4 ms·
It turns out you can make it all the way to become president of Harvard [1] while ignoring this rule so it is questionable whether it is as set in stone as you
by the_third_wave 3y ago
It turns out you can make it all the way to become president of Harvard [1] while ignoring this rule so it is questionable whether it is as set in stone as you make it out to be, at least in certain disciplines.
In a way these models are a perfect mirror of the current academic climate. They plagiarise without remorse, they follow the latest identity-politics diktat to a point and make up 'facts' when needed to reach a desired narrative. Google Gemini is the latest example [2] of where this leads.
Given that it is plausible that models like these will soon be used in educational settings this is a recipe for disaster. The same goes for the trend to replace search engine results with 'interpreted' results in which LLMs take up the same role as Winston in 1984: Winston works in the Ministry of Truth where he alters historical records to fit the needs of the Party.
It is time for a decentralised distributed search engine which limits itself to pure search, something like YaCy [3]. Something to replace Winstonian search engines like Google and Bing (et al.).
[1] https://www.campusreform.org/article/claudine-gay-is-a-dei-hire-lacking-intellectual-credentials-critics-argue-/24451 https://www.campusreform.org/article/claudine-gay-is-a-dei-h...
[2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39465255 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39465255
[3] https://yacy.net/ https://yacy.net/
- the_third_wave 3y agoInstead of pressing that down-vote arrow in yet another attempt to grey out a dissenting opinion it would be interesting to hear what you have to say. If you do not agree with any of the facts I stated - plagiarism being rampant in academia, LLMs doing the same, identity politics ruling the roost in places like OpenAI and Google - where the lead of the Gemini project is a political activist against 'white privilege' [1] - and the near-certainty that LLMs will soon play a large role in education as well as 'content discovery' - just state what you consider to be the truth. [1] Speaking in a keynote address in 2021 she openly suggests that she treats “Black, Hispanic and Latinx” employees differently from white employees, she insists Google’s commitment to “antiracism” is a key component of their AI work from which they won’t be deterred, she was caught on hidden camera implying that 'Google will do what it can to prevent Trump from winning again', etc. Treating people differently based on race is called 'racism' and as such it is punishable under criminal law.