4 ms·
Why did you change the title of the article to something entirely different, unrelated, and nonsensical? I wish there were a special type of flag for when peopl
by mattmaroon 18y ago
Why did you change the title of the article to something entirely different, unrelated, and nonsensical? I wish there were a special type of flag for when people do that.
- yters 18y agoHe's poking fun at all the "X ways to Y" posts.
- swombat 18y agoActually, the suggestion came from authentic on the IRC channel: [15:09] < authentic> for HN i would recommend a title of "A List of 1 Way to Get Rich in the Construction Industry (iPhone)" I thought it was a brilliant title for submitting it to HN, and even considered changing the title of it to this article altogether, on the blog itself. However, I decided to keep the original title on the blog and use this title for submitting to HN. As one of the authors of the post, I feel I can allow myself the artistic freedom to pick a suitable title for submitting the article to HN. In practice, it seems the title definitely did what it was supposed to do, so I consider it a good move. Oh, and it is related. I certainly feel that building out the tool mentioned in the article could provide a profitable business to someone. At the moment, we're busy with another part of the construction pie, but if no one else does it within a couple of years, we'll probably have a look at it ourselves. Hence the "way to get rich" part of things. The "List of 1 way" part if obviously poking some fun...
- mattmaroon 18y agoIt just feels like the title is misleading for the purpose of getting clicks.
- petercooper 18y agoThat's why I didn't vote. I felt like the candidates were just campaigning and running commercials to win votes.
- petercooper 18y agoYeah, it's called the "don't vote it up" flag.
- mattmaroon 18y agoThat's not enough for semi-link bait.
- petercooper 18y agoI agree, if the people voting the article up are dimwits who vote things up without reading them. You're smart. You wouldn't have voted it up. But clearly a bunch of dimwits did - it's a sign of bad voting rather than bad submission. The voting system is meant to weed out bad submissions.
- mattmaroon 18y agoWell, actually the article isn't a bad one. It's just misappropriately titled. That's why I would like a special flag so a mod could fix it, though I guess maybe that's too infrequent to warrant a feature.
- vlad 18y agoI disagree. This is a very good change. The real title ("snagging smartphones") isn't good. In fact, it's almost entirely meaningless, and has nothing else going for it other than alliteration. This one is better. Regarding frequency, I actually think this happens pretty often. However, I think each time is a judgement call, and we have a flag link already. After all, if we were not meant to editorialize from time to time, Paul Graham could have the yc news script take the title of the web site.
- mattmaroon 18y agoNot necessarily. A lot of sites don't put the article title in the html title unfortunately. Most do, but enough don't that you have to have that feature there. Also, lots of them put extraneous crap after it, like the website's name and some descriptive text. I feel like flag is the nuclear option, when what's called for here is a surgical strike. I probably think too much about this stuff though.