3 ms·
Hiroshima fallout debris linked to first solar system condensates
- brabel 3y ago[flagged]
- dTal 3y agoBad? Yes. "By far the worst war crimes ever committed by any nation"? In war which also featured the holocaust, not even close. You must have anticipated this response?
- tonetegeatinst 3y agoI suspect they must have...I mean this has to be bait.....it has to be or its just straight up ignorance of what went down in ww2
- dTal 3y agoIf bait, it's very effective. 13 comments on this article and all replying to this hyperbolic sideshow.
- tonetegeatinst 3y agoAgreed. Unfortunately no further interaction from the person...seems like they want to just drive discussion or create discord.....who can say but them at this point
- brabel 3y agoI have a life and was not around... but yes, I am glad there's a discussion, though as usual, people defend their ancestors horrible decisions with the same tired, proven false, arguments. No surprise though. If you think it would be ok to drop a bomb on Moscow today to force Russia to surrender in the current war, or for Russians to do the same on Kyiv (just imagine how many lives will be saved by stopping the ground invasion, right!??), then you're just using the same rationale as the people defending the Americans' horrible crime. Tell us: do you support one of those?! If not, why not???
- brabel 3y agoWell, of course I did. You think the Holocaust was a war crime?? It was not! It was happening regardless of war as far as I understand the Germans motivations. Yes, it may be an even worse crime (though I would argue that because it happened over many years - you need to take that into account - the Americans would probably kill the full Japanese population if they had not surrended, given enough time), but not a "war crime". They were not killing Jews to force them to surrender or something... they were trying to exterminate them in Europe simply because of their ideology. The Allies were not fighting to protect the Jews either, mind you. No one really knew the extent of the gas chambers at the time, and I suspect a lot of people in the Allies countries didn't actually mind much anyway - given just how racist their own societies were at the time (I hope I don't need to remind you how blacks/asians and even Italians were treated in America in the 1930's).
- 15155 3y agoHow many of those same people would've lost their lives during a ground invasion of Japan?
- ejb999 3y agomany more - plus hundreds of thousands of USA soldiers as well fighting a battle they didn't need to.
- hef19898 3y agoI'd like to see some sources dor those numbers. Also, Japan was ready to surrender, nukes or not.
- ben_w 3y agoThe number of people involved in the Kyūjō incident even after the second bomb, suggests the nation was probably not ready to surrender before then. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kyūjō_incident https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kyūjō_incident
- hef19898 3y agoOh, wow, some hardliners weren't happy and tried a coup. That failed. Obviously representative for the overall leaderahip and the nation at large. And a perfectly fine reason to bomb civilians...
- ben_w 3y agoNo. That's not the reason to drop the bombs, you need much more than that to reach such a conclusion. 18,000 rebels on one side tried pick a fight with 25,000 government soldiers to prevent a surrender even after the second city had been levelled, is a reason for thinking that Japan was still only borderline ready to surrender at that point, and therefore that it was unlikely to have been ready before this point.
- actionfromafar 3y agoYou gotta say "some of the worst" or you fail on a technicality right out of the gate. Humanity has been fighting to produce the worst war crimes since ever and displays no particular signs to give it up any time soon.
- tonetegeatinst 3y agoThis exactly. I can agree that using those nukes was many questionable. Who can truly say if lives were saved from a land invasion. So much is classified and what ifs. But it is far from the worse war crime.....
- dTal 3y agoThey said "by far" the worst, which is pretty much opposite to your point. If we soften it down to "dropping nukes was pretty bad", it becomes a boring and uncontroversial comment with no punch, and we wouldn't have a huge pile-on of a comment chain discussing it.
- actionfromafar 3y agoEhm, yes? :) What you said.
- roenxi 3y agoI think the comment at the thread root is just wrong then (although the downvotes seem excessive). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_massacres_in_China https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_massacres_in_China alone seems to have a couple of worse crimes than the atomic bombs; the Chinese are an old civilisation with reasonable record keeping.
- tonetegeatinst 3y agoI mean don't forget the red army is according to scholars...mostly responsible for the mass raping during the occupation of Germany. Or when Germany was split into two, the Russians refused humanitarian aid in the form of food for the German people who starved. Or the Japanese military that experimented on people...and then got away with it and managed to find jobs that's to operation paperclip.
- lm28469 3y agoOr when the US killed 30k+ Iraqi and never found a single weapon of mass destruction
- dralley 3y agoThat's not exactly true, we found old ones (that we knew they already had), what we didn't find was any production of new ones.
