No. If the feature requires 10 commits and only 9 are universally agreed on then under this model you would merge 9 commits. Those 9 commits, despite doing noth

No. If the feature requires 10 commits and only 9 are universally agreed on then under this model you would merge 9 commits. Those 9 commits, despite doing nothing, would have agency and real estate in the code. There's nothing that says that 10th commit will even get merged if it's so controversial. To be frank, PRs are almost never universally controversial. It's the details that make them controversial, so this outcome is likely more often than not.