10 ms·

Is it intentional? You think they intentionally made it not understand skin tone distribution by country? I would believe it if there was proof, but with all th

Is it intentional? You think they intentionally made it not understand skin tone distribution by country? I would believe it if there was proof, but with all the other things it gets wrong it's weird to jump to that conclusion. There's way too much politics in these things. I'm tired of people pushing on the politics rather than pushing for better tech.

Workaccount2 3y ago
>I'm tired of people pushing on the politics rather than pushing for better tech. I'm surprised you're not attacking google over this then...
bakugo 3y ago
> Is it intentional? You think they intentionally made it not understand skin tone distribution by country? I would believe it if there was proof, but with all the other things it gets wrong it's weird to jump to that conclusion. Yes, it's absolutely intentional. Leaked system prompts from other AIs such as DALL-E show that they are being explicitly prompted to inject racial "diversity" into their outputs even in contexts where it makes no sense, and there's no reason to assume the same isn't being done here, since the result seems way worse than anything I've seen from DALL-E and others.
robswc 3y ago
I mean, I asked it for a samurai from a specific Japanese time period and it gave me a picture of a "non-binary indigenous American woman" (its words, not mine) so I think there is something intentional going on.
- trackflak 3y ago
  Ah, I remember when such things were mere jokes. If AI 'trained' this way ever has a serious real world application, I don't think there will be much laughing.
- kweingar 3y ago
  I would be very surprised if it said "nonbinary indigenous American woman" considering that nonbinary and woman are different categories
  - robswc 3y ago
    You're right, my mind inserted "woman" to go with the picture: https://gemini.google.com/share/ba324bd98d9b https://gemini.google.com/share/ba324bd98d9b At least it would never make such a heinous mistake like that :)
deleted 3y ago
[deleted]

Workaccount2 3y ago

>I'm tired of people pushing on the politics rather than pushing for better tech. I'm surprised you're not attacking google over this then...

bakugo 3y ago

> Is it intentional? You think they intentionally made it not understand skin tone distribution by country? I would believe it if there was proof, but with all the other things it gets wrong it's weird to jump to that conclusion. Yes, it's absolutely intentional. Leaked system prompts from other AIs such as DALL-E show that they are being explicitly prompted to inject racial "diversity" into their outputs even in contexts where it makes no sense, and there's no reason to assume the same isn't being done here, since the result seems way worse than anything I've seen from DALL-E and others.

robswc 3y ago

I mean, I asked it for a samurai from a specific Japanese time period and it gave me a picture of a "non-binary indigenous American woman" (its words, not mine) so I think there is something intentional going on.

trackflak 3y ago
Ah, I remember when such things were mere jokes. If AI 'trained' this way ever has a serious real world application, I don't think there will be much laughing.
kweingar 3y ago
I would be very surprised if it said "nonbinary indigenous American woman" considering that nonbinary and woman are different categories
- robswc 3y ago
  You're right, my mind inserted "woman" to go with the picture: https://gemini.google.com/share/ba324bd98d9b https://gemini.google.com/share/ba324bd98d9b At least it would never make such a heinous mistake like that :)

deleted 3y ago

[deleted]