- tonetegeatinst 3y agoTechnically we never went to war since ww2....which is kinda insane to think about
- lm28469 3y agoJust a few little special military operations ™ (but good ones don't worry)
- ben_w 3y agoI don't like that they happened either, but they were continuously getting leaflets dropped on them by the Americans telling them their cities were going be bombed, told to surrender after the first nuke, and nearly had a coup after the second in order to prevent their surrender. And developing their own nukes at the same time.
- tonetegeatinst 3y agoYou are correct on this. They were given plenty warning and even after the war they tried to coup
- hef19898 3y agoThe people who got the warnings, average people in the cities, were not the ones who tried a coup. Nor were they ij charge of anything...
- ben_w 3y agoThe people who were in charge, criminalised possession of the letters the Americans were dropping, and those who attempted the coup to continue fighting were from the leadership (not top level, but they did have a lot of support in aggregate). This isn't to justify civilian casualties, it's only and entirely that the people with the power to surrender were given the opportunity to do so and made aware of the reason to do so well before the nukes actually exploded, and decided they preferred to fight.
- hef19898 3y agoFascinating reading of the timeline. And it does sound a tad like justifying the bombing of civilians, nukes or fire bombing doesn't matter here, for something the leadership does.
- ben_w 3y agoI'm blaming the Japanese leadership for not surrendering sooner (though given the coup attempt, I'm not sure if they would've been capable of surrendering). My opening line was "I don't like that they happened either", and the reason for that is civilian deaths are bad — I reject "total war" as a concept, and I see the Allies use of this in WW2 as having all the moral weight of a child in a playground saying "the other guys did it first" (and not just because I moved from the UK to Berlin about 5 years ago and get to see all the museums, archive footage of bombed-out apartments, and that the house building process still today includes "we have to check for unexploded munitions"). The point is that, even in with the benefit of hindsight, it seems to me that this much force was actually needed to make some very arrogant leaders stop their war. Also, we can and should learn from hindsight, which suggests e.g. that Hitler's remilitarisation of the Rhineland could have resulted in a coup against him if the French had sent in (IIRC) "a dozen soldiers with bayonets". I presume there were also other missed opportunities in the Pacific theatre, though I don't know them.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 3y agoI would say the Rape of Nanking by the Japanese was worse than Hiroshima and Nagasaki. If I was forced to choose I would have definitely chosen to be in Hiroshima or Nagasaki and endure the atomic bomb and the after effects than I o be in Nanking and endure days of sadistic torture (babies tossed in the air and bayoneted, brothers forced to rape sisters, gang rape, sexual mutilation, etc).
- dralley 3y agoIt's not even the worst war crime of WWII much less all of history.
- fragmede 3y agooh. they're saying that fallout debris from Hiroshima looks like stuff right after the solar system formed
- actionfromafar 3y agoIt's almost poetic in a frightful kind of way: "city materials (concrete, iron and aluminum alloys, industrial glass and soil) were vaporized and mixed with sand, Ota River water and the atmosphere to produce the various glasses" Edit, related - how do elements get created: https://medium.com/lessons-from-history/the-six-billion-year-story-of-how-earth-got-uranium-cf14c243d2c4 https://medium.com/lessons-from-history/the-six-billion-year...
- tonetegeatinst 3y agoWell I wonder if were seeing these kinds of formations due to the extream conditions that result from nuclear detonation. I wonder if a fusion bomb would create a similar result....because I know most attempts at modern fusion reactors are using lasers to create extreme temperatures and pressure via controlling condensed plasma
- DeIonizedPlasma 3y agoYou know we tested fusion bombs as early as the 50s? They've been around quite a while. Also, very few reactors use lasers. The laser system at NIF is actually entirely meant to physically emulate what fusion bombs are like without having to build one and set it off. Reactors typically use magnetic fields instead of lasers, because the approach is much more scalable to things like power generation.
- jtc331 3y agoThe title here is pretty confusing.
- mannykannot 3y agoYeah - saying 'linked' is not helpful, maybe something like 'resemble' would be more informative. On the the Elsevier ScienceDirect page for the paper itself, there is a 'highlights' summary: • The Hiroshima glasses are condensates produced by the Hiroshima nuclear explosion. • The wide silicon kinetic fractionations in the Hiroshima glasses can only be explained by condensation. • In Hiroshima glasses, oxygen mass-independent fractionations resulted from chemical reactions during condensation. • A scenario was established to describe the formation of the Hiroshima fallout. • The Hiroshima glasses can be considered an analog of the first condensates of the solar system. (My apologies if I am inadvertently reposting an LLM-generated summary, but it looks reasonable to my nowhere-near-knowledgable eye.) https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0012821X23004867?via%3Dihub https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S00128...