4 ms·
A peek at Intel's future foundry tech
- riv991 3y agoI really hope Intel succeed here, not because I'm a massive Intel fan, but we need some competition
- rdl 3y agoCompetition is great, but also in this case geographical redundancy; having the entire world depend on chips produced in one of the world's most likely military hotspots is terrifying. Still pretty amazing that there's basically one global top-tier chip supply chain, with hundreds of companies, some of which are sole-source at the scale of 6-12mo+. ASML is as much a bottleneck as TSMC.
- tromp 3y ago> ASML is as much a bottleneck as TSMC. A bigger one, since all of TSMC, Samsung, and Intel rely on ASML. It could be many years, if not decades, before ASML gets some serious competition.
- baq 3y agoAt least if all ASML fabs gets blown up, the existing equipment will still be functional for a few years...
- 15155 3y agoWhere will this existing equipment be operating if an EU nation has a critical piece of infrastructure "blown up?"
- Fronzie 3y agoAnd ASML relies on Zeiss, which is as big a bottleneck as ASML and TSMC.
- tomxor 3y ago> ASML is as much a bottleneck as TSMC. Yes, this is _one_ of the reasons I think TSMC is fairly safe from doomsday theories like China trying to cut it off from the world. Because that would risk it being cut of from ASML, and they are unlikely to be anywhere close to making their own machines before grinding to a halt. Short term, it's mutually assured fabrication destruction; Long term, the world needs more redundancy and competition in both areas.
- hardware2win 3y ago>like China trying to cut it off from the world. Because that would risk it being cut of from ASML, and they are unlikely to be anywhere close But... arent they already cut from ASML? US disallowed ASML to sell advanced tech to China
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- The_Colonel 3y agoChina bought a lot of ASML equipment before the sanctions + they can still buy the less state of the art equipment.
- mnau 3y agoAt this time, US sanctions cover even NXT:1980Di (Netherlands will be soon pressured to do the same). That is from 2016 and is least advanced DI ASML still makes.
- daveguy 3y agoI think the idea was that China cutting off TSMC would prevent TSMC from accessing ASML fab tools and maintenance, which would quickly degrade TSMC capabilities. Edited to specify China as the one who would potentially cut off TSMC from the rest of the world, which would also cut off ASML->TSMC.
- 3y ago
- ysofunny 3y agoI think it a testament to the collectively perceived value of semiconductors. I'm saying IMO no matter where in the world the fabs were that place would be a military hotspot. the miltary hotspotness will follow the top of the line fabs additionally, I take it as evidence of the perceived value that people gone to great lengths to avoid widespread proliferation of this techniques because scarcity is a value amplifier. so by keeping it scarce its value increases. so if I'm correct, if/when there are multiple comparable fabs in multiple parts of the world the geopolitical risks should go down in taiwan finally, having typed it out, I feel my whole argument is wrong...
- hnfong 3y ago> I think it a testament to the collectively perceived value of semiconductors. Taiwan has been a subject to threat of invasion for a long time before TSMC was a thing. A short while ago Intel had the best fabs and CPU chips. Nobody thought another country invading USA was plausible. > so if I'm correct, if/when there are multiple comparable fabs in multiple parts of the world the geopolitical risks should go down in taiwan No. Taiwan has for decades been a point of geopolitical tension between powers around in Pacific (which currently is US and China). The existence of TSMC makes the rest of the world care more (or scared more), but the PRC isn't just going to give up its decades long goal of taking over Taiwan because there's another TSMC somewhere else (or even in mainland China).
- raccoonDivider 3y agoThe US might have less incentive to support Taiwan though. They've never really committed to defending it.
- babypuncher 3y agoI feel like it would be a lot harder for China's military to target a fab in landlocked Arizona than one in an island nation 100 miles off the coast of Xiamen.
- monocasa 3y agoWe're going to get that. We only have a handful of nodes left, so every geopolitically relevant region is scrambling to have last leading edge fabs on their soil for defense use cases if nothing else. My guess is that US, China, and Taiwan will all have essentially equivalent fabs, Korea and the EU will have what look like cheaper versions until everyone figures out that they don't have the yields the promise and so it's actually more expensive but propped up by .gov money (even more than the first group). I wouldn't be surprised to see another one shared by Brazil, India, South Africa (and maybe Russia) that kind of works, enough for low volume defense projects.
