9 ms·
Why Writing by Hand Is Better for Memory and Learning
- veunes 3y agoI think it depends on the way your brain is remembering. Like there are types of memories specific to the sensory modality. For people who have visual memory more developed, I think, writing by hand is better way for remembering.
- palata 3y ago> Like there are types of memories specific to the sensory modality. My understanding was that this was a myth... what's important is to actively pay attention, which seems to be the point here: "It’s very tempting to type down everything that the lecturer is saying, [...] but you don’t process the incoming information. [...] But when taking notes by hand, it’s often impossible to write everything down; students have to actively pay attention to the incoming information and process it [...]". So it's not directly the fact of writing with a pen on a piece of paper, but rather the fact that it makes people "actively pay attention".
- lupire 3y agoWorrying about how to compress the data in real time doesn't seem like a good way to pay attention. Maybe jotting down reactions helps maintain attention. Actually paying attention, and writing down things you want to follow up on later so you don't have to hold them in memory seems better than both superficially stenographozing on a computer or trying to compress for handwritten notes. I suspect that writing helps by letting you forget, not helping you remember.
- vladms 3y agoI think what could make the difference is the process of selection "what is important to me to compress". If you know something already you can skip writing it. If you heard an interesting idea you should write it in a way you would understand it the easiest later. For me, not all notes taken by people on exactly the same course were as understandable, because everybody did some "reinterpretation/selection" - which for me could be a proof of some intricate processing. If you want to follow up later, well, I think that's a different use-case - not related to focusing on the topic (also important but in other circumstances)
- palata 3y ago> Worrying about how to compress the data in real time doesn't seem like a good way to pay attention. Well the whole point is that you should only do it if it actually helps you pay attention. If it is a distraction, then of course you should not do it. I guess typewriting tends to generally be more of a distraction. But again, if it turns out that typewriting is the best way for you to learn, feel free to do it!
- russdpale 3y agoNothing beats a pad and pencil.
- victor106 3y agoIn my kids school it's iPad and Apple Pencil. Great products.
- 2Gkashmiri 3y agoI understand the "appeal" of writing by hand but here is the thing. I am told when I was a kid, I started to have a dispensation for writing with my left hand but mums being mums "corrected" me to use my right hand. This is one theory but I have never enjoyed writing by hand. I just suck at it. I remember all my school life was like "improve your handwriting". Covid gave me an interesting experience. I had a short exam, like 2 hours during the time and I opted for " remote proctoring". Suddenly, for the first time in my life I was like "now its my time to shine" I learned to type from when i was a kid because my handwriting was a physical disability and with typing, I could simply wish that problem away. This has progressed in my professional career where I can just type for hours at end comfortably but I cannot write my name in block letters on a form. I ask one of my coworkers to do it for me. (Its that bad)
- opwieurposiu 3y agoAnyone had success with improving a kid's handwriting? My son's writing is 2/10. I myself am only 3/10. With reading and math I am able to help him. I have not found anything effective for penmanship.
- gorango 3y agoJust have to use the pen(cil) more. Make it fun: drawing, lettering, doodling - it all translates to handwriting itself.
- wccrawford 3y agoA teacher and my parents both tried to improve my penmanship by forcing me to write page and pages of letters. My handwriting got worse each time. So I don't recommend that. I think you have to want it to improve, and to value it. And then you have to practice with that in mind. At that age, I was unable to see a reason to improve it, and it was a lot of work, so I didn't put any actual effort into it beyond that torture they were putting me through. (It hurts my hand to write.) Lately, though, I've considered finally improving it. I think improving it will involve re-learning how to hold a pen and move my arm/hand while writing. They way I do it is basically guaranteed to produce bad results, and I should approach it more like art than utility. That all said... I still haven't found the energy or resolve for it. Good luck!
- lylejantzi3rd 3y ago> A teacher and my parents both tried to improve my penmanship by forcing me to write page and pages of letters. This is a decent tactic if, like you said, you want to improve your handwriting. You have to want it. You have to go slow and form the letters perfectly every time so you develop that muscle memory. I printed pages of a single letter in the font I wanted to imitate and traced the letters. It's a great activity to do while you're sitting in front of the TV. edit to clarify: the decent tactic is to re-learn how to form your letters IF you want to improve your handwriting. DO NOT force your kids to do so. It will be counter-productive because they won't focus on forming the letters. They'll speed through it to get it done and wind up with worse handwriting than before. As wccrawford and I both said: You have to want it.
- sowbug 3y agoAnyone else remember less from reading an ebook compared to a physical one? This happens to me, and I think it's a similar explanation. I recall less of where I read something in an ebook. But in a physical book, I often remember that a phrase was at the top or middle or left side of a page, or that I was sitting in a particular chair when I read it. There's simply more of the brain working when I read a physical book, much as handwriting needs more of your body than typing.
