3 ms·
> got a totally bonkers result they couldn’t anticipate. I fundamentally disagree with this statement and frankly the entire line of reasoning This isn’t some
by Havoc 3y ago
> got a totally bonkers result they couldn’t anticipate.
I fundamentally disagree with this statement and frankly the entire line of reasoning
This isn’t some unforeseeable 3rd order side effect coming out of a black box from left field.
You’re always injecting an instruction to put in diverse people so now it’s always doing just that. Entirely predictable.
This is like adding a system prompt saying always put tamagotchi into the picture and then being puzzled by why a request for a dog painting includes an inappropriately present tamagotchi. Like wtf did you think would happen?
- troyvit 3y agoI agree with you that it's entirely predictable. Why was it not predicted by a company that has achieved hegemony over so many aspects of our online lives and therefore must be pretty good at stuff? Other people offer: * google drove their head up their own ass * actually they expected this behavior, but didn't think there would be backlash * google didn't scope for the normal consumer but rather for their managerial class I'd say that the first and third items are close to the "result they couldn't anticipate" reason. The second reason sounds google-ish, but they're also trying to win in a market where they're behind, so is their blindness to real humans that deeply institutional?
- almatabata 3y agoSome people are saying people knew internally but didn't dare point it out: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39466135 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39466135
- Tiktaalik 3y agoAlso probably * everyone is in such a rush to get to market that they didn't test it well.
- Tiktaalik 3y agoYes. It was a hilariously bad solution to a real problem. The problem was that their training data yielded outcomes that weren't a representative sample of reality. They didn't try to solve that problem. Instead they just tried to put their thumb on the scale to compensate.
- Havoc 3y agoYes - that seems like a good summary of root cause. This problem needs to be fixed at data level. ...admittedly a challenging proposition so I can understand why everyone is trying to "fix in post" via prompt