3 ms·
I would consider it as being opposed to the Constitution and the Declaration of Independence. Things like the Bill of Rights, separation of church and state, de
by WalterBright 3y ago
I would consider it as being opposed to the Constitution and the Declaration of Independence. Things like the Bill of Rights, separation of church and state, democracy, the President being a civilian, the notion of the inherent rights to Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of Happiness, etc.
- caslon 3y agoOn the other hand, if being anti-indoctrination is the goal, it might be a good idea to turn the same lens toward universities that see an oversized volume of alumni participating in the defense industry, something seen as pro-American (albeit against many of the criteria you list off). Historically, some universities have been extremely fond of propaganda in this regard, going as far as to creating direct pipelines from school to participation, like Caltech's participation in the V-12 program, JPL, or Project Vista. If that isn't indoctrination, I'm not sure what is. Indoctrination isn't bad, and students should be able to have a choice between whether they want to get indoctrinated by the types of people who created the nuclear bomb, if they want to get indoctrinated by hippies, or if they want to get indoctrinated by a church-funded university. Education is inherently ideological, and the market is really leaning toward hippie faculty at the moment. Allowing market forces to do what they will seems fine. It'll come back around eventually, and in the meantime, state school kids are doing what prestigious university students are too good for. Look at Anduril, which is far more impressive a defense achievement than anything that's come out of Caltech since before you were a student.
- WalterBright 3y ago> Allowing market forces to do what they will seems fine Sure. But I draw the line when people try to force their anti-American agenda on people. > Look at Anduril, which is far more impressive a defense achievement than anything that's come out of Caltech since before you were a student. Caltech is a very small university. > Education is inherently ideological My education at Caltech was nearly entirely math, science, engineering, etc. I don't see that as ideological. I did get a palpable sense from the profs that these subjects were exciting. I never heard any defense propaganda from the Caltech faculty, none at all. JPL was there, but not a single soul pushed me to apply for a job there. The only propaganda I recall was my economics professor pushing Marxism, and if you didn't regurgitate his Marxist views on the exams, you received a bad grade. I learned my lesson, and instead satisfied the social studies requirement by taking business accounting - something useful.
- caslon 3y ago> Sure. But I draw the line when people try to force their anti-American agenda on people. This doesn't happen, though; there are a lot of universities that love pro-American sentiment in professors. A university deciding to be anti-American seems fine, and quite American. As an employer, it should be able to choose who it wants to offer positions. No one is forced, they just fail to incentivize prestigious universities in maintaining their employment under conditions they desire.
- wolverine876 3y agoWhat is 'pro-American' and 'anti-American'?
- trollerator23 3y agoWhat's impressive about Anduril? Please.
- addicted 3y agoThen how is suppressing activism, which in its peaceful form is the most threatened expression of the contents of the Bill of rights, as the Mar professors claim to want to do, not “anti-American”. I’m sympathetic to the idea that the university as an institution should maintain neutrality. However, at the same time, individual professors, students, and even administrators should be protected by the university when engaging in speech.
- WalterBright 3y agoThere's nothing un-American about activism. People are free to hold and express whatever beliefs they want. But when they want to force their beliefs on others, by: 1. shouting down anyone with a different view 2. requiring "loyalty oaths" from the staff 3. harassing others who disagree with them 4. trying to block roads and otherwise impede people from going about their business that is anti-American.
- wolverine876 3y agoWhat makes those anti-American? What does it have to do with the US in particular? And who are you to tell other Americans what's American or not? That assertion is what is fundamentally un-American. It's everyone else's country as much as yours. > 4. trying to block roads and otherwise impede people from going about their business That is the fundamental nature of protest, stopping people from going about their business. The whole point is that the issue is being ignored. Suddenly, all protest is suspect in our great democracy.
- WalterBright 3y ago> What makes those anti-American? They infringe on our rights. Do you really believe there is a right to harass others? > What does it have to do with the US in particular? It's the US that has a Constitution, a Bill of Rights, the Declaration of Independence, etc. Of course, any other nation is free to adopt them as well, and become American. > And who are you to tell other Americans what's American or not? I'm an American. I have relatives that fought in the Revolutionary War, the Civil War, WW1, WW2, and the Korean War. In particular, these are my father's opinions, very strongly held by him. I did not earn them like he did in combat, but he's gone now and so I carry on. He told me once that he fought so I wouldn't have to. Never forget that our freedoms were all paid for with blood, lots of blood. > It's everyone else's country as much as yours. Yes. I see people all the time eager to throw away our rights that were so bitterly fought for. The Constitution also has a lot of checks and balances meant to make it difficult to for people to throw it away. > all protest is suspect in our great democracy You can protest all you like. But our freedoms do not include the right to impede other peoples' rights to go about their business.
- diggan 3y agoJust for curiosities sake: So if being opposed to the constitution is anti-american, does that mean that people who submit and support amendments are anti-american too? As the amendment was proposed because a person didn't agree with what is in the constitution.
- wait_a_minute 3y agoThe Constitutition itself supports that process of creating amendments. That is not anti-American.