- mapreduce 3y agoThis absolutely happens to me. Happy to know I'm not the only one. > But in a physical book, I often remember that a phrase was at the top or middle or left side of a page, or that I was sitting in a particular chair when I read it. Exactly! And for reasons I cannot explain this helps me with better recall too! Like when I remember something I read, I know roughly where in the book that stuff was physically printed and what other stuff were around it and how they relate to each other. With ebook too I still know how things relate to each other but the clarity feels much less. I can see it much less in my mind's eye. I don't know why! And it drives me mad!
- makeitdouble 3y agoIf that lack of spaciality bothers you, you could try reading ebooks on a bigger format. Using a 13" ipad or Surface, or another tablet/reader for instance allows to have two pages side by side (or one A4 full page) which is pretty close to the physical book format.
- lupire 3y agoThat's still only 2D, not 3D navigation
- makeitdouble 3y agoWas reacting to the "I often remember that a phrase was at the top or middle or left side of a page" part. In particular for technical documentation, having a vague memory of how the page looked like and where in that page the information is IMHO tremendously useful to get back quickly to the relevant parts. I personaly see less use of feeling the weight of the book or the physical artifacts (even for the position in the book, the ratio on the scroll bar is to me a good enough replacement).
- makeitdouble 3y agoThis reads like the usual beat about students taking notes in school. As usual the title and article conclusions are wide reaching, while the study itself is only done in a very limited context on a very specific scope. Precedent variations: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24714990 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24714990 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27810632 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27810632 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37909756 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37909756 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8760392 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8760392 PS: Is there so much research just to counter cursive getting removed from school requirements ? What is the reason for so much focus on such a seemingly limited subject when there's basically no research on professionals using keyboards instead of pens.
- andrew-dc 3y agoThere is another important angle to all of this that I have discovered: I began writing/journaling several years ago by hand and have off and on kept up the habit. For me personally, the experience is enjoyable and therapeutic, given my day job is 100% on a computer. (I'm also an illustrator (focus on traditional, rather than digital) so I naturally nerd out on pens, paints, ink, paper, etc. Illustrating with analog tools also has a similar effect as writing.) I have found that I very easily enter flow state writing, for whatever reason. More importantly, I recently felt inspired (HT to the late Humphrey Carpenter's excellent biography of Tolkien, who wrote to his kids a ton) not just to write for myself, but to write to my sons. This has given my writing even a greater purpose, as I want to give my thoughts (I'm not some profound thinker or such rubbish) and encouragement to my boys when I may not be around (not just in death, but even not near them). I want them to hear and remember the goofiness, and some of the things that went unsaid, or may have been missed, to apologize for my own failings, to really know how much I love and am proud of them. And I want them to not feel alone and discouraged in this world. That sort of stuff. I don't believer there would be anything wrong with typing things to them, however It feels like actually holding a thing that my dad held, and seeing his lines, scribbles, ramblings, bad spelling and stuff...but meant for me...would be really meaningful.
- screenoridesagb 3y ago[dead]
- softfalcon 3y agoI was late to this game of "going backwards" to improve my memory and understanding of what I read and wrote. Being raised by two technologically forward engineers, we jumped on the palm-pilot/laptops/tablets/phones/e-readers bandwagon very early. 5 years ago I started turning back to calligraphy, fountain pens, and hand writing. I buy books and fill up my bookshelf. It wasn't just for the memory recall, it was the pleasantness of writing. I can't begin to tell you just how wonderful it is to write with a nice fountain pen. This was the culmination of writing instruments prior to the bastardization caused by modern cheap pens/pencils. I heartily recommend folks pick up an affordable Parker pen or similar and try it. It's also a great stress reliever to just free form thoughts onto a page, and you'll remember what your wrote later in the day! One other bonus, your handwriting improves. I had to fill out some government forms recently. The online forms were cutting off any addresses longer than 24 characters, so I filled it out by hand. Went into the offices to submit and after the clerk saw my papers they went, "oh my goodness, you have incredible handwriting!" Besides the learning, recall, etc, there are so many side benefits. Read and write physically y'all!
- ambrose2 3y agoVery interesting! Is there a particular Parker model you’d recommend?
- abdullahkhalids 3y agoEveryone's hand and preferences are different. Just look at a guide like this [1] and buy one within you budget. You will eventually learn what works for you. [1] https://www.jetpens.com/blog/The-Best-Fountain-Pens-for-Every-Budget/pt/368 https://www.jetpens.com/blog/The-Best-Fountain-Pens-for-Ever...
