3 ms·
It's entirely possible for two opposing sides in a polarized polity to both employ a populist strategy. How you'd see that happening is that the two sides would
by tptacek 3y ago
It's entirely possible for two opposing sides in a polarized polity to both employ a populist strategy. How you'd see that happening is that the two sides would deliberately exclude moderates and centrists.
- leereeves 3y ago> the two sides would deliberately exclude moderates and centrists Which is exactly what's happening lately.
- tptacek 3y agoIf you say so. I'm a moderate (non-progressive) Democrat and feel perfectly at home in the party, but we don't have to agree. The "Democrat vs. Republican" thing is boring, and we won't get anywhere with it. But popularism vs. pluralism is a discussion we can have; there are left-populists to dunk on!
- leereeves 3y agoYou're not a politician so there's no need to for the party to exclude you. Moderates with actual power, like Kyrsten Sinema and Joe Manchin, have been excluded from the modern Democratic party. As Manchin said: "The bottom line is — will the middle speak up? Does the middle have a voice?"
- tptacek 3y agoI don't love the way Twitter treats Sinema or Manchin (Sinema I could take or leave though!) but they are objectively two of the most powerful people in the party. I don't think this is a winnable argument. Look at the 2020 candidate field, and look who won. Look at the track record for Justice Dems over the past 3 cycles. We have a strategy, and it's "win the suburbs". I'm fine with it.
- leereeves 3y ago> they are objectively two of the most powerful people in the party. You didn't hear that Sinema left the party? And Manchin is considering leaving it? That's what I was referring to when I said they were (or at least felt) excluded from the party.
- tptacek 3y agoI'm not even sure if Sinema is really running, and Manchin definitely isn't.
- kevinmchugh 3y agoYeah, I think 2016 with Bernie employing one populism and Trump another one tells this story well. They're more different than similar, to be clear but their pitches had similar shapes. There's an elite, they cause all the policies you dislike, and if we could just engage all the disaffected voters we'd easily get the things we want. For Bernie it was the economic elite preventing expanded welfare programs, especially Medicare For All. For Trump it was a globalist elite preventing nativist policies. It was more obvious in 2020 (with a less complicated, more policy-driven primary) that tons of Democratic primary voters don't want Medicare For All, and that the story as Bernie had told it didn't match the reality on the ground of differing policy goals even within the party's constituents.
- tptacek 3y agoImmediately following 2016, there was a vogue for left populism as a response or corrective to the right populism that carried the election, an idea that "our side" needed to get some of that energy for itself. 2018 was a test of that idea, and it failed pretty conclusively.