkdsjnv 3y agoI disagree, the energy you have at that age is unparalleled. If you spend it on entrepreneurship, your chances of success are much higher. People consistently underestimate what it takes to build an innovative new company, young very bright people can do it. If they wait til 25/30, they will have lost some of the spark required. It can also take a decade, so start at 25, you are looking at success by 35. Start at 19, by your mid 20s you are in a very good place.
- endisneigh 3y agoNonsense. Go look at this very site’s startups and you will see it’s not true
- jwells89 3y agoEarly 20s energy is really something else. I can’t even begin to imagine what would be possible if I could somehow send to my 22 year old self my present day 35 year old brain.
- nothercastle 3y agoEnergy vs wisdom. Young people like to take 10 actions when only one is needed. Sometimes that works out and other times all those actions are expensive
- rubymamis 3y ago
- siva7 3y agoI don't get this obsession with skipping college. When you finish college, you're still a "kid" as in totally young and nothing to loose. There's absolutely nothing lost time-wise in the greater scheme of life. Peter Thiel is playing on the insecurity of these young people like they will loose out on something if they don't do this.
- echelon 3y agoThe debt a lot of kids incur certainly sets them back. Even community colleges have absurd tuitions now. I studied biochem and computer science in college. The biochem parts I absolutely could not have learned at home without a lab and domain experts teaching me. The computer science bits, not so much. I was already programming by college and was doing capstone-level work in my freshman courses. I suspect this is true of many students who get started with learning their field in high school. I get the sense that for many degrees that are not hands on with labs and equipment, a university setting is unnecessary. None of my "connections" from university mattered. I made it much further by making my own outside of classes. So, at least anecdotally, I can't buy that argument either.
- siva7 3y agoIt's not necessary the knowledge but the social experience which makes it worth for many. You can always become part of the corporate world later. Though i'm aware that not everyone is given those chances.
- echelon 3y ago> social experience It shouldn't cost so much! Perhaps college aged kids could join something like the Peace Corps instead? Community college costs need to return to <$10k/yr, too.
- kcplate 3y agoI was well experienced in getting wasted and hanging out with my friends long before I went to college.
- 3y ago
- hardwaregeek 3y agoIn What Tech Calls Thinking, there’s a part that analyzes tech college dropout culture. There was a good point that it’s this odd double bind of wanting the prestige of the school but also wanting to rebel or deny it. You want to show to everybody that you could get into Stanford but also you’re too cool for it. It’s also quite funny in that the more challenging classes occur to the end of college. Even if you’re a very advanced student, the classes are only so sophisticated in the first year or two. But I guess the idea is that these kids are genius autodidacts and therefore can learn all the material on their own? That seems plausible in some cases (CS, math) and less so in others (biomedical engineering cough Elizabeth Holmes cough)
- xyzzy_plugh 3y ago> About a quarter of the Thiel fellows eventually returned to college to finish their degrees, suggesting that even the dropouts see enduring value in higher education. > Thiel says they “got way more out of it by going back” after launching their businesses. > “The other 75% didn’t need a college degree,” he says. I definitely don't think everyone needs a college degree and I definitely think it would do a lot of folks good to delay pursuing a higher education for at least a little while for them to figure out what they want to do. So many of my peers went to college without much of an end goal in sight. I certainly think employers should discriminate less when it comes to degrees. I don't agree with Thiel on much but this maybe isn't as bad as it seems. However attacking the institutions and promoting successes where no secondary education was necessary seems disingenuous at best. Everyone should be entitled to higher education. As a society I'm pretty sure it is not in our best interest to lower the bar here. Maybe if you're a politician you want ignorant constituents. I definitely think more folks should consider community college as an alternative and that the stigma surrounding "inferior" forms of higher education is harmful. A CEO straight of highschool that I'd want to work for would be a diamond in the rough to say the least.
- insane_dreamer 3y ago> should consider community college as an alternative and that the stigma surrounding "inferior" forms of higher education is harmful very true; and CC captures the original intent of college which was to gain knowledge, whereas 4-year colleges are focused on a lot of other stuff (prestige, network opportunities, job opportunities, sports, college life, etc.)
