3 ms·
It's the second sentence of the abstract: "Current AI models are already automating away the livelihoods of some artists, actors, and writers." OpenAI's chart
by esafak 3y ago
It's the second sentence of the abstract:
"Current AI models are already automating away the livelihoods of some artists, actors, and writers."
OpenAI's charter says:
"OpenAI’s mission is to ensure that artificial general intelligence (AGI)—by which we mean highly autonomous systems that outperform humans at most economically valuable work—benefits all of humanity."
https://openai.com/charter https://openai.com/charter
So they are going to develop software that can outperform humans, for less money... Of course people are going to lose their jobs. That's your disempowerment. They're making good on that part. Now we're waiting for the second act where they're going to show us how it magically benefits all of humanity, including the newly unemployed horde.
- ActionHank 3y agoA vital part is implied, but not stated - these companies own the novel solutions to training and running the models and they likely own or will own the hardware it runs on. Without these things the rest of the world, even large corporations, will not be able to compete.
- codethief 3y agoI think this is a great point. If AI becomes much better at certain tasks than humans, this will devalue human labor and cause a power shift towards AI companies which will act as gate keepers. I mean, let's face it, AI is not going to get democratized (at least not the state-of-the-art stuff – that one will always be under tight control). And even if models and hardware schematics were public, the average Joe would still not know what to do with that.
- Legend2440 3y agoPeople made this argument every time a new thing gets automated, and so far they've been completely wrong. Job loss is temporary, the gains from cheaper/better/faster production are permanent.
- mitthrowaway2 3y agoWe've had machines that outperform humans at some tasks, which has always shifted value onto other tasks that human workers could do which machines could not. We've never had a machine that could "outperform humans at most economically valuable work". At some point, there is a finite limit to human capabilities, and it has never in history been reached, so there is no historical example to draw on. We do have a historical examples for horses, though, which was reached somewhere between around 1900 and 1920.
- incrudible 3y agoFarming used to be most economically valuable work until it was not. OpenAI is not even close to producing anything as valuable as farming equipment. If we need jobs, we will create them, do not worry about that, see David Graebers work on the topic.
- Legend2440 3y agoPeople aren't horses. Horses were just a tool, and we found a better one. The economy exists to serve us, not us the economy.
- mitthrowaway2 3y agoHorses are animals, not tools, but they found an economic role through their labor. Hopefully humans fare better, but as far as the economy is concerned, the difference between horses and people is that horses don't have money to spend; their owners did, and once tractors became available they no longer saw fit to spend that money on horses. The economic role of unemployable humans would depend on how much purchasing power they have access to through means beyond their labor. Economic theory makes no guarantees about that.
- swatcoder 3y agoPrior to industrialization, there wasn't much affordance in commumities for fully idle people. Give or take toddlers and people troubled by striking physical or mental disabilities, everybody had social duties (i.e. work) and played some role contributing to their community. Even most aristocrats and nobles that lived on the backs of othes's labor had community obligations of some kind. Now, though, we aim society towards 5% of people who want to work not having some opportunity to do so, while doing some paperwork magic to exlude an order of magnitude of other non-workers from that measure. Meanwhile, we recognize widespread depression and anxiety that makes sense in a society where most people have no clear, constructive community obligations to give them direction and we struggle to reconcile liberal ideas of universal life, liberty, and happiness with the intuitive collectivist expectation that everybody should be chipping in (even when they have no opportunity to do so). One can argue it's all been worth it, or that it's surely the road to some future utopia, but "completely wrong" is maybe not the right word choice for the opposing view.