2 ms·
> Even if the hot fuel could not be refined for weapons, it still wouldn't be something you could just buy or get though eh? Eh. Nuclear reactors are expensive
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
> Even if the hot fuel could not be refined for weapons, it still wouldn't be something you could just buy or get though eh?
Eh. Nuclear reactors are expensive because of regulatory requirements, not physics. It's not that hard to get natural uranium. If you're a criminal who just wants fission byproducts and doesn't care about NRC approval, you could make one without too much trouble. If you had some basic knowledge you might not even kill yourself.
> For instance, can you name a chemical that will be any MORE expensive to clean off something you want to keep than a mixed radionucleotide soup? Even HF or FOOF should be way easier.
HF or FOOF might not be that easy to remove now that the thing you're trying to clean it off of has been dissolved by acid or vaporized in the resulting explosion. It is in general hard to clean something after it has ceased to exist.
> But I'm not sure they would cause less fear than exploding a bunch of mixed 'hot' radionuclides in a crowded area.
I hate to quote FDR so maybe we should use the example of the English during The Troubles.
If you allow yourself to be terrorized, you let the terrorists win. People are afraid because the media and politicians tell them to be afraid because they're manipulating you just as much as the terrorists are, for their own purposes. Anyone caught doing this should be regarded as committing an act of betrayal and condemned as a coward attempting to capitalize on a tragedy.
> Also worth burning various media offices to the ground probably, but good luck getting any group of people to agree on whose eh?
You don't actually have to burn down their offices. Just stop watching them and at scale they'll fail.
- lazide 3y agoOkay, but at the point you're refining your own Uranium and building your own breeder reactor, you're also at the point you're likely making your own intermediate (or even intercontinental) range ballistic missiles no? And then you're more visible/have more of a footprint, and it's a lot harder to get under the radar. And perhaps you'd even have something more useful to do with your life - or at least you'd have something you'd be hesitant to lose in retaliation. Same as if you're able to build your own airplanes, you don't need to hijack any. But also, if you can hijack an airplane to do what you want to do - why bother going to the effort of building your own? And as for the other points - I've never been worried about Hamas or personally cared to watch Fox News - and it's been decades. I also stopped reading/watching any general news several years ago. So why are they not only still there, but have caused a lot of damage since? And made a lot of money? No man is an island. And no matter how mentally healthy someone in Stalingrad was, they were still in for a world of hurt between '42 and the '60's, eh? And if you refuse to use a tool against someone who will not hesitate to use it against you, guess what tool they'll eventually end up using all the time?
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> Okay, but at the point you're refining your own Uranium and building your own breeder reactor, you're also at the point you're likely making your own intermediate (or even intercontinental) range ballistic missiles no? Gosh no. Rocket science is legitimately hard to the point that it's a cliche. Getting some elements to do physics together when you don't care about regulatory requirements is pretty much just a matter of putting them near each other and hoping you used enough shielding that it won't kill you. > So why are they not only still there, but have caused a lot of damage since? And made a lot of money? Because other people watched them, of course. Everyone has to do their part by turning off the fear-mongering talking heads. You can't stop other people from doing it, but you can stop doing it yourself, and so could they. > And if you refuse to use a tool against someone who will not hesitate to use it against you, guess what tool they'll eventually end up using all the time? The one that makes everyone hate them. It is not possible to defeat evil by doing evil. You only become that which is to be defeated.
- lazide 3y agoUh huh. Yet, every nuclear power was at exactly at that point right at the same time, and had roughly the same success level (working reactors and rockets). And the Nazi’s were destroyed by…. Hugs? And not firebombing, machine gunning, etc. most of Western Europe? Let me know when you care about reality more than the illusion. Some things, it's an existential threat - and existential threats like that tend to only be resolvable with by death or complete subjugation of one side or the other.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoAnd then the United States, having won the war using Hugs, disbanded the military industrial complex and threw the One Ring into the volcano, which is why the country is now so beloved in places like Iran and South America. Notice how we were talking about terrorists and you had to switch to WWII to actually find an existential threat, and yet once you normalize these measures they become routine. Even the term "national security" was meant to imply this -- something critical to the security of the nation, that could cause it to fall to an enemy. How is this applicable to the War on Terror? Was the United States ever at risk of surrendering to bin Laden and disbanding Congress in favor of a Caliphate? It was not, and yet "national security" was the justification for every evil act committed in the name of fighting evil. If you're weaker than someone else and you can win without fighting dirty, you're clever. If you're stronger than someone else and you can't win without fighting dirty, you deserve to lose.