- fullshark 3y agoIt's really not hard to find a college willing to take your money / government sponsored student loan, especially for the type of person to get a Thiel fellowship. It's not a major opportunity these people are giving up.
- xyzzy_plugh 3y agoIt's not about these particular people or the money he's giving them, but rather the general message he is endorsing.
- phmqk76 3y agoCollege was sold to us as a way to enter a rarified sector of the job market, and that’s not as true as it once was, and was never as true as it was sold. But a college education is tremendously important for our democracy to exist in any meaningful way. An educated citizenry is crucial, irrespective of whether that translates to wealth (by the way, it still does translate to higher wealth over a lifetime).
- insane_dreamer 3y ago> a college education is tremendously important for our democracy to exist in any meaningful way this was the original purpose of college (and what liberal arts colleges still attempt to do today); but at some point (maybe starting in the 70s?) college became a place to get the skills necessary to enter the job market, until now it's basically become a prereq for almost any job that's not minimum wage so basically an extension of HS -- serves no real purpose but companies require the piece of paper so you have to have it. (Yes there are exceptions -- tech, professional sports, acting -- but only if you are supremely talented at a young age, or very lucky, and therefore for the very very few.)
- phmqk76 3y agoThat function of colleges is still very much alive. As part of being an accredited college with accredited programs, most kids are required to take courses in the liberal arts, even for science degrees. And a college education is a very strong indicator of a person’s support for fascism in America as opposed to our democratic norms. Still a very worthwhile endeavor that should be more accessible to more people financially.
- EchoChamberMan 3y agoGood thing Peter isn't interested in democracy! > Thiel explained in a 2009 essay that he had come to "no longer believe that freedom and democracy are compatible" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_Thiel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_Thiel
- kwar13 3y agoNotable alumni: https://cointelegraph.com/news/ethereum_founder_awarded_100k_thiel_fellowship https://cointelegraph.com/news/ethereum_founder_awarded_100k...
- text0404 3y agoalumnus, from a decade ago, who had already done the big thing they're notable for.
- meroes 3y agoI’m get the feeling Thiels of today won’t make any history books. College gives you a way to learn about the people history deemed important, and learn from them. If making more money is your goal, then Thiel’s advice is probably good. But it is a one or the other. You won’t have time at your startup for that.
- doubloon 3y agoUS college requires you to understand the enlightenment roots of American democracy. Something that Thiel is fundamentally against
- hbarka 3y agoJoin the military. There are plenty of modern opportunities, you get to serve your country, and tuition is free.
- EchoChamberMan 3y agoHopefully you come back alive!
- consumer451 3y agoThiel's program is an embodiment of the Texas GOP platform from 2012. > Yes, you read that right. The party opposes the teaching of “higher order thinking skills” because it believes the purpose is to challenge a student’s “fixed beliefs” and undermine “parental authority.” https://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/answer-sheet/post/texas-gop-rejects-critical-thinking-skills-really/2012/07/08/gJQAHNpFXW_blog.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/answer-sheet/post/texas... https://www.forbes.com/sites/johntharvey/2012/07/01/texas-gop-platform/?sh=8496cd5666da https://www.forbes.com/sites/johntharvey/2012/07/01/texas-go...
- mapster 3y agoCollege is a maturing process intellectually. The thinking one does during this time is crucial. It’s not just about getting a J.O.B. Thiel has another agenda, maybe steering ppl away from ‘liberal ideologies’ because lest we forget he is a MAGA grifter
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- MilnerRoute 3y agoRepublished on MSN... https://www.msn.com/en-us/money/careersandeducation/peter-thiel-s-100-000-offer-to-skip-college-is-more-popular-than-ever/ar-BB1iO8zk https://www.msn.com/en-us/money/careersandeducation/peter-th...
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y agoText-only, no Javascript: curl -si40A "" https://assets.msn.com/content/view/v2/Detail/en-in/BB1iO8zk \ |grep -Eo "\"body\":\".+\"readTimeMin\"" \ |(echo "<meta charset=utf-8>"; sed 's/\"body\":\"//;s/\",\"readTimeMin\"//') > 1.htm firefox ./1.htm links 1.htm links -dump 1.htm