- Solvency 3y agogrowing up, I remember visiting and touring AMD in high school through some youth technology summit. It felt like AMD were these tiny little Davids against this absolutely enormous Intel goliath. How did the dominance ratio shift so dramatically?
- bee_rider 3y agoThe switched to fabless which let them focus on the part they do well.
- hardware2win 3y agoIve invested in them 1yr ago and as the time is passing Im feeling more and more confident that it was really good bet Im excited and cant wait to see next 3 years
- blopp99 3y agoThat's a great username, do you have another hardware investments you've made?
- hardware2win 3y agoI invested in AMD around 95 levels, but I started selling them on recent tops around 175-180 to buy more INTC when they dropped after their guidance for Q1 It is not that I dont believe in AMD, I just believe that their growth potential is lower than INTCs. Foundry businsss is crazy and has waaay higher entry level
- j_walter 3y agoWhat is your cost analysis on Intel's foundry arm? If AMD can support high profits using TSMC as a supplier...who also has high profits, why do you think Intel can compete on price and make good money?
- hardware2win 3y agoWell, it is not like they arent aware of it. They were pretty open about this on some earning calls and how do I see it? I see it as room for improvement and maybe some kind of potential edge over duos like amd+tsmc
- j_walter 3y agoI see TSMC and Intel cost structures all the time...they run fabs very differently and the costs are no where near close to each other. When running a foundry the main component of being competitive is price and yield. Intel will struggle with both...mark my words.
- throwaway4good 3y agoWho will be Intel's customers? Will Intel compete with them?
- throwaway4good 3y agoApple - hardly. AMD - no. NVDIA - maybe. Qualcomm - probably.
- signatoremo 3y agoThe answer will be: All of them, plus Microsoft, Amazon, Google. TSMC and Samsung can’t meet the demand of those companies. If Intel can be TSMC’s customer then surely AMD can be Intel’s customer, so is Apple. Intel’s foundry business is structured to be separated from its processor business
- throwaway4good 3y agoI listed TSMC's biggest customers - and really AMD using Intel foundries? You cannot be serious. The assumption is that there is going to be a lot more demand. Even after cutting China out which is like 1/3 of global demand. The assumption is that will be driven by AI, mostly in data centers. Could be. Otherwise Intel foundry services will face an uphill battle vs. TSMC.
- signatoremo 3y agoAgain, Intel is a fierce competitor to TSMC, yet they are also TSMC’s customer. AMD will be the same to Intel if they can’t secure enough volume from TSMC. TSMC’s revenue is like 70 times of Intel’s foundry business. Intel only plans to leapfrog Samsung by the end of this decade. What Intel aim to lead is the process. They plan to introduce 18A by the end of this year, followed by 14A. China will not be cut off from the global market, only at the very high end. Nvidia just recently showcase their latest chips to Chinese market. They will continue to be a main driving force along with the US.
- rjzzleep 3y agoWorth remembering that the US had been pressuring TSMC and Samsung to hand over more and more trade secrets to qualify for the Chips act subsidies[1]. Unless they massively screw up with the hand they have been dealt, it's very likely that this will be a serious competitor moving forward. [1] https://asiantechpress.com/ked-global-us-forcing-tsmc-samsung-chipmakers-to-hand-over-business-data.html https://asiantechpress.com/ked-global-us-forcing-tsmc-samsun...
- sgift 3y agoThe trade secrets in question seem to be yield and inventory numbers according to the article. Certainly interesting, but not sure how this helps Intel with their foundry business?
- synergy20 3y agointel has an over promise under deliver trust problem for the last 10 years though
- gradschool 3y agoSome details about cooling these devices would have been informative in either the article or the white paper. All I know is that my crummy consumer-grade Intel processor thermally throttles almost instantly under load despite a bulky liquid cooling block on top of it. What breakthrough is going to enable a closely stacked ensemble of them to perform acceptably without overheating?
- ajross 3y ago> All I know is that my crummy consumer-grade Intel processor thermally throttles almost instantly under load That's... the design. You have a boost clock and a sustained clock spec, and the latter is what you're guaranteed to get "under load". Usually it will do better with most parts and cooling solutions (note that the motherboard regulator hardware matters too!), but the load performance will always be "throttled". Basically you've just misunderstood. This isn't the 90's and clocks aren't fixed things. It's impossible to treat your criticism without numbers.
