5 ms·
Horeshoe theory [1] is one of the most interesting viewpoints I've been introduced to recently. Both sides view censorship as a moral prerogative to enforce th
by echelon 3y ago
Horeshoe theory [1] is one of the most interesting viewpoints I've been introduced to recently.
Both sides view censorship as a moral prerogative to enforce their world view.
Some conservatives want to ban depictions of sex.
Some conservatives want to ban LGBT depictions.
Some women's rights folks want to ban depictions sex. (Some view it as empowerment, some view it as exploitation.)
Some liberals want to ban non-diverse, dangerous representation.
Some liberals want to ban conservative views against their thoughts.
Some liberals want to ban religion.
...
It's team sports with different flavors on each side.
The best policy, IMO, is to avoid centralized censorship and allow for individuals to control their own algorithmic boosting / deboosting.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Horseshoe_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Horseshoe_theory
- stared 3y agoYes and no. I mean, a lot of moderates would like to avoid seeing any extreme content, regardless of whether it is too much left, right, or just in a non-political uncanny valley. While the Horseshoe Theory has some merits (e.g., both left and right extremes may favor justified coercion, have the we-vs-them mentality, etc), it is grossly oversimplified. Still, a very simple (yet two-dimensional) model of Political Compass is much better.
- echelon 3y agoI think it's just a different projection to highlight similarities in left and right and is by no means the only lens to use. The fun quirk is that there are similarities, and this model draws comparison front and center. There are multiple useful models for evaluating politics, though.
- crashmat 3y agoI don't think there are any (even far) leftwanting to ban non-diverse representation. I think it's impossible to ban 'conservative thoughts' because that's such a poorly defined phrase. However there are people who want to ban religion. One difference is that a much larger proportion of far right (almost all of them) want to ban lgbtq depiction and existence compared to the number of far left who want to ban religion or non-diverse representation. It says on the wikipedia article itself 'The horseshoe theory does not enjoy wide support within academic circles; peer-reviewed research by political scientists on the subject is scarce, and existing studies and comprehensive reviews have often contradicted its central premises, or found only limited support for the theory under certain conditions.'
- echelon 3y ago> I don't think there are any (even far) leftwanting to ban non-diverse representation. Look at the rules to win an Oscar now. To cite a direct and personal case, I was involved in writing code for one of the US government's COVID bailout programs, the Restaurant Revitalization Fund. Billions of dollars of relief, but targeted to non-white, non-male restaurant owners. There was a lawsuit after the fact to stop the unfair filtering, but it was too late and the funds were completely dispensed. That felt really gross (though many of my colleagues cheered and even jeered at the complainers). > I think it's impossible to ban 'conservative thoughts' because that's such a poorly defined phrase. I commented in /r/conservative (which I was banned from) a few times, and I was summarily banned from five or six other subreddits by some heinous automation. Guilt by association. Except it wasn't even -- I was adding commentary in /r/conservative to ask folks to sympathize more with trans folks. Both sides here ideologically ban with impunity and can be intolerant of ideas they don't like. I got banned from my city's subreddit for posting a concern about crime. Or maybe they used these same automated, high-blast radius tools. I'm effectively cut out of communication with like-minded people in my city. I think that's pretty fucked. Mastodon instances are set up to ban on ideology... This is all wrong and a horrible direction to go in. It doesn't matter what your views are, I think we all need to be more tolerant and empathetic of others. Even those we disagree with.
- asddubs 3y agothis comment reminds me of that "did you know good things and bad things are actually the same" tweet
- echelon 3y agoI'm sorry, but censorship and partisanship are not good things. Both sides need to get a grip, start meeting in the middle, and generally let each be to their own. Platforms weighing in on this makes it even worse and more polarizing. We shouldn't be so different and disagreeable. We have more in common with one another than not. The points of polarization on each end rhyme with one another.
- asddubs 3y agoThat wasn't my point. My point is that equating bigotry with efforts to counteract bigotry is stupid and disingenuous. I don't really think many people actually want to ban non diverse representation anyway, so the premise already doesn't work, but even still, targeted malicious discrimination is not the same as misguided but well meaning policies. And meeting in the middle between "i hate gay people" and "i don't hate gay people" is morally bankrupt.