4 ms·
I submitted this story 8 hours ago: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3943379 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3943379 It did really well for a time, gett
by ColinWright 15y ago
I submitted this story 8 hours ago: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3943379 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3943379
It did really well for a time, getting 10 votes in fairly quick succession. Then in the space of about 15 minutes plummeted from about 35 in the rankings to about 470. Clearly a few people flagged it, and that was that.
The same story was then submitted 2 hours ago here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3945323 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3945323
That got a solitary upvote, and that was all she wrote.
Now here is the same story, currently number 8 on the Front Page.
Somehow I feel that things really ought to "work better", whatever that means. But having said that, I'm pleased to see the story doing well again, and I've upvoted it.
Again.
His work was fascinating and entertaining, but having read the interviews with him one wonders if he was ever really happy. Makes me hope he's now found the peace that seemed to elude him in his life.
- scott_s 15y agoWith the enormous number of submissions, I think there's just always going to be a large amount of randomness in what makes it to, and stays on, the front page.
- swordswinger12 15y agoWho gives a fuck about upvotes? A guy who was special to a lot of people is dead, give the bullshit a rest.
- ColinWright 15y agoLet me start by saying that Sendak's work was a large part of my childhood and he was special to me too. I wanted to reply privately, by you don't have contact details in your profile, so I'll have to reply to you here ... You may find this hard to believe, but I really don't care about the upvotes. What I care about is this. An article that the general HN community seems to care about had to get submitted three times (at least - there may have been others) and endure flags and indifference before it got noticed and promoted to everyone's attention. It nearly got lost. To me, that's evidence that good items, items I care about, other items that "the HN community" cares about, items that you would care about, are now being lost in the noise. And that's my point, that HN is in some sense "broken," and items like this, about someone who was special to me, and to others, get lost. I hope that helps explain my point. If not, <fx:shrug> I tried. Added in edit: I've had several out-of-band replies from people who clearly feel the way I do about this, so despite the downvotes here expressing disagreement, I feel encouraged that my feeling that HN is "broken" in this sense is shared by others.
- swordswinger12 15y agoI don't disbelieve you, but the way you phrased your original post gave me pause. You wrote 5-6 sentences comparing the different submissions, making special mention that yours didn't gain much traction, then you added a perfunctory-seeming Sendak tribute in the last sentence.
- ColinWright 15y agoThanks for the clarification. Perhaps I should have said "This was submitted ..." rather than "I submitted ..." but that just sounds ingenuous, especially if someone then follows the link and sees it was me. And to some extent it wasn't just the lack of traction. My interests don't exactly align with the majority here, so many of my submissions don't get traction. That I really don't care about. It was the flags, coupled with the obvious "success" of this item that makes me think the voting, karma, and ranking system(s) on HN is/are broken. In this case I mostly noticed because it was my submission and I was paying attention. How much else is there that I care about but never get to see because of these things.