- softfalcon 3y agoFor Parker's, there are just so many options. However, it can be extremely pricey to buy-and-try or your local store may not have many in stock. I started with the Parker 51 by trying out a clone by name of Jinhao 51A. My suggestion is to look for the knock-offs like Jinhao and buy a few of them (you can get 4-5 pens for the price of the cheapest Parker). Then you can try them all and whichever you like most, when you choose to upgrade, buy that variant of Parker it was trying to clone. Or maybe the Jinhao ends up good enough for you and you stick with that, nothing wrong with a nice affordable pen! Also, the Jinhao's make pretty gifts for small occasions, they're very colourful and elegant, if you upgrade away from them, can gift them to friends/family.
- tombert 3y agoI think I need to actually read the studies for this, because this has been completely contrary to my personal experience on this. I'd like to see how they're controlling their variables. I cannot read my own handwriting anymore, so I almost never write anything by hand now, but when I was in college the first time I took notes by hand in a notebook, and later moved to typing on a laptop. I don't feel like I retained appreciably less information when I was writing by hand, BUT I did have the ability read my notes later, in addition to being able to search and index them easily. Additionally, I type a lot faster than I can write by hand so I was able to write down more detailed notes during lectures. Now, obviously, college-age Tombert was 18-20, not a young child, but I still do school, and I still pretty much exclusively type my notes. I've found that the utility of using Obsidian to be able to try and figure out ways in which things are connected is just as valuable to me. I'm not a complete idiot; it's possible that I'm actually not learning as well, but I really have no desire to go back to physical notes. ETA: I would like to point out, I've always resisted the urge to simply transcribe what the instructor is saying. I always try and summarize/break-into-bullets, because I feel like the summarization is part of the learning process; reading the article it looks like a lot of people typing notes are just larping as stenographers, which I would agree is a terrible way to actually learn.
- nemo 3y agoThe study's questionable, and at the very least not universally generalizable. My handwriting is so bad notes are pointless typically, and I avoid hand writing anything so far as possible since writing is painful as well as pointless. I do not learn better taking written notes, I've tested this, personally I've tried it a few times and always found hand writing notes actually hinders my learning - I associate the subject with needless pain and busy-work. I have spent time working out how to most effectively learn news things. Associating the learning with something you enjoy is critical, I hate physical writing, it can only hinder learning for me.
- uptownfunk 3y agoYou don’t even need a fountain pen for it to feel nice, for me there are many nice needle point pens at a decent thickness 0.5+ that have a great feel to them. That and a nice Japanese paper notebook like hobonichi and the like and you’re in for a good time
- uptownfunk 3y agoI rarely end up reading what I write or take down in notes it’s mostly a form of recitation for me, what did I remember and how did I structure it in my brain -
- xjay 3y agoWriting by hand implicitly involves a delay which is another factor to consider. With the modern typewriter and rectangular light bulb, you may have to explicitly slow down to soak the information, in this hypothetical scenario.
- Zambyte 3y agoBetter for memory doesn't necessarily mean better for recall. I think if high fidelity recall is your goal, it is best to assume your memory is flawed, and create artifacts to account for that. The product of writing by hand is useful, but relatively clumsy next to a lot of computer-based note taking systems. Hyperlinking and backlinking are gold when it comes to note recall, and you can't really get that with handwritten notes.
- cannonpr 3y agoAs someone with dysgraphia (more info here: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dysgraphia https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dysgraphia), I often find the discussion about handwriting both amusing and sometimes disheartening. I understand that handwriting may help some people learn better, but I have found many other effective learning methods. It was liberating when I first managed to get my school teacher to accept printed homework. I'm not keen on articles that label handwriting as the "best" method, mainly because I believe there are many other equally valid approaches.
- dguest 3y agoI'd go a bit further: for those who have terrible handwriting (or spelling, or both) typing has played a big role in landing an education or job. Before modern word processing it was much harder for these people to be taken seriously. I don't doubt that writing by hand can be very useful to many, maybe even most people, but it's not for everyone.
- chenxi9649 3y agoI wonder if it also had to do with the fact that handwriting is slower. Which means that you generally hold the concept in your working memory for longer than typing. Which often times does not require the concept to be held in working memory at all because typing speed matches reading speed. I also wonder if looking down at the page as you write vs looking up at the board. Constantly looking up and down is like a high frequency spaced repetition game, whereas the latter is a more motor/mechanical practice.
- alok-g 3y agoI too wonder the same thing. In addition to holding the concept in working memory for longer, writing being slower also leads to better refinement of the ideas as you write as the brain has more time to process the thought being written down.
- chenxi9649 3y agowhat do you think is the difference between "being in the memory for longer" and "more time to process the thought"?
- alok-g 3y agoI perhaps wrote it suboptimally; sorry about that. I meant the brain having more time to process the thought and thereby also actually processing it to refine it by connecting the dots better with the existing knowledge & understanding by recalling the latter too into the working memory from the long-term memory, as well as perhaps the working memory creating a stronger stimulus for the long-term memory to record better. As an abstraction (which would not match how this actually works in the brain), merely having/holding a thought constant in the (working) memory for longer before transfering it to the long-term memory should not by itself lead to a better long-term memorization and recall, nor to a better understanding of the concepts involved. It could at best strengthen the working memory itself. Please let me know if I misunderstood your question, if I am failing to answer it, and/or, if you think my understanding posited is not correct, accurate or complete. Would be happy to learn back and/or discuss further.
