4 ms·
"The Earth is fine": of course, it's a giant ball of rock. A few degrees isn't going to affect it. "~90% of species are fucked": it's not the magnitude of th
by bryanlarsen 3y ago
"The Earth is fine": of course, it's a giant ball of rock. A few degrees isn't going to affect it.
"~90% of species are fucked": it's not the magnitude of the change, it's the speed. The climate is changing on a decades-long time scale, and that's too fast for most species and ecosystems to adapt.
The corollary there is that ~10% of species will be fine, and thrive. Like every mass extinction event the world will look a lot different pre and post-extinction but it will "survive".
Humans aren't fucked. We had pre-industrial humans living in both the Arctic and the Sahara. We adapt the environment to us, and we migrate quickly. If we destroy the environment we can grow food in greenhouses. It'll be crazy expensive, but we'll survive. The speed at which India is currently adopting A/C shows how all but the bottom billion of humans are already adapting to climate change. The bottom billion is fucked, unless the top billion stops whining and starts doing something.
The status quo is fucked. We're a bunch of spoiled brats that think 10% inflation and the end of the world are calamities of similar magnitude. If you want to get a good handle on what true hardship is like, talk to a refugee or a member of the greatest generation. (Do it quick, that means somebody ~100 years old).
Is civilization fucked? It depends on how well it adapts, and what your definition of "fucked" is. (see above).
- lebean 3y agoAs long as the top billion lets the bottom billion develop like they have and use cheap energy, humans will continue to be fine. Good, even.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoThe bottom billion lives on $2 a day. It doesn't matter how cheap energy is, they can't afford it. OTOH your comment does apply to the second billion. There's no energy cheaper than solar power, and solar powered air conditioning is a great supply/demand match.
- mp05 3y ago> unless the top billion stops whining and starts doing something. The most vocal whiners I know still drive a giant 4Runner and get new skis every year. > We're a bunch of spoiled brats that think 10% inflation and the end of the world are calamities of similar magnitude. What's the point of this statement? What solution are you suggesting that will directly lead to inflation? Reduced employment? Carbon taxes? > fucked. fucked. fucked? Lay off the John Oliver.
- bryanlarsen 3y ago> What's the point of this statement? What solution are you suggesting that will directly lead to inflation? Reduced employment? Carbon taxes? Carbon taxes, yes. > > fucked. fucked. fucked? > Lay off the John Oliver. Just echoing the tone of the comment I'm replying to. And they were going Carlin, not Oliver.