2 ms·
I don't like that they happened either, but they were continuously getting leaflets dropped on them by the Americans telling them their cities were going be bom
by ben_w 3y ago
I don't like that they happened either, but they were continuously getting leaflets dropped on them by the Americans telling them their cities were going be bombed, told to surrender after the first nuke, and nearly had a coup after the second in order to prevent their surrender.
And developing their own nukes at the same time.
- tonetegeatinst 3y agoYou are correct on this. They were given plenty warning and even after the war they tried to coup
- hef19898 3y agoThe people who got the warnings, average people in the cities, were not the ones who tried a coup. Nor were they ij charge of anything...
- ben_w 3y agoThe people who were in charge, criminalised possession of the letters the Americans were dropping, and those who attempted the coup to continue fighting were from the leadership (not top level, but they did have a lot of support in aggregate). This isn't to justify civilian casualties, it's only and entirely that the people with the power to surrender were given the opportunity to do so and made aware of the reason to do so well before the nukes actually exploded, and decided they preferred to fight.
- hef19898 3y agoFascinating reading of the timeline. And it does sound a tad like justifying the bombing of civilians, nukes or fire bombing doesn't matter here, for something the leadership does.
- ben_w 3y agoI'm blaming the Japanese leadership for not surrendering sooner (though given the coup attempt, I'm not sure if they would've been capable of surrendering). My opening line was "I don't like that they happened either", and the reason for that is civilian deaths are bad — I reject "total war" as a concept, and I see the Allies use of this in WW2 as having all the moral weight of a child in a playground saying "the other guys did it first" (and not just because I moved from the UK to Berlin about 5 years ago and get to see all the museums, archive footage of bombed-out apartments, and that the house building process still today includes "we have to check for unexploded munitions"). The point is that, even in with the benefit of hindsight, it seems to me that this much force was actually needed to make some very arrogant leaders stop their war. Also, we can and should learn from hindsight, which suggests e.g. that Hitler's remilitarisation of the Rhineland could have resulted in a coup against him if the French had sent in (IIRC) "a dozen soldiers with bayonets". I presume there were also other missed opportunities in the Pacific theatre, though I don't know them.
- hef19898 3y agoAgree, except this bit: >> The point is that, even in with the benefit of hindsight, it seems to me that this much force was actually needed to make some very arrogant leaders stop their war. None of the leaders actually cared a single bit, the Nazis even wanted to burn down Germany for having lost the war. Industrial output was not really impacted, numbers and assessments from both sides show that, while moral of the bombed was actually stiffened. Including Axis POWs in Normandy being debriefed (understandable, if someone bombs my house and family I do not nexessarily like them much). All the strategic bombing of Germany did was satisfy hunger for revenge (especially in the case of Bomber Harris, whom seemed to be extremely butt hurt after the Blitz), despite knowing strategic bombing doesn't do much after the Blitz. That, and showing Stalin that the Western allies did something on the continent. The only time strategic bombing had some impact in Europe, was the preparation of Overlord, when Eisenhower basically forced US and UK bomber commands to focus at logistical networks, hubs and oil installations above cities. And even then, civilian casualties, including in France and the Low Countries, were way to high for the results. Again, USAAF and RAF assessments show that. And yet the bombing of civilians continued unabetted. There is simply no defending this.
- actionfromafar 3y agoNow we are getting somewhere interesting in the discussion. What the Japanese High Command is not automatically determining if it was morally right or wrong to drop the bombs. The Japanese almost coup could have been driven by other concerns than yet-another city turned to ashes, by nuclear or conventional fire. (To spell it out: "let's surrender to the Americans before we have to surrender to the Russians" vs "fight to the end and bring down as many enemies with us as we can".)
- FpUser 3y ago>"but they were continuously getting leaflets dropped on them by the Americans telling them their cities were going be bombed" "But there was never any specific warning to the cities that had been chosen as targets for the atomic bomb prior to the weapon’s first use. The omission was deliberate: The United States feared that the Japanese, being forewarned, would shoot down the planes carrying the bombs. And since Japanese cities were already being destroyed by incendiary and high-explosive bombs on a regular basis — nearly 100,000 people were killed the previous March in the firebombing of Tokyo — there was no reason to believe that either the Potsdam Declaration or Truman’s speech would receive special notice" -[0] [0] - https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/five-myths-about-the-atomic-bomb/2015/07/31/32dbc15c-3620-11e5-b673-1df005a0fb28_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/five-myths-about-the...
- dralley 3y agoAll that means is they warned more cities than they needed to.
- FpUser 3y agoI am curious why weasels take people for an imbeciles?
- hef19898 3y agoBy all definitions, including papers written by both, RAF Bomber Command and the USAAF at the time, deliberate bombing of enemy cities and civilians was a) a crime and b) didn't produce a meaningful effect on enemy moral or warfighting capabilities.
- thehappypm 3y agoAre you arguing hiroshima and nagasaki did not impact the Japanese warfighting capabilities?
- hef19898 3y ago