- zharknado 3y agoThe only conclusion that seems even remotely supported by the evidence here is that writing by hand is important for learning letters. As in, learning your ABC's. No arguments there. The new study cited is a Norwegian small-sample-size study of college kids typing vs. writing Pictionary words while wearing an EEG. Not learning, I would point out. What they observe is more connectivity between brain regions when they write, because well, writing and uses more of your brain. And then they make this immense leap to, "and it seems like the connectivity we see when people learn, ergo it's good for learning." Then Scientific American amplifies it because it's a divisive non-falsifiable thing that people (like me, admittedly) get weirdly invested in. This is bad science and bad science comms. Show me how you decided that this connectivity pattern was evidence of learning when observed in a non-learning context—that's the crux of the issue. I suspect you can't "see" learning of the type that college kids do in an hour-long EEG session. It unfolds over days, months, years.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hot_gril 3y agoI learned to read the Armenian alphabet a few years ago, and writing actually didn't help at all with that, reading did. What I did was try my best to read passages and have the English transliteration underneath as a cheat sheet. Despite not knowing much vocab, I learned the alphabet quickly this way. Then vocab helped later on because it made words more recognizable.
- janeskie 3y ago[flagged]
- dthedavid 3y agoIn university I noticed that some of my classmates just sat there and didn't take notes. So I stopped as well. I sat there, listened and then took pictures of the blackboard. This method worked better for me and I noticed that I performed better. The lesson here is that people learn in different ways.
- andy-eye-candy 3y agoThis was key for me as well. I tried doing transcription style notes on my computer (I'm a fast typer), and I tried doing deliberate handwritten notes. When I first started actually paying attention without noting I learned so much more
- MSFT_Edging 3y agoTo extend this further, most of my math notes in college were done with a wacom tablet and a note app, xournal. this worked better for me than an ipad because I was able to keep my eyes up, my small laptop screen right below the whiteboard in the front. I was able to handwrite, but also adjust scale to make tiny annotations or large diagrams. I could also use built-in tools to quickly make perfect straight lines for graphs, change the background to lined, graph, blank, or a pdf, insert images, etc. Then I was able to export notes as pdfs for classmates, retaining the speed of handwriting for non-text notes but also having the digital usefulness and never forgetting a notebook.
- StefanBatory 3y agoI have similar feelings on this. I took notes only if I felt it was quite important. I could either listen to lecture or take notes by hand, but not both.
- 1auralynn 3y agoYeah the more auditory learner types don't need to take notes. If I try to do this as a visual learner I'm like "yeah yes OK I get it!" then completely forget what the lecture was about 30 min later. If I just take like two- or three-word notes, especially placed around some kind of diagram, it allows me to remember a little bit of what was said (and, more importantly, be able to look it up).
- begueradj 3y agoGreat article. I was wondering where I read the same idea weeks ago, and I found it: https://www.psychiatrist.com/news/handwriting-shows-unexpected-benefits-over-typing/ https://www.psychiatrist.com/news/handwriting-shows-unexpect...
- diyojen 3y ago[dead]
- jtrn 3y agoProperly controlling for "time spent with material" is obvious confounding variable. I doubt this effect is real.
- jtrn 3y agoTime spent on material...
- Unfrozen0688 3y agoI have nioticed this but I never do it. I feel dumber and dumber. I never read anymmore.
- taejavu 3y ago> She notes that children who have learned to read and write by tapping on a digital tablet “often have difficulty distinguishing letters that look a lot like each other or that are mirror images of each other, like the b and the d.” Not saying the broader claims of the article aren’t without merit, but the sentence quoted was true long before ubiquitous touchscreens (mid 90s, and long before then too I imagine)
- dang 3y agoRecent and related: Handwriting but not typewriting leads to widespread brain connectivity - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39364576 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39364576 - Feb 2024 (191 comments)
- joehogans 3y agoIn conclusion, let's craft impactful notes, whether written or unwritten. Delve deeper into the topics you're learning and summarizing.
- tonetegeatinst 3y agoI handwrite almost all my college notes except for a few select classes. While it defiantly helps with learning....I have diagraphia and it makes learning so difficult....and iv recently been informed via my doctor I might have diacalculia as well and I might want to get tested. I really only have 1 downside when it comes to hand written notes....it is not easily searchable compared to text files, and it can be much harder to take notes when their is diagrams or a math problem where the teacher is skipping steps.... This means I really need to go find a second hand review via a video to ensure I know what's going on