4 ms·
Emergence of stone-tool use behavior in a population of common macaques
- fuzzfactor 3y agoThese might be some uncommon macaques right here.
- nullserver 3y agoRare or even legendary.
- tetris11 3y ago> During the COVID-19 curfew, however, tourists were not allowed to access the island, and monkeys began to face food scarcity. This can't have been the first time these monkeys have experienced food shortage. I know we had a bioengineering boom in the 50s, and probably a lot of animals have been eating well for the past few decades because of that... but I wonder if the behaviors of the monkeys with tools and crows dropping nuts is something that often happens with animals during the down period where crop yields aren't doing so well, and then they revert back to scrounging when they are. I guess we had luck that the tools we developed during our own shortages in the past could be used to kill and enslave other animals. Let's hope the crows and monkeys aren't taking notes.
- hyperthesis 3y agoNecessity is the mother of invention. Humanity's greatest creation is therefore manufactured scarcity, through marketing, mortgages and competition.
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y agoThere's definitely scarcity if you look around. Check out the housing and infrastructure in Nigeria. About ~2B people globally are in that situation or worse.
- flandish 3y agoRight. Also it’s a manufactured scarcity. The too brass of this capitalist system we working class suffer under could clearly fix house scarcity.
- gcau 3y agoHow? By hugely cutting down immigration?
- BenFranklin100 3y agoHouse scarcity is caused by restrictive zoning laws that limit or even outright ban the construction of new homes in high demand areas. It has little if anything to do with capitalism. The main supporters of restrictive zoning are homeowners who oppose new homes in their neighborhoods. See Katherine Einstein, “Neighborhood Defenders’. http://tinyurl.com/mr394vbe http://tinyurl.com/mr394vbe House scarcity is a result of too little capitalism, not too much.
- idle_zealot 3y agoNIMBYs are incentivized to restrict zoning to preserve the value of their capital.
- BenFranklin100 3y agoYou’re equivocating on the terms ‘capital’ — the monetary assets required for a business to provide goods and services— and a ‘capitalist system’ — an economic system in which the means of production and distribution are privately owned. Neither of these terms have much to do with restrictive zoning. A more precise statement is that NIMBYs support public municipal regulations that preserve and/or increase the value of their private assets, i.e. homes.
- adrianN 3y agoI don't think zoning is the problem in Nigeria, but I know little about Nigerian politics.
- hinkley 3y agoIsn't it macaques that adopt guard dogs as well?
- card_zero 3y agoI seem to know this factoid too, but it looks like it's just an echo from an old story about baboons living on a Saudi garbage dump among dogs. https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/animals-and-us/201507/baboons-might-kidnap-puppies-not-pets https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/animals-and-us/20150...
- hinkley 3y agoAh. I had a “was it macaques or baboons” moment and Google failed me. There’s a theory that dogs domesticated us almost as much as we them. It centers on why the whites of our eyes are so big. It would be interesting to see an uplift saga with baboons or macaques that relied not on Doctor Moreau style medical interventions but on selection and domesticated animals. But then I’m also a weirdo who thinks birds use tools. I maintain that structure building counts as a tool. Particularly the ones who weave baskets.
- card_zero 3y agoI once argued for dinosaurs using stone tools, in the form of gastroliths. So what if the tool is only held internally and manipulated by the stomach, why does that not count? But here I'm really questioning the meaning of "tool" and use. I think it's all very debatable, even with apes, especially when you get to the part about what you're trying to imply by observing the animal uses tools. (The mirror test is similarly sketchy in meaning, being passed by certain tiny fish but not by dogs.)
- hinkley 3y agoDogs understand “look at that” which some think is why you can see our sclera. Enhances nonverbal hunting communication. Some monkeys do not understand meaningful glances or pointing. We also know crows and wolves can mutualistically hunt. Crows narc and then collect the leavings. Maybe crows didn’t used to be as smart as they are either…
- diebeforei485 3y agoI find it fascinating that 15 of the 17 were males.
- Modified3019 3y agoThere was another study looking at gender differences in tool use linked on the page: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21905061/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21905061/ In that one there doesn’t seem to be any clear difference in took use occurrence or skill between genders, though their were differences in what they used tools on, and the size/weight of the tools.
- BlueTemplar 3y ago"and mostly solitary" Is this a species where young males get kicked out of the tribe (especially when food scarcity) while young females do not ?
- begueradj 3y agoI have read, in the past, the case of an orangutan who learned to spear fish with a stick as local fishermen do: https://www.newyorker.com/tech/annals-of-technology/orangutan-learns-fish https://www.newyorker.com/tech/annals-of-technology/oranguta...
- wjholden 3y agoI have a small pet theory on animal usage of tools: perhaps animals are watching humans and have learned from our example. In the past, people believed that no animals used tools. We now have countless examples of animals using tools in clever ways. So our ancestors were completely wrong, right? Well, perhaps the truth is in the middle: perhaps biologists of yesteryear didn't observe animal tool usage because it was less common at the time.
- junon 3y agoPerhaps primates might fit this theory, but cockatoos making spoons to fish out seeds from fruit whilst entirely isolated from human contact means it's not a learned behavior and is more clever deduction (birds are smarter than most people think). Not a biologist though (simply a parrot and monkey lover).
- ben_w 3y agoPerhaps, but also there were fewer biologists in yesteryear, and they didn't have access to a cheap and convenient supply of semiconductor golems with unblinking eyes and perfect memories to watch the birds while the researchers were doing other things.
- Viliam1234 3y agoThen why didn't animals learn from our ancestors already? In the past, progress was slower, they had plenty of time.
- int_19h 3y agoFor one thing, only some very specific animal species use tools, and then in specific ways that you need to observe closely to notice. But also, what makes you believe that our ancestors didn't notice? In ecosystems where they observed that, it might have been so routine and obvious to them that it was not something even worth noting. After all, historically, humans have treated animals similar to people for a very long time (e.g. putting them on trial for theft and murder). When you already have that mindset, a tool-using animal is very unremarkable.
- leobg 3y agoThey may still catch up with us. The way it’s going with social media and internet addiction and LLM hallucinations, maybe they actually do have a shot. :)