- ooterness 3y agoIt's not just the cooling block; little things like rough surfaces, voids in the thermal paste, or too much thermal paste can make a huge difference in the cooling performance. Tech Ingredients has some detailed discussion in the linked video ~28:20 regarding surface preparation and paste application. (Lasers not CPUs, but the principles are the same.) https://youtu.be/9VmITd0dKAo?t=1700&feature=shared https://youtu.be/9VmITd0dKAo?t=1700&feature=shared
- Night_Thastus 3y agoWithout knowing the load and what the frequency looks like over time, it's very hard to say if this is incorrect or normal behavior. As others have stated, modern Intel and AMD chips essentially boost as hard as the cooling solution will allow to eek out that last few % of performance.
- ChrisArchitect 3y agoRelated news to this: Microsoft Will Use Intel to Manufacture Home-Grown Processor https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2024-02-21/microsoft-will-use-intel-to-manufacture-home-grown-processor https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2024-02-21/microsoft...
- signatoremo 3y agoWorth mentioning that the Microsoft processor will be made on 18A process. That means Intel is confident they can start offering it to their customers by the end of 2024 as planned.
- j_walter 3y agoWhy would that mean they are confident? You always get customers ready before the technology is ready...you think TSMC doesn't have 2nm customers lined up already?
- signatoremo 3y agoI’m not privy to the details of the contract between Intel and Microsoft, but such explicit mention of the technology usually means there are financial penalties if Intel can’t deliver. They wouldn’t commit to it unless they think they can make it work. Who said anything about TSMC?
- tupac_speedrap 3y agoI can't wait for single percent gains over previous generations and Kilowatt TDPs
- bjoli 3y agoSomething happened recently (or maybe not so recently. I am an old fart) with the cooling situation. Previously a beefy air cooler could give you good performance at a low noise level. Now they all sound like jet planes when they try to dissipate 200w of heat. Heck, even my 420mm AIO was struggling with the newer processors before undervolting. With AMDs latest series I have started using eco mode. An undervolted 7900x at 88w ("105w TDP") is at 95% of stock performance and doesn't make a sound with a decent air cooler if you are comfortable with it staying at 85 degrees C when doing work. The single thread performance is the same, and I managed to have a stable boost of 5.8ghz for single core workloads. It compiles code good enough for me, and the occasional Minecraft session is a breeze.
- beebeepka 3y agoIs it a good time to buy Intel stock? I think they have a good chance of scooping a fair bit of AI chip revenue in 5 years or so.
- brucethemoose2 3y agoI think so. But Intel pretty much bet everything AI on Falcon Shores (2025). If its crumby or late, I think it will be difficult for them to catch up. They'll have inference hardware in laptops, sure, but still...
- ein0p 3y agoI’m going to need to see the actual products at this point. The times when we trusted Intel to deliver what it promises ended many years ago.
- wmf 3y agoYou can buy Core Ultra (Meteor Lake) laptops made with Intel 4 so they've finally demonstrably broken out of the 10 nm/7 nm rut.
- ein0p 3y agoYou’d think that “Intel 4” refers to 4nm, and “Intel 7” refers to 7nm, but Anandtech doesn’t think so: https://www.anandtech.com/show/17448/intel-4-process-node-in-detail-2x-density-scaling-20-improved-performance https://www.anandtech.com/show/17448/intel-4-process-node-in... Quote: “Previously known as Intel’s 7nm process, Intel 4 is Intel’s first time using EUV lithography for their chips.”
- wmf 3y agoThis doesn't mean anything if you think deeper. What if the original "7 nm" name was inaccurate and "4" is more representative of the process's performance?
- ein0p 3y agoWhat, and do hear me out on this, Intel 4 is just the invention of Intel’s marketing department aimed to confuse people who don’t know what they’re talking about? Do you think that’s more likely perhaps? Notice how strenuously they avoid any mention of the process node in all their materials.
- wmf 3y agoI mostly agree, but if TSMC and Samsung are "lying" about nanometers... what is Intel supposed to do about that? Just keep punching themselves in the face by underselling their processes? Also see https://fuse.wikichip.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/hp-density-14nm-5nm.png https://fuse.wikichip.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